3 ms·
Shouldn't a distinction be made between asserting this for a population vs. for an individual? Yes, for a population it results in overdiagnosis and over treat
by mhb 9y ago
Shouldn't a distinction be made between asserting this for a population vs. for an individual? Yes, for a population it results in overdiagnosis and over treatment. As a personal decision, though, I understand this and will choose how to proceed with that in mind.
- BeetleB 9y ago>Shouldn't a distinction be made between asserting this for a population vs. for an individual? Yes, for a population it results in overdiagnosis and over treatment. We get overdiagnosis and overtreatment of the population precisely because it is done at an individual level.
- mhb 9y agoRight, micromotives. But what's best for me, personally, may be different than what is best for a whole population.
- astura 9y agoMedicine is individualized. If you have certain risk factors you may benefit from a particular screening tests or even prophylactic treatment and procedures. These should be evidence based too, however. Same when you're having symptoms. The topic at hand is, as stated up-thread, "full body MRI scans for healthy people."
- skybrian 9y agoIt seems possible to do better than average here? Just from reading this article, we learn about some "cancer" that is less scary than it sounds and unlikely to cause a problem. I would be more skeptical if there were a study showing overtreatment still happens in a population informed and wary of overtreatment.
- emiliobumachar 9y agoIt's bad for the individual too. Many checks have non-trivial rates of false positives, many treatments have non-trivial rates of severe complication. Checking occasionally for something specific that's reasonably suspected due to symptoms is good. If you're always checking for everything, you have a high risk of finding something you don't actually have. It turns out that that risk overrides the beneficial chance of finding something real before it has any symptoms.