3 ms·
I suspect that lawsuits like this will show that trying to artificially influence diversity through hiring practices is an incorrect approach. When I'm in a hir
by gwbas1c 9y ago
I suspect that lawsuits like this will show that trying to artificially influence diversity through hiring practices is an incorrect approach. When I'm in a hiring position, it's not like we sit around a table and say, "we'd prefer the white male." We just don't have enough women and minorities in the hiring pool to begin with.
The problem is that there aren't enough women and minorities entering our field. We just can't decide to hire more women and minorities when there aren't any to hire. Getting women and minorities to choose tech as a career isn't something that I honestly don't know how to solve. Ultimately, our employees reflect who's in our hiring pool.
The same happens in other fields, too. In pediatrics, there aren't a lot of men entering medical school, so there is a desire to hire more men.
Anyway, getting back to the original topic; I suspect there's more going on than we realize. I'm curious about how much this reflects Google actual policies versus a decision of a middle manager.
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoI agree with you in general, but I'm curious how many would be "enough"?
- edanm 9y agoSince the US has 10s of thousands of open developer positions which are going unfilled, then purely from a pragmatic "what would help the economy" perspective, a good lower bound on "enough" is "we are able to fill those open positions".
- quotemstr 9y agoThere is no such thing as a labor shortage --- only a mismatch with respect to salary expectations.
- edanm 9y agoThat's kind-of-true, but I think doesn't fit in this case. I mean, let's take a hypothetical world - only one person knows how to program. You could say "there's no such thing as a labor shortage - just a price mismatch, she should be receiving one billion dollars for every line of code". But you could also say "maybe we should teach a few more people programming. And clearly, lots of software wouldn't get written, because its cost would be too high. This is the "same" situation, only a bit more spread out. Maybe those 10k jobs legitimately aren't worth paying more for - that doesn't mean that, if there were more programmers and therefore their salaries would be lower, that software wouldn't be valuable. It's still a good indication that there's lots more to do.
- sincerely 9y ago"enough" of a specific demographic in this sort of discussion usually means "roughly proportionate to that group's percentage of the overall population". this belief is held most ardently by those who attribute the difference in outcomes to societal pressures (as opposed to inherent biological differences). of course this is mainly relevant in the context of an entire field or industry and not a specific company's workforce (although if the company is big enough the lines blur).
- kelukelugames 9y agoA supreme court justice was asked the same question. I don't agree with it completely but think it's an interesting opinion. >Rosen: Why is it good for men—as you said recently, there should be nine women on the Supreme Court … >Ginsburg: No, I didn’t say there should be. The question was when will there be enough, so there’ll be enough when there are nine. >For most of our history, except the times the court was less than nine, and the one time there were 10, they were, until Justice O’Connor, all men. And nobody thought anything was unusual about that. https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/02/ruth-bader-ginsburg-opens-up-about-metoo-voting-rights-and-millenials/553409/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/02/ruth-ba...
- humanrebar 9y agoThe logic there is just terrible. Maybe her point was that even if eight women were sitting, we'd still be considering women candidates for the open seat? If so, it didn't come across in the text.
- akvadrako 9y agoThe way court transcripts read it often doesn't come across as very natural.
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoPerhaps Ginsburg's point was that 9 is definitely enough, but she's addressing what the smallest number for "enough" is?
- humanrebar 9y ago> Getting women and minorities to choose tech as a career isn't something that I honestly don't know how to solve. A lot of the histrionics lately seem to indicate a general lack of humility. We can't be condemning people for not getting with the program if we don't even know if the program will work.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- driverdan 9y agoWhile what you said is true you can still try to improve your own pipeline by targeting places other people look for jobs, using language that minimizes bias (careful here, lots of pseudoscience going around), and ensuring your company culture is welcoming to others (eg not acting like a frat). You may not be able to expand the opposite end of the pipeline but you can try to make the start of your pipeline as large as possible.