8 ms·
The 99% Rule (nsfw)
- powrtoch 16y agoI'm at work. Can someone at least tell me why I shouldn't click?
- Mc_Big_G 16y agoHe reverses the negative image used in press releases of the new airport body scanners, which basically shows a naked woman.
- d4ft 16y agobackscatter nudity
- rabarber 16y agobecause you should be working.
- torial 16y agoBasically it includes some screenshots of the supposed effectiveness of the Airport scanner... e.g. a nude woman, then has the images inverted. I didn't read the article too closely, I'm not sure that the author understands those images are from an image catalog that has nothing to do with the airport scanner, but have been misrepresented as being so. Can't provide citation, but saw that on an earlier article from HN about a month ago.
- sp332 16y agoReminds me of Hearst: "You furnish the images, I'll furnish the war!" He got images like this one of a woman being strip-searched NSFW http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Spaniards_search_women_1898.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Spaniards_search_women_189... which (he knew) was totally fabricated, and published them to rally pro-war sentiment.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- sp332 16y agoText-only Google cache http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?strip=1&q=cache:http%3A%2F%2Fwww.whattofix.com%2Fblog%2Farchives%2F2010%2F08%2Fthe-99-rule-nsf.php http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?strip=1&q=c...
- ciupicri 16y agoOr use lynx or disable images.
- d4ft 16y agoQuick nitpick: The Court that issued the judgment on the GPS case was the 9th circuit (not district). Otherwise, I do agree. The right to privacy is something that is not explicitly guaranteed in the Constitution. It only exists because it was read in by Justice Douglas as a side product of "penumbras and emanations" of the Bill of Rights. The balance between freedom and government protection has always been tenuous. After 9/11 we have certainly seen a tipping toward the latter. Only time will tell if this trend continues, but in a world in which technology can reveal even our naked bodies, I certainly hope not.
- jemfinch 16y ago> The balance between freedom and government protection has always been tenuous. After 9/11 we have certainly seen a tipping toward the latter. Have we? All I've seen is a reduction in freedom.
- d4ft 16y agoThats exactly what I meant. Sorry if it wasn't clear. I was trying to say that we are leaning toward government protection over personal freedoms. So, yes I agree.
- seven 16y agoI missed absolute numbers. Talk for example about false positives in airport security. An error rate of 'only 0.01%' looks pretty good at first. But if you put in the actual numbers, you see a very different image. Airport Frankfurt had about 50 million passengers in 2009. An false positive rate of 0.01% would cause trouble for 5000 people. Each day about 13 people would be falsely accused.
- confuzatron 16y agoTo be honest, I don't think that's a big deal - 'false positives', whatever those might be in the case of backscatter machines, can be easily caught at the second stage - a pat-down. The bigger issue is blindly forcing everyone to effectively strip naked for the authorities before they are allowed to board a plane.
- seven 16y agoAgree, but actually I was not thinking about backscatter machines. I had biometric passports in mind while writing... and people missing flights as a consequence.
- viggity 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayes_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayes_theorem
- napierzaza 16y agoThere are airport scanner photos of a naked woman. This isn't really a 99% case is it? He's saying that someone making fun of a scanned persons genitalia is part of the 1% where it doesn't work. I would argue that 100% of the time this practice is demeaning. I think that using spy satellites on American Citizens (I'm Canadian) is a bad idea 99% of the time. It's the other way around. You're catching the bad guys maybe 1% of the time or less, not the other way around. Where is even the 1% of crimes prevented by taking naked pictures of women and children? What is the benefit if the bomb won't be in underwear anymore, but an orifice. "Sometimes the people in charge of tracking you have ulterior motives -- which are very easy to have when there's no warrant involved. That pesky 1%" Yeah, my tracker is always calling me out when I'm off my diet.
- mey 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_One_Percent_Doctrine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_One_Percent_Doctrine
- moron4hire 16y agoThese example images that they always use to show the effectiveness of the backscatter X-Ray always crack me up. They show big, bright blobs of gun-shaped somethings. Gee, what gun is that for it get past the metal detector?
- cullenking 16y agoMake it a glass knife instead of a firearm.
- thaumaturgy 16y agoSure, but someone that wants to get a glass knife through airport security can come up with much better ways of doing it. My dad and I occasionally play a game where we try to one-up each-other with ways to get weapons or contraband through security. There are a lot of ways. These backscatter scanners -- like most of the rest of airport security -- do very little to actually increase the security of the system. Also: http://xkcd.com/651/ http://xkcd.com/651/
- apphacker 16y agoIf you need help accessing the credibility of this article, it links to a page that claims the christmas bomber was staged. http://musicians4freedom.com/?p=5016 http://musicians4freedom.com/?p=5016 "The fact that authorities initially lied and denied this was the case as part of the agenda to hastily install scanners after the staged Christmas bombing incident was clearly a case of mass public deception and one of the primary reasons why the scanners need to be removed now." So uh, yeah.
