6 ms·
> one good argument for capitalism: sooner or later it brought a demand for democracy... Nope, capitalism is an economic system, not to be confounded with othe
by ekianjo 9y ago
> one good argument for capitalism: sooner or later it brought a demand for democracy...
Nope, capitalism is an economic system, not to be confounded with other types of Freedom. Capitalism is the ability of freely trade private property, among other things. In the West we tend to think it goes hand in hand with Freedom of Speech, Freedom of Press and other liberties, but it does not have to. However, if Individual Freedom is the goal of your political system, then you will have Capitalism as well (the US is a good case since the constitution is clearly about the ultimate protection of individual liberties, even before the State).
- coldtea 9y ago>Nope, capitalism is an economic system, not to be confounded with other types of Freedom. Capitalism is the ability of freely trade private property, among other things. In the West we tend to think it goes hand in hand with Freedom of Speech, Freedom of Press and other liberties, but it does not have to. Exactly -- and all this obscures how those things came to be: with fierce struggle from the lower classes (workers, women, blacks, etc.) in most cases, handed over to the patricians of the state in others (e.g. US Declaration of Independence and so on) and spread more widely later. Not from the system for running the economy. Heck, Hayek, for one, a champion of capitalism, was in bed with Pinochet. And one of the things western countries did when they entered capitalism, was to conquer and enslave 2/3rds of the world in their colonies. So much for democracy.
- scythe 9y agoHayek was practically senile by 1973. It does not make sense to critique the legacy of someone who is mostly known for his work in the 1920s-40s with some of his more outlandish ideas many decades later.
- ekianjo 9y agoThat sounds dubious that he was senile in 1973 when he wrote this in 1980: > Well, I would say that, as long-term institutions, I am totally against dictatorships. But a dictatorship may be a necessary system for a transitional period. At times it is necessary for a country to have, for a time, some form or other of dictatorial power. As you will understand, it is possible for a dictator to govern in a liberal way. And it is also possible for a democracy to govern with a total lack of liberalism. Personally I prefer a liberal dictator to democratic government lacking liberalism. My personal impression — and this is valid for South America — is that in Chile, for example, we will witness a transition from a dictatorial government to a liberal government. And during this transition it may be necessary to maintain certain dictatorial powers, not as something permanent, but as a temporary arrangement.
- ttoinou 9y agoSeems like he was right about Chile at least
- ekianjo 9y agoYes because Chile ended up as a democracy after a short period of dictatorship (relatively speaking).
- RobertoG 9y agoIt seems to me, that what happens (and not only in Chile) is this: A few political parties alternate in government without big changes. More or less, they have the same program, with minor differences. They, both, are part of the Establishment and the owners of everything, normally a few families, can live with them. Democracy it's good. Nevermind the conditions of the rest of society. For some reason, despise the media being owned by "reasonable" hands, somebody outside of the establishment it's elected. Then, democracy it's not so good, and a dictatorship is needed to restore the power to the correct people, sorry, to "protect the freedom". When the situation it's stabilized we can go back to the democracy simulacrum. I would like to see how long would take for a new dictatorship appear if the people in power since always feel their position threaded.
- exceptione 9y agoMaybe I misunderstand you here, but - Slavery was the norm before western countries got involved with it as well. - Democracy didn't exist when the west was also active in the slavery market. I do not know too much about the US though.
- coldtea 9y ago>- Slavery was the norm before western countries got involved with it as well. Not in the scale of enslaving 2/3rd of the world. In fact many nations had put an end to the practice way before colonialism. And of course those countries didn't pride themselves on their christian or englitenment values, or beings democratic, and having some "white man's burden" of civilizing the world. >- Democracy didn't exist when the west was also active in the slavery market. You don't need democracy to abolish slavery.
- ttoinou 9y agoNot in the scale of enslaving 2/3rd of the world. In fact many nations had put an end to the practice way before colonialism. Source ?
- purple-again 9y agoHes conflating colonization with slavery. A horribly thing to do as they were not similar tragedies.
- coldtea 9y agoActually they were very much intertwined. Colonization was how slavery was justified, commercialized and gone global, and colonial subjects were treated as an abundant work force for their colonial masters (when they were not hunted for fun, treated as animals, or displayed on "human zoos"). https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/sep/08/european-racism-africa-slavery https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/sep/08/europe... But even if I was "conflating" the too, that would at best a mistake in the use of words, not a "horribly" (sic) thing to do. Slavery and/or colonization themselves would be actual examples of horrible things to do.
- ekianjo 9y ago> Heck, Hayek, for one, a champion of capitalism, was in bed with Pinochet. Where? Hayek said basically that there was more freedom under Pinochet than under Allende, which is not the same thing as being a supporter of Pinochet. > Hayek: More recently I have not been able to find a single person even in much maligned Chile who did not agree that personal freedom was much greater under Pinochet than it had been under Allende.
