4 ms·
> If you exclude research due to funding sources and potential conflicts of interest, you wouldn't be left with much. If the majority of research is tainted by
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> If you exclude research due to funding sources and potential conflicts of interest, you wouldn't be left with much.
If the majority of research is tainted by conflicts, that doesn't somehow make it any less tainted by conflicts.
It's trivially easy to design a study to produce the results you want it to, just by selecting things like accounting methods at the outset.
For example, one method of accounting is to allocate costs based on usage. So if you have a car and you drive it 90% for Uber and 10% for your own usage, allocate 90% of all costs to Uber. That makes Uber look really bad.
But if you would have bought the car either way and the question is the incremental cost of driving for Uber, that accounting method is the sunk cost fallacy. It allocates large fractions of a bunch of fixed costs to the incremental use, like the original purchase price of the car, even though they're sunk and can't be avoided either way.
And the money actually does taint the study, because the funders know the parameters of the study ahead of time and only fund the ones that will produce the results they want, which makes the results tainted by selection bias.
- elgenie 9y agoYou could also read the methodology in the study when it comes out, since describing that is required in science, as opposed to questioning hypothetical methodologies that could be used. From the brief version of the study (http://ceepr.mit.edu/files/papers/2018-005-Brief.pdf http://ceepr.mit.edu/files/papers/2018-005-Brief.pdf), it appears they're using per-mile costs and ascribing only the incremental costs on a per-mile basis. > Of the five sources of cost estimated per mile (Insurance, Maintenance, Repairs, Fuel and Depreciation), approximately 40% of costs are attributable to Insurance, Maintenance and Repairs, 40% to fuel expenses, and 20% to depreciation.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoYou are correct that I used a hypothetical methodology. That's because -- and this is the real problem -- finding the flaw in a specific methodology is a lot of work. It's often not just one thing that throws the numbers off by 200%, it's one thing that throws them off by 12%, then another by 7%, and twenty other little things that add and multiply up to an inaccurate overall conclusion. It can take multiple hours to figure out what actually happened and people don't have that kind of time, so the majority of people only have time to read the conclusion and who sponsored it. In theory the solution to the problem of everyone having to personally evaluate every study is for a trustworthy reporter to do it for you, but that hasn't worked ever since reporters figured out that "Uber eats souls" gets more clicks than "wage study methodology miscalculates wages." But if you want a real flaw in this study, how about this one -- most other jobs don't let you count transportation expenses against the hourly wage. Obviously an Uber driver's transportation expenses will be higher, but that doesn't mean you can discount them in the other cases when you count them in this case. If someone has a 30 mile commute (because living closer to work is even more expensive) at $0.53/mile, that's 60 miles a day, so $31.80 in daily incremental expenses to take the job. 8 hours at federal minimum wage ($7.25/hr) is $58, so after transportation expenses their hourly wage is $3.28/hour. For someone with a 50 mile commute it's $0.63/hour. Suddenly Uber doesn't look so bad.
- malandrew 9y ago> most other jobs don't let you count transportation expenses against the hourly wage Good job in pointing out this huge flaw in this study. Every minimum wage job I ever worked required me to have a vehicle to get to and from that job. That means that every minimum wage job out there where you need to pay for transportation to get to it is paying below minimum wage as the end the day. Those who live in cities have the benefit of public transportation but also have the time cost of being slower and reduces the number of waking hours they can earn money. What's the hours lost commuting averaged across and subtracted against the number of worked?
- eevilspock 9y agoSo everyone here is agreeing that things are pretty fucked for people relying on minimum wage jobs, putting aside whether Uber/Lyft pay below or above minimum.
- Clanan 9y agoDo other transportation jobs count transportation expenses against the wage? If not, then that is an excellent point. I would assume taxiing, food delivery, etc. would count them.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoProbably a bad assumption. The guy delivering pizzas in his own car for minimum wage is basically an Uber driver that happens to do a lot of business with a pizza place.
- rictic 9y agoWhen I delivered pizzas (2006; Pizza Hut; Alabama) there was a small additional consideration for gas and wear and tear on my vehicle. As I recall it was around 1/6th to 1/10th of the the ~$6 an hour wage I was otherwise making.
- malandrew 9y ago> Of the five sources of cost estimated per mile (Insurance, Maintenance, Repairs, Fuel and Depreciation), approximately 40% of costs are attributable to Insurance, Maintenance and Repairs, 40% to fuel expenses, and 20% to depreciation. Does their methodology ascribe only the incremental aspect of each of these costs? If I own a car already for my own personal use. I'm going to deal with all of these costs. You're already going to have insurance, maintenance and repairs, they'll just be more frequent. Fuel expenses is the only input that can be accurately estimated and attributed to ridesharing work performed. Even this contains a huge variable. Did they account for drivers using hybrid vehicles, which more and more ridesharing drivers opt for because it's significantly more profitable? Is the median TNC driver using a more fuel efficient vehicle than the one they accounted for in their calculations? The fact that the study doesn't have an entire section that I found entirely devoted to potential problems with their methodology that we are pointing out here is reason enough to discount it as tainted after also considering its funders.
- elgenie 9y agoThe study's not published and expecting the two page preview of the working paper to have a 'discussion of potential problems with methodology' section is utterly unrealistic. They're clearly trying to gauge incremental costs, not fixed costs, and each of insurance/maintenance/repairs/fuel/depreciation are incremental. The breakdown between the personal and ride-hail vehicle use is part of the study and appears in the sentence previous to the quoted one as "the vast majority of drivers report that the bulk of the miles they drive are for ride-hailing".
- malandrew 9y ago> The study's not published and expecting the two page preview of the working paper to have a 'discussion of potential problems with methodology' section is utterly unrealistic. In that case, it's grossly irresponsible to publish what little they have. Society is still struggling to correct the "statistic" that a woman earns 70 cents for every dollar a man earns. This new statistic about how much TNC drivers make is going to be accepted as fact from here on out, when it's grossly misleading. > "the vast majority of drivers report that the bulk of the miles they drive are for ride-hailing" That doesn't change the fact that the vast majority of the drivers would already have that car as a sunk cost whether they drove the vast majority of those miles for ridesharing or not.
- Clanan 9y agoNothing you said refutes my claim. All research requires some sort of funding. Humans have biases which can affect their judgment/work. If you think potential conflicts should automatically make a paper worthless, then you're basically excluding the vast majority of scientific work. Read the paper and decide whether its methodology and results are valid and correct. Don't just look at a list of sponsors and walk away - that's just intellectual laziness.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> Don't just look at a list of sponsors and walk away - that's just intellectual laziness. Is everyone supposed to personally fully read every individual scientific study? That doesn't scale. The only way it works is to have experts you trust to give you the truth, which is what the scientists are supposed to be, but the funding source undermines the trust.
- mygo 9y agoNah, you’re just lazy. You’re not supposed to read every single piece of research in existence. No one person does that. Not even the scientists. But if the topic interests you enough for you to comment about it and there is a research paper that you can read, then just read the dang paper or let other people make decisions for you. Nobody has to give you the truth. And, on top of that, even if the results of research are quantified, there may not even be an unquestionable “truth” — the implications of the research can still be up to interpretation.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> Nobody has to give you the truth. Then you have to figure it out for yourself. For everything. Which, again, doesn't scale. At some point you do need to trust some people to make some decisions for you. But what kind of fool trusts someone with a conflict of interest?
- mygo 9y ago