2 ms·
I've been thinking about this for a long time. The initial problem is that any old forum is going to have a community around it that knows how it works. This
by jasonlotito 16y ago
I've been thinking about this for a long time. The initial problem is that any old forum is going to have a community around it that knows how it works. This makes any change disruptive to users.
Secondly, most information in a forum exists in a manner that is already organized in a certain way to account for the forum. So, you have a lot of content that is already organized and should be easily found.
Hacker News is no different. It's a forum with threads. SO was the first real departure from this. However SO succeeded for reasons besides the organization. First, it had big names behind it who could pimp it out. Secondly, it was SEO'd well. Finally, it made participation a game. The organization of SO isn't really better then what a forum can offer.
So, I'm back to thinking how I'd go about navigating a large, information intensive forum, but it's not easy. SO is great for Question/Answer problems, but that's hardly the only things forums provide.
Wiki's are another version, though very much document-centric. They allow for discussion and interaction, but in a different manner.
Maybe instead of talking about it, I should just code-up one of my ideas and see what people think.