5 ms·
> You can’t make people richer by printing money and just handing it out, tho’ that doesn’t stop governments trying it (quantitative easing being the latest exa
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> You can’t make people richer by printing money and just handing it out, tho’ that doesn’t stop governments trying it (quantitative easing being the latest example).
That actually does work pretty well, because it causes people to spend money. If you had none before and the government prints some and gives it to you, now you have some and can spend it. If you had some before and you know the government is going to be printing more, you want to spend it before the inflation reduces its value.
As long as the things people are stimulated to buy are economically productive, it increases real wealth.
The thing you have to be careful with is combining it with policies that cause people to spend the money on unproductive things. See housing bubble.
- UncleEntity 9y agoI used that argument during my counterfeiting trial, didn't go over too well until I started talking about broken windows...
- thaumasiotes 9y agoCounterfeiting is one way of creating money and is generally unpopular. But making loans is a more mainstream way of accomplishing the same thing, and is in fact often considered to promote growth.
- skookumchuck 9y agoLoans don't make people wealthier. The loans are backed by collateral, and have to be paid back. It is not at all the same thing as counterfeiting.
- notfromhere 9y agoLoads generate lots of wealth if they're used effectively, and great at creating problems if used irresponsibly.
- opwieurposiu 9y agoWe use a fractional reserve banking system. Currently the reserve ratio is 10% for large banks. Therefore when you get a loan, 90% of the money you get from the bank the bank conjured from thin air. Loans are backed by 90% nothing.
- skookumchuck 9y agoLoans are not made to people who do not have collateral. That's what backs them.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoDo you by any chance have a credit card? Furthermore, while there are economic models in which loans are collateralized by goods of value exceeding the amount of the loan, modern American loans are generally not that way.
- skookumchuck 9y agoYes, I do. And my assets will be seized by the credit card company via legal proceedings if I refuse to pay.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoYou've got an odd focus on loan recovery. Issuing a loan creates money where there was no money before. Paying back that loan in the normal way is neutral, preserving the money that was created. Defaulting on the loan and having value recovered, in whole, in part, or not at all, from your property, destroys money.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> Paying back that loan in the normal way is neutral, preserving the money that was created. Actually it destroys the portion of the money that was created. Sort of. The bank doesn't get to keep the principal it originally created, it gets destroyed. But then they're back to having some slack against their reserve ratio, so they can immediately go recreate the money again and loan it to someone else. Which is how banks actually create money, and inflation -- by over time increasing the net amount of outstanding loan principal across all debtors. This is also why it's important to have the government create a certain amount of money -- it's necessary in order to allow people on net to pay down their loans without causing deflation. Or even to prevent people from having to increase their net real debt as the economy expands. And despite all the whinging about QE, the banks are still way ahead on the "average real debt per citizen" front.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoSure, making loans is not the same thing as counterfeiting. However, viewed in terms of effect on the money supply, it is the same thing as counterfeiting. They both increase the money supply.