3 ms·
Why did we need that upgrade? There are about a zillion reasons you can come up with for that, to match the entire spectrum of political outlooks and levels of
by pvg 9y ago
Why did we need that upgrade?
There are about a zillion reasons you can come up with for that, to match the entire spectrum of political outlooks and levels of cynicism, none of which have to include 'to start a new nuclear arms race'.
What would you expect to see if there were a new nuclear arms race?
Well, for one thing, I'd expect the race to include at least two parties. If Russia truly believed something on the US side is actually putting the global strategic nuclear balance in question, I imagine their response would be more robust than running a missile-naming competition on the internet.
The reporting on these issues always stresses the risk of starting a new nuclear arms race - the NYT piece you linked to does, as has much of what has been written over the last 15-odd years at least. The risk is surely real but this does imply that we have not, in fact, been in a nuclear arms race. So far.
- eesmith 9y agoI would like to hear a few of those zillions of reasons which make sense given an opponent who wants to maintain a second-strike response. Because I can't think of any. You mention wanting something "more robust than running a missile-naming competition on the internet". How does the RS-28 Sarmat not count as one example? Quoting from https://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/world/russia/ss-30.htm https://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/world/russia/ss-30.htm : > On 07 September 2016, a defense industry official told Russian media that the mass production of the RS-28 Sarmat intercontinental ballistic missile, a new multi-warhead, super-heavy missile designed to defeat anti-missile systems, would begin in 2018, two years ahead of schedule. ... > Russia's State Rocket Center V. P. Makeyev of (Miass) and NGO's Engineering (Reutov) along with NPO Mashinostroyeniyais is developing the new sarmat / Sarmatian heavy liquid-propellant intercontinental ballistic missile to overcome the U.S.’s prospective missile defense system, Strategic Missile Forces chief Lt. Gen. Sergei Karakayev said 16 December 2011. The decision had been made to create a new silo-launched heavy missile that will have “enhanced capability to breach a hypothetical US missile defense system,” he said. That's exactly what I would expect as part of a nuclear arms race, as a response to US efforts to get ahead in the race.