5 ms·
LimeSDR Now Backed by the European Space Agency
- calebm 9y agoAnyone know how the LimeSDR Mini compares to the LimeSDR or HackRF?
- tomswartz07 9y agoThe main CrowdSupply page has a very good comparison table: https://www.crowdsupply.com/lime-micro/limesdr-mini https://www.crowdsupply.com/lime-micro/limesdr-mini
- superkuh 9y agoThe most important difference is that that HackRF has a huge ecosystem of established software now than it's been a handful of years since the kickstarter. With crowdfunded SDR devices expect a 1.5-3 year lag between hardware release and the software/firmware being there to do what it advertises.
- walterbell 9y agoLimeSDR vs mini: http://qrznow.com/limesdr-mini/ http://qrznow.com/limesdr-mini/ ”the LimeSDR Mini is a smaller, less expensive version of the original LimeSDR ... uses the same LMS7002M radio transceiver as its big sibling. The Mini has two channels instead of four, and, by popular demand, SMA connectors instead of micro U.FL connectors.” A positive review (2016): https://myriadrf.org/blog/first-tests-limesdr-gqrx/ https://myriadrf.org/blog/first-tests-limesdr-gqrx/ A negative review (2017): http://sv3exp.blogspot.com/2017/03/limesdr-review.html?m=1 http://sv3exp.blogspot.com/2017/03/limesdr-review.html?m=1
- tomswartz07 9y agoIt's important to point out that the two reviews listed from 2016 and 2017 are for the previous version of the LimeSDR, not the LimeSDR Mini which was just recently released.
- walterbell 9y agoWhat hw/sw changes were made between versions?
- tomswartz07 9y agoIt's a very different architecture. The original LimeSDR was able to receive from 100kHz - 3.8GHz. The LimeSDR Mini can only do 10MHz - 3.5GHz. It also only supports about 1/2 the bandwidth and sample rate. The official page highlights more differences: https://www.crowdsupply.com/lime-micro/limesdr-mini https://www.crowdsupply.com/lime-micro/limesdr-mini
- stagger87 9y agoBoth devices use the same transceiver chip so I don't think the architecture is very different at all.
- simcop2387 9y agoSame transciever, different FPGA, different ADCs, no extra ram, and some other differences. Different architectures on the digital sides of things.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThe original LimeSDR was able to receive from 100kHz - 3.8GHz. This is incorrect, and it is the source of much pain. The chip that provides the ADCs and DACs, the LMS7002, has an input range of 100kHZ to 3.8Ghz but the design of the LimeSDR front end filter banks made its minimum usable frequency with decent SNR about 200Mhz[1]. Initially you couldn't even pass a tuning frequency below that through the API. Even with the vendor/factory supplied "fix" the LimeSDR has a hard time getting below 100Mhz. A lot of people read the chip spec and expected the card implementation to be able to do the same, they were unpleasantly surprised to find out that was not the case. Hence a lot of griping early on. On the plus side, since it was deaf to the FM band it was more sensitive to higher frequency signals. Other SDRs like the SDRPlay RSP2[2] are actually quite usable down even into the AM range (500Khz - 2Mhz) and have a notch filter for the FM band to keep it from swamping the input and eating up all the dynamic range. [1] Firstly, we would like to highlight the fact that it is not possible to achieve optimum performance across the entire operating range of LimeSDR — all the way from 100kHz to 3.8GHz — with only a single matching network. -- https://myriadrf.org/blog/optimising-limesdr-matching-hf/ https://myriadrf.org/blog/optimising-limesdr-matching-hf/ [2] https://www.sdrplay.com/rsp2/ https://www.sdrplay.com/rsp2/
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI bought one (the LimeSDR) and based on that experience declined to buy the mini. If I had to summarize the mismatch it was that MyriadRF, the folks who are the actual developers behind the systems, had a decidedly windows/microwave focus. If you wanted to build an LTE simulator and use PothOS on Windows there were people to talk to, but gnuradio and Linux support was hit or miss. That was made particularly challenging by the LimeSDR folks modifying and building tools in their own PPAs which had incompatible changes/libraries with the 'mainline' sources. As a result I could build a working gnuradio setup that only had LimeSDR support (through SoapySDR) or one that supported the other three SDRs I had simultaneously. That was really painful. The 'microwave' focus was particularly apparent when, by default, there was no reasonable way to listen in on things below about 200Mhz. (all the FM band for example). They later offered an HF mod which was to remove an inductor(coil) from the front end selector on one of the antenna inputs to give it better frequency response. Even with the change I found a number of systems with better performance in the low bands. It isn't a deal killer but it means if you're going to be exploring the low bands you probably want an upconverter.
