4 ms·
Apropos HN, he then says, officials set out to fix Indiana's poorly-performing welfare system by inserting an untested, theoretical experiment, and subst
by wahern 9y ago
Apropos HN, he then says,
officials set out to fix Indiana's poorly-performing
welfare system by inserting an untested, theoretical
experiment, and substitute personal caseworkers with
computers and phone calls ("remote eligibility"). This
is now admitted to be an error, and there is nothing in
this case, or the Court's power, that can be done to
correct it, or remedy the lost taxpayer money or
personal suffering of needy Hoosiers.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoML based welfare eligibility screening seems a few short steps from Kafka. I'm not sure if that's what they were doing, but it seems like something that somebody would think is a great idea.
- samstave 9y agoThe ONLY person who would think all that is a good idea are the engineers who were able to update their linkedin with "implemented ML based solution to replace human resources with computer resources to streamline the welfare system for the state of X"
- theossuary 9y agoI don't think any engineer would consider that a good idea. But if somebody tells you that's what you're working on for the next few years, make lemonade I guess.
- wolco 9y agoStill sounds like fun to build.
- paulie_a 9y agoLinkedIn is basically the epitome of HR pointlessness. so that would probably be a bullet point to not include
- fphhotchips 9y agoThat's not at all true. The only engineers who would think all that is a good idea are those who could update their LinkedIn. The salespeople and non-technical leadership though? They're going to love the idea of ML (read: magic) based solutions to replace human resources with computer resources to streamline their welfare systems.
- gowld 9y agoThe quoted paragraph isn't ML, it's telecommunications.
- nraynaud 9y agoIn France a few years ago I registered for unemployment benefits (that was quite a quest), I received a letter from the electricity utility telling me that I qualified for a reduced price. Later when I found a job, they put back the normal price.
- Spooky23 9y agoStates were successful in moving Medicaid enrollment to outsourced providers. THis was probably seen as building on that theme. I think IBM bought an Irish company that did similar work in the UK, so it probably looked achievable, and a potential Cash cow for other states. (Accenture was able to sell child welfare solutions at great profit in the 90s) Its a great business as it generates alotmof complimentary sales and services.
- jessaustin 9y agoAccenture was able to sell child welfare solutions at great profit in the 90s In the 90s that would have been Andersen Consulting rather than Accenture. Although having worked with them at the time and found them worse in every way than IBM is described in this thread, I wouldn't be surprised to learn they profited at the expense of poor children.
- Spooky23 9y agoI've worked in the public sector and in support of a large complex social services system at a very large scale. It's a frustrating place to be put in charge of for a political appointee charged with reform, usually without alot of knowledge, or with a idealogical bent fueled by conservative dogma in this case. IGS is a shitshow, but outsourcing stuff like this is ridiculously dumb. IBM was in a position where failure was the only option, and anyone attempting to do this will fail. IBM underestimated the difficulty of the task, probably because the customer had zero clue.