- coldtea 9y ago>Where? Hayek said basically that there was more freedom under Pinochet than under Allende, which is not the same thing as being a supporter of Pinochet. Even if he had just said that, it would have been enough to make him a supporter -- considering that he said that for a fascist junta leader that overthrew a democratically elected leader, and is responsible for thousands of executions, and tons of torture and violence. There was just no redeeming quality. But Hayek went much further: http://crookedtimber.org/2013/06/25/the-hayek-pinochet-connection-a-second-reply-to-my-critics/ http://crookedtimber.org/2013/06/25/the-hayek-pinochet-conne...
- ekianjo 9y ago> Allende democratically elected Note that the election was far from being "the majority of electors" and heavily disputed at the time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salvador_Allende#1970_election https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salvador_Allende#1970_election Let's not pretend Allende represented the population of Chile at large, please. Hoover report on before and after Allende: https://www.hoover.org/research/what-pinochet-did-chile https://www.hoover.org/research/what-pinochet-did-chile > In 1970, Allende won 36.2 percent of the popular vote, less than the 38.6 percent he had taken in 1964 and only 1.3 percent more than the runner-up. According to the constitution, the legislature could have given the presidency to either of the top two candidates. It chose Allende only after he pledged explicitly to abide by the constitution. “A few months later,” Whelan reports, “Allende told fellow leftist Regis Debray that he never actually intended to abide by those commitments but signed just to finally become president.” In legislative and other elections over the next three years, Allende and his Popular Unity (UP) coalition, dominated by the Communist and Socialist parties, never won a majority, much less a mandate, in any election. Still Allende tried to “transition” (his term) Chile into a Marxist-Leninist economic, social, and political system. and > Many on the left had long believed that capitalism and democracy were incompatible. In a brazen demonstration of its contempt for majority wishes, and for the institutions of what it called “bourgeois democracy,” the pro-Allende newspaper Puro Chile reported the results of the March 1973 legislative elections with this headline: “The People, 43%. The Mummies, 55%.” This attitude and the actions that followed from it galvanized the center-left and right, whose candidates had received almost two-thirds of the votes in the 1970 election, against Allende. On August 22, 1973, the Chamber of Deputies, whose members had been elected just five months earlier, voted 81–47 that Allende’s regime had systematically “destroyed essential elements of institutionality and of the state of law.” (The Supreme Court had earlier condemned the Allende government’s repeated violations of court orders and judicial procedures.) Less than three weeks later, the military, led by newly appointed army commander in chief Pinochet, overthrew the government. The coup was supported by Allende’s presidential predecessor, Eduardo Frei Montalva; by Patricio Aylwin, the first democratically elected president after democracy was restored in 1990; and by an overwhelming majority of the Chilean people. Cuba and the United States were actively involved on opposite sides, but the main players were always Chilean.
- jonathanstrange 9y agoHayek is not a capitalist, he's a Social Darwinist who also believes - without a shred of evidence, given the shortness of the time spans under consideration - that free market capitalism gives groups an evolutionary advantage. That's a huge difference.
- freeflight 9y agoIsn't Social Darwinism just the outcome of arguing that "laissez-faire capitalism solves everything by weeding out the weak"? It has nothing at all to do with socialism and the Darwinism rather references Darwin's evolutionary concepts in a "survival of the fittest" way. Afaik it's nothing anybody would label themselves as.
- dna_polymerase 9y ago> Capitalism is the ability of freely trade private property, among other things. Wrong. Capitalism is about maximizing profits and accumulation of wealth. Free markets are essentially a very hostile environment to that. As soon as big players emerge in a field they will root for protectionism. Less competition leads to more profit. Free markets are something completely different.
- dalbasal 9y ago"Capitalism is the ability of freely trade private property, among other things." Is it? IDK. There are different definitions. Part of the problems is that opponents and proponents use different definitions. Opponents describe characteristics, or consequences. On the radical end, they use marxist definitions (really, the original) which are mostly about an urban, company-centric (wage labour) economy. Less radical ones use it to describe the power/wealth inequalities we have. Proponents generally focus on "free markets," free trade, private property^ and such. IE, you could have bronze-age capitalism if people were free in certain ways. IE, the ideologies of anglo-american liberals (libertarians, neoliberals...and other derivatives).
- sideshowb 9y ago> Capitalism is the ability of freely trade private property, among other things. Within limits. For example, we can't freely trade slaves, sex with minors, powerful weapons, etc, and I'm sure most of us are pretty thankful for that. Most western nations also have limits on trading private property, inasmuch as such trade is taxed. See Ha Joon Chang's books for a reminder that "free" markets aren't really as free as the ideology would have you believe.
- jack9 9y agoNo, not within limits. It's a descriptive economic model. The modern us version isnt the standard.
- cm2187 9y agoI think the thinking is that capitalism creates wealth, creates a middle class, i.e. a large population of wealthy educated people (in other times we would call it the bourgeoisie). This middle class would be large enough, organised enough to threaten a corrupt/unpopular dictatorship and would ultimately result in its downfall, either violently or gradually. I think it is misguided in the short term. Dictatorships are very good at protecting themselves from the hostility of its population. However I think it does work in the long run, that is 30-50 years. So we just need to be either patient or ruthless with China.