- sk_0919 16y agoInteresting how a nsfw link makes it to the top of HN between 9:30 and 10:30 AM :-)
- NickPollard 16y agoIt's only between 9.30 and 10.30 in one particular timezone.
- steveklabnik 16y agoWhen you work for yourself, you decide what's safe for work.
- techiferous 16y agoInteresting how a link about politics (this is about politics, not technology) makes it to the top of HN...
- points 16y agoCan someone with a scientific knowledge tell me if we'll one day have technology to package the full body scanner into glasses? That will open a massive can of worms for humanity :/ What happens when everyone can see everyone else naked...
- 83457 16y agoOf course. Your body radiates waves of various types through your clothes, or waves can be bounced off your body, that are not visible to the human eye. The waves can be recorded through various methods and converted to an image that we can see on a video screen. Once we have augmented reality glasses which is inevitable, this will certainly be on the market somewhere. Google for "night vision see through clothes" and "infra red see through clothes".
- dmoney 16y agoI think the grandparent was asking if the X-ray machines themselves could be miniaturized enough to fit in the glasses. In case you wanted to use them when a giant machine wasn't around.
- Retric 16y agoYou can generate X-ray's from a device the size of a flashlight.
- techiferous 16y agoBut there is a limitation: you would be able to detect the underlying shape but not the colors of the skin. tl;dr: Won't work on tattoos.
- sofuture 16y agoI don't mean to detract from the article but it's worth pointing out that those are absolutely fake/photoshopped images and not at all actual scans.
- sofuture 16y ago(I also realize the article alludes to that fact, but several comments here do not make that distinction)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- spatulon 16y agoHere's a link showing that the images are almost certainly fake: http://trueslant.com/KashmirHill/2010/01/27/tsa-scanner-porn-hoax-fools-gizmodo-drudge-report/ http://trueslant.com/KashmirHill/2010/01/27/tsa-scanner-porn...
- jamesseda 16y agoI wonder if(when) the real scans get to that same resolution the public will be informed.
- hbt 16y agoYup, Picture used in the article. http://www.f1online.de/premid/000518000/518434.jpg http://www.f1online.de/premid/000518000/518434.jpg
- tmsh 16y agoI'm surprised image filtering technology doesn't have a way to just view a silhouette of the skin. I.e., establish the skin color gradients and then remove them...
- ajj 16y agoI work in image processing / computer vision (albeit in completely different applications), and the technology is not very good at doing that, at least yet. On the other hand, whenever you mention 'skin color' in a research proposal, that does not have an easy route either, even when it has nothing to do with racism.
- rarestblog 16y agoThe image used in article is a known hoax (it's a stock image, not a real scanner result). http://www.tatumba.com/blog/archives/1369 http://www.tatumba.com/blog/archives/1369 Compare with: http://www.kelowna.com/2010/04/08/kelowna-airport-using-full-body-scanner/ http://www.kelowna.com/2010/04/08/kelowna-airport-using-full...
- jessriedel 16y agoYour "compare with" link is a millimeter wave image, not a back-scatter x-ray image. The later really is much more detailed... http://www.naturalnews.com/gallery/articles/WaveScanners.jpg http://www.naturalnews.com/gallery/articles/WaveScanners.jpg ...though not quite as detailed-looking as the hoax.
- rarestblog 16y agoThanks for the correction! I thought those two were the same.
- ataggart 16y agoIn a functioning constitutional republic we would not first be asking what Amendments prohibit government power, but rather by what constitutionally-delegated power does the government assert its authority to act. Alas we've spent the better part of two centuries carving out an ever-widening reading of Federal power. There are those who are perfectly willing to read into the Interstate Commerce Clause the power to mandate individuals purchase health insurance. There are those who are perfectly willing to read into the Interstate Commerce Clause the power to forbid purely intrastate sale of otherwise legal drugs. How sadly humorous that these two groups, likely opposed in most political issues, can agree on near-limitless Federal power, and in so doing they have left us with only "penumbras and emanations" as defense.
- radioflyer 16y agoIs anyone else more worried about radiation exposure from these things than their privacy?
- jedwhite 16y agoBen Franklin put it well: "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
- nchapman 16y agoThat picture is a fake. That's how the scans actually look.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoHey guys, I apologize that I got punked with the image. It is a known fake. Having said that, the technology really does take naked pictures of folks. The only question is how much image manipulation the software performs (and how easily it can be hacked) From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backscatter_X-ray http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backscatter_X-ray - " it performs a virtual strip search, easily penetrating clothing to reveal concealed weapons; however, it raises privacy concerns in that it appears to screeners essentially as a nude picture of the subject, and may allow screeners to gain access to otherwise confidential medical information, such as the fact a passenger uses a colostomy bag, has a missing limb or wears a prosthesis, or is transsexual." From http://science.howstuffworks.com/innovation/backscatter.htm http://science.howstuffworks.com/innovation/backscatter.htm - "And yes, it's possible for backscatter X-raying to produce photo-quality images of what's going on beneath our clothes. But because of privacy concerns, for the time being, the peep show has been distorted: " I would also direct you to http://www.prisonplanet.com/exposed-naked-body-scanner-images-of-film-star-printed-circulated.html http://www.prisonplanet.com/exposed-naked-body-scanner-image... and http://oklahoma.watchdog.org/1053/naked-machines-do-store-and-transmit-images-feds-admit/ http://oklahoma.watchdog.org/1053/naked-machines-do-store-an... Very sorry about the slip-up. I'm also sorry that this was taken as a political rant. This same thing happens in large organizations when dealing with other things that cause political risk, and for the same reason. And it's just as upsetting. I simply used the security business as a theme. It's what upsets the most folks, and it seemed to be easily understandable by the largest audience. I've updated the blog to remove the naked picture and make the correction.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- RK 16y agoRight now I see one removed, but the other one is a fake as well. I was watching the way (some of) these are "cleaned up" for display at the airport the other day. It was basically a stick figure with little boxes showing where items were on the person. Pretty interesting.