- VectorLock 9y ago>Even with the change I found a number of systems with better performance in the low bands. Such as? I'm not aware of anything in the price arena of the LimeSDR that can Tx.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoIf you're transmitting the RSP2 (mentioned earlier) is about $100 cheaper and can transmit in all of the lower spectrum. HackRF works well as a transmitter in this spectrum as well where its dynamic range isn't the limitation like it is when receiving. You can add a down converter of course and shift spectrum where the SDR is comfortable playing into the lower bands, but if you're going to do that you might as well get the PLUTO-ADALM from Analog devices which is only $150 (I got mine on the intro deal of $99 but still). That said the LimeSDR excels at MIMO type applications (as that really is its design target).
- teamster94 9y agoNot quite sure how unbiased of a source the positive review is. Myriad is owned and fully controlled by Lime. Anyway, I'm not quite sure what ESA will be able to do that Canonical couldn't. This whole app store idea for radio seems very farfetched.
- znpy 9y agoQuestion: can I use LimeSDR and some SDR software to save on hardware and not get a Yaesu or Icom ham radio? I wanted to play with ham radio for a while but I am not sure I want to spend 750+ Euros for a Yaesu station.
- aphextron 9y agoAbsolutely, but you'll probably need an amplifier as these things tend to be ~1mW-10mW output power.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- webbles 9y agoYes, and you don't need to limit yourself to the LimeSDR. You will want to pay attention to the frequency range the SDRs support to get an idea of which bands you will be able to use, but that is definitely one of the many things SDRs are good for.
- calebm 9y agoYou'd also probably need an upconverter like the HamItUp (which works for the HackRF).
- tomswartz07 9y agoIf you're just using a standard RTL-SDR, then yes, an upconverter like HamItUp or SpyVerter would work. However, the LimeSDR Mini supports down to 10MHz out of the box, which is "good enough". If you really need to get the 160, 80, 60, and 40 Meter bands then the converter would be needed, or you can just use the previous-generation the (full size) LimeSDR, which can receive down to 100KHz.
- tomswartz07 9y agoIt would be a good proxy for those radios, but if you're licensed and are simply looking for an inexpensive transceiver, Baofeng UV-5R radios can be found on Amazon for ~$20 and will get you working right out of the box. If you try to mock up a station using a TX/RX SDR system, it would probably much more expensive and require significantly more hardware.
- fyfy18 9y agoOther than the basic SDR projects like tracking aircraft and decodimg garage door fobs, what cool projects are people using this hardware for?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nickysielicki 9y agoThe thing to note about the Ettis and Lime devices is that they're good for so much more other than just moving I/Q to your computer. They have powerful FPGAs that make it possible to do filtering and decoding and such in hardware. If you're just looking to play around with radio, you don't need a device with these features -- not until you're much further along the learning curve. For any practical usage of these devices, it's assumed you have the wherewithal and radio background to build the pieces that it lacks; filtering, amplifiers, antennas and feedlines, and so on. This is very much a professional device, and it's not meant to replace the common usage of $20 rtlsdr dongles within the hobbyist radio community.
- chrissnell 9y agoCame here to ask this. I'm an extra-class ham but I've never done any SDR. Are these suitable for regular ham use for voice and digital modes? (assume you'd want a big amp)
- adim_web 9y agoYes. See my video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W_o8sOZHoeE&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W_o8sOZHoeE&feature=youtu.be Software is http://qradiolink.org http://qradiolink.org built with GNU radio.
- platz 9y agothe limesdr is not good for HF though. other sdr's are better.
- sliken 9y agoFor an extra class ham interested in HF more than UHF/VHF I'd recommend the Airspy HF+, it's RX only, but quite good at RX.
- jhallenworld 9y agoI used LimeSDR at work. We were nervous to buy from Crowd Supply, but they are really a good value add. Compared with something like Kickstarter they inventory the products and handle returns- something a tiny startup might not deal with well. LimeSDR was convenient for us because the LMS7002M has two radios, each with I & Q plus 3:1 input switch (so 6 inputs total).