3 ms·

There were no promises made for Welsh Independence. What are you talking about?

• mcny 9y ago
  Sorry. I was thinking Scotland. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jan/22/david-cameron-scottish-vow-smith-commission https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jan/22/david-... https://archive.fo/ekq26 https://archive.fo/ekq26
  • hardlianotion 9y ago
    Not true. SNP talk about it all the time. "The Vow" is highly contentious. What you believe was promised largely depends on what side of the nationalist divide you sit on.
    • mcny 9y ago
      > SNP talk about it all the time. Sorry, I think I failed to be clear. I meant to signal the lack of the Tories talking about keeping their promise. SNP wants more devolution. It is silly for the English to say why Scotland should have a say in English affairs if the English should not have a say in Scotland. > "The Vow" is highly contentious. Well, of course it is. > What you believe was promised largely depends on what side of the nationalist divide you sit on. Isn't that very convenient? The way I understand it, Labour expects to win a lot of seats in Scotland so it is against their interest as well for Scotland to be independent? In any case, the point is not how England screws over Scotland but rather use it as an example that a fully democratic government to replace China PR will still screw over Hong Kong and Tibet.