- zacharypinter 16y agoIs the source image a fake? You can see it inverted back by hitting "command+option+control+8" on your mac.
- forgottenpaswrd 16y ago"Look. I don't like running naked pictures of people on my blog. This is a family deal and the kids read it." Hmmmm, what's wrong with kids seeing people naked? I'm sorry but I can't understand, I'm not American. Satellites are only available for short periods of time, and are so expensive, SUAVs are going to be way more used than satellites.
- TheMadApe 16y agoTalk about being stuffy. I own the site showing the hoaxed body scanner images http://www.tatumba.com/blog/archives/1369 http://www.tatumba.com/blog/archives/1369 and because of that article an advertiser kicked me off their network. They told me remove the article or cover up the nudity. The nudity is part of the story so I told them to stick their ads up their covered up asses! The Mad Ape
- jedwhite 16y agoOf course the arguments for governments doing full backscatter body image scans are fundamentally the same as the arguments for getting access to encrypted mail and voice calls. As India is doing in this other currently popular story here on HN: http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/india/100831/blackberry-research-in-motion-ban http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/india/100831/blackberry-r... If we're happy to have government agents inspect our private parts to board a plane, why shouldn't we be happy for them to inspect our emails and phone calls to be able to communicate with each other? Email and phone calls aren't any more of a right than freedom of movement are they? Technology should be increasing not decreasing the effectiveness of our freedoms. And us folks who make it should have liberty on our brains as we hack away.
- notahacker 16y agoA "99% accurate" paedophilia test would quite possibly falsely accuse as many innocents as catch positive people (given that only a tiny fraction of people are paedophiles) and being wrongly accused of being a paedophile has a pretty substantial negative impact on your welfare. I'm not sure the airport scanner argument is really connected: it causes mild embarrassment to 100% of people asked to use it. The real question is whether having the mild embarrassment of being subject to certain security procedures (voluntarily; you bought the ticket) is worth a reduced chance of a fiery death in mid-air. Personally I'd say yes even though the chances of the latter occurring are vanishingly small. If anything the "99% rule" is the defending the opposite argument: >99% of the time it reveals nothing or throws up false positives, same with passport control and with the delay-inducing regular maintenance checks on the aircraft and the costly OEM approvals required for each and every component fitted on the aircraft and the extra hours spent by the pilot getting type-rated on the newer variant and the slight adjustments to the flight path to take into account the remote possibility of bad weather and extra airspace assigned to that particular aircraft because of mildly reduced visibility and the minute corrections of altitude shortly before and the possibility of deploying the autopilot.... and actually, I quite like the way having all these seemingly easily-dispensed-with checks ensures that an aluminium tube travelling at several hundred mph thousands of feet above the ground is the safest mode of transport.
- doki_pen 16y agoLet the market decided! Those who want the "added protection" of naked pictures, can fly the naked picture airlines!
- notahacker 16y agoNot everyone affected by lax airline security/safety chooses to buy tickets... http://www.kinomaniak.pl/film/world_trade_center/world_trade_center6b.jpg http://www.kinomaniak.pl/film/world_trade_center/world_trade... http://www.twf.org/News/Y2003/0815-Lockerbie.jpg http://www.twf.org/News/Y2003/0815-Lockerbie.jpg
- seanalltogether 16y ago
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- frank304 16y agoA few years ago I was on a school trip, and we were flying back to the US from London. The security at the airport asked me if I minded going through a new type of scanner with a shorter line. The airport was doing a test run of the same kind of backscatter machine. Everyone likes short lines, so I agreed. After the scan was over, the security showed me the scan of my backside. It was literally an inverted naked picture of my ass. They looked at the scan of the frontside, but didn't show it to me. I wasn't expecting anything like this, because the technology was so new and it hadn't been widely publicized. It was really embarrassing to think that I had just been practically strip searched. That image is a fake, but it's not very far from the truth.
- sliverstorm 16y ago> There is no doubt in my mind that if every person in the United States were relieved of their guns, we would have no gun violence Uh... there's a whole lot of doubt in MY mind.