4 ms·
> polyethylene – a soft, durable and flexible plastic that can now be made with ethanol extracted from sugar cane material and, Lego claims, is as durable as co
by ars 9y ago
> polyethylene – a soft, durable and flexible plastic that can now be made with ethanol extracted from sugar cane material and, Lego claims, is as durable as conventional plastic. As a bio-plastic, it can be recycled many times, though it is unlikely to be 100% biodegradable.
As a bio-plastic? polyethylene? What different does it make if your atoms were cycled through a living plant, or a dead plant in the ground (oil)?
From a chemistry point of view it makes no difference.
This is 100% greenwashing, and it relies on gullible reporters not to call them out on their nonsense.
You can make polyethylene from air. Are we calling it atmo-plastic now?
- typetypetype 9y agoBecause atoms that come from a renewable resource that can be sourced locally are preferred over atoms from non-renewable resources that come from distant lands.
- ars 9y agoWhy? What difference does it make? We don't have a shortage of atoms. From your reply and others I can see why they did this. People actually believe it makes a difference. The environment is doomed. I'm sorry, but if people can't even tell the difference between something that helps the environment, and something that makes no difference, then I don't see how we'll ever make things better.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoThat’s not a very convincing response. It’s like pointing out that electric vehicles are still dependent on fossil fuel power networks for their energy. It’s true, but misses the point that one of the requirements in transitioning to a sustainable economy is decoupling energy production methods from consumption methods. Fossil fuel as the input to a car is bad; fossil fuel as the input to a power plant, that produces electricity that is the input to a car is not perfect, but it is better. Similarly, plastics sourced from biological sources are better.
- ars 9y ago> Similarly, plastics sourced from biological sources are better. What makes them better? Seriously. What is better about cycling them through a plant first? You need hydrogen and carbon to make that plastic. You can get them from anywhere, it makes no difference whatsoever if a plant hold them for a while first. It's energy that matters.
- kaybe 9y agoWaste is important too, in this case notably the gaseous one.
- bllguo 9y agoThis is just absurdly overdramatic and frankly, insufferable. Why do you expect the general public and media reporters to know offhand about polymer chemistry? Why does their lack of this knowledge doom the environment? You had a chance to amicably and clearly educate others about the misleading connotations of the term "bioplastic" and instead you launched into some kind of weird tirade. This is why society needs better science communicators.
- ars 9y agoWeird tirade? It might be tirade, but it's not weird. I'm just tired of people claiming "I'm green", while actually being worse for the environment. > Why does their lack of this knowledge doom the environment? Because people change their behavior based on what they find out. So it looks like legos are now "better" for the environment, because the plastic touched a plant. But not only does it not make a difference, it's actually worse for the environment. It reminds me of when BMW used hydropower to make electricity to each ovens for carbon fiber manufacturing. https://www.alternative-energies.net/bmw-produces-carbon-fiber-using-renewable-energy/ https://www.alternative-energies.net/bmw-produces-carbon-fib... Guess what? That's worse for the environment! Electricity is a very inefficient way to heat things. Save that electricity for where it's needed and heat your ovens with natural gas. Instead someone else is making electricity with natural gas, and the total environmental impact is higher. But then of course BMW doesn't get to falsely claim "we're green". > Why do you expect the general public and media reporters to know offhand about polymer chemistry? I expect the reporter to ask a chemist. Go check and see if Lego's claim holds any water.
- gus_massa 9y ago> Why do you expect the [...] media reporters to know offhand about polymer chemistry? I don't expect that all media reporters have a Ph.D. in chemistry, but it would be nice that they check the information with an expert instead of just copy&paste whatever PR the company sends to them. After all, there should be a difference between a serious newspaper with real journalist and a random dude with a blog...
- kaybe 9y agoI actually support any use of oil that does not include burning it. (within reason) Better make all of it into Lego and then bury it into a landfill when it breaks, if it can be done on renewable energy.
- eropple 9y agoI am not an expert in this area, but polyethylene made from living plants takes rather fewer millenia to sustainably source than polyethylene made from petroleum.
- ars 9y agoWhat?? No. It makes no difference. What matters is the ENERGY. Not the atoms. We have absolutely no shortage of atoms, we have an unlimited supply of those. What matter is the energy inherent in the oil. And I see absolutely nothing in this press release about where the energy comes from.
- eropple 9y agoDo we have an unlimited supply of petroleum and the bandwidth to extract all of it at a reasonable price? Because, last I checked, that stuff is used for a lot of other things that is not "making Legos". Or is this just the "well, if all power isn't green it's just so futile" argument in a fetching hat?
- cf498 9y agoIts about the footprint of the production. The problem here is that prior processes in this field needed alot more input energy and they have relied on conventional power input. They actually had worse footprints despite "producing plastic from thin air".
- eropple 9y agoI understand that part, and I understand opportunity cost. I don't understand the frankly nastily-phrased assertions of "greenwashing"; even if it is currently inefficient due to using additional conventional power, that's not likely to stay the case over time, and I think it's a much longer row to hoe to assert that over a reasonable time horizon it would remain inefficient enough to make it less viable than continuing with current practices. Meanwhile, it looks like Lego-the-company is pretty heavily involved in the development of sustainable energy sources to use and to offset their own power usage[0]. [0] - https://www.lego.com/en-us/aboutus/news-room/2017/may/100-percent-renewable-milestone https://www.lego.com/en-us/aboutus/news-room/2017/may/100-pe...
- mrob 9y agoThere's a difference in that the plant-sourced polyethylene is sequestering carbon from the air. But I agree it's mostly greenwashing, because we don't know the total atmospheric carbon balance over the whole manufacturing process.
- oldcynic 9y agoThe earliest Lego was cellulose, which is biodegradable. They'd do better simply going back to that. Though I'm not sure how cellulose is for longevity.
- quink 9y agoI have some cellulose acetate LEGO bricks. It's no good for longevity. They've all changed colour and deformed a bit in various ways.
- gamblor956 9y agoAs a bio-plastic? polyethylene? What different does it make if your atoms were cycled through a living plant, or a dead plant in the ground (oil)? From a chemistry point of view it makes no difference. There are many types of polyethylene. This particular type used by Lego apparently can be recycled more easily than other types of polyethylene for reasons not explained in the post. As for why it matters whether the plant is living or dead, there is a vast order of magnitude difference in the energy extraction cost from living plants vs finding, drilling, refining, processing, and transporting dead plants. Oil extraction is expensive and the various processes required to extract and use it come with significant environmental externalities. You can make polyethylene from air. Are we calling it atmo-plastic now? Citation needed. As 1/3 of the most common polyethylene molecule is carbon, and 2/3 is hydrogen, you would need some very special air to make polyethylene.
- gus_massa 9y agoTo get Hydrogen, just add some water. Moreover, perhaps you don't need liquid water because air has some water vapor, but I'm too lazy to do the stoichiometric calculation now. Someone already though it: "Exclusive: Pioneering scientists turn fresh air into petrol in massive boost in fight against energy crisis" http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/exclusive-pioneering-scientists-turn-fresh-air-into-petrol-in-massive-boost-in-fight-against-energy-8217382.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/exclusive-pio... [spoiler alert: they use electricity too]