4 ms·
A question I still have is what Trustico _hoped_ was going to happen here. Was there some arrangement where if the certs have to be revoked they get a refund?
by tialaramex 9y ago
A question I still have is what Trustico _hoped_ was going to happen here. Was there some arrangement where if the certs have to be revoked they get a refund?
Trustico also don't seem very clear on what exactly they're accusing Symantec of, the Ars article quotes them
"We believe Symantec to have operated our account in a manner whereby it had been compromised" and "We believe the orders placed via our Symantec account were at risk and were poorly managed"
In the relationship we're talking about here, a reseller to a CA, basically the only valuable information that can be compromised is payment instructions. All the important seeming cryptographic stuff? All of that is allowed to be public by design, the CSR, the Certificates themselves, any validation messages used - all public thanks to asymmetric cryptography.
Symantec got in trouble last year for inadequate (in fact basically non-existent) oversight of their RAs, particularly the Korean CrossCert. Unlike a reseller the RAs were trusted to do the domain validation themselves, so if CrossCert said "We checked and it's OK to issue a Thawte cert for www.example.com with this key" then Symantec just did it and didn't ask any questions (though they do seem to have checked they got paid...). Resellers aren't trusted with validation, they're just glorified sales people who just take a cut and help with price discrimination, what's there to "compromise" months after you cease the relationship?
- Ajedi32 9y agoI suspect the logic was something along the lines of "Symantec has acted in an untrustworthy manner (enough to get them distrusted by several major browser vendors) therefore we consider all our customer's certificates that were issued by them to be untrustworthy ("compromised") and want them revoked." Still doesn't explain why they thought that revoking 50k of their customers certificates with less than 24-hours notice would be a good idea though. That really just seems like shooting themselves in the foot.
- rando444 9y agoCan we take a step back even further? I can't figure out the logic that got this started: "These Private Keys are stored in cold storage, for the purpose of revocation." Like what? Why? Since when do you need a private key to revoke a certificate? I feel like I understand certificates really well, but .. am I missing something?
- xorcist 9y agoThose are Trustico's customer's certificates. The only way Symantec could have fraudulently issues those was if Trustico told them to or lied about who their customers were. There's no logic here to understand. I think the previous thread about Trustico had it right: Digicert bought all Symantec's customers but Trustico wants their customers to stay with them instead and wants Digicert to look untrustworthy. If none of this went pubilc and Digicert revoked all their certificates, Trustico could step in to save the day.