3 ms·
1) No. Both principal sides have a fraction of the warheads they had at the end of the cold war. 2) It's hard to tell. The standoffs have been (fortunately) mu
by pvg 9y ago
1) No. Both principal sides have a fraction of the warheads they had at the end of the cold war.
2) It's hard to tell. The standoffs have been (fortunately) much talkier. Periodically, the US makes noises about nuclear arsenal modernization, smaller tactical nukes, 'theater missile defense' etc. Similarly, the Russians announce unstoppable super-missiles. There's always the risk these moves could lead to a full-blown nuclear weapons arms race.
- eesmith 9y ago1) Absolutely yes. Here's a quote from the New York Times from https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/04/us/politics/trump-nuclear-russia.html?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=&stream=top-stories https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/04/us/politics/trump-nuclear... : > Yet when President Trump called on Congress to “modernize and rebuild our nuclear arsenal” in his State of the Union address last week, he did not mention his administration’s rationale: that President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia has accelerated a dangerous game that the United States must match, even if the price tag soars above $1.2 trillion. That is the latest estimate from the Congressional Budget Office, one that many experts think is low by a half-trillion dollars. The CBO report is at https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/115th-congress-2017-2018/reports/53211-nuclearforces.pdf https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/115th-congress-2017-2018/re... . Sure, the US has fewer warheads. It's still something like 5,000 warheads which is far more than is needed for any sort of retaliatory strike. It is what's needed if you want a first-strike capability to take out all of Russia's hardened launch sites. "Makes noises"? Aren't we actually doing that, and have been doing that, for decades? The most recent is super-fuze. Quoting https://fas.org/blogs/security/2017/03/super-fuze/ https://fas.org/blogs/security/2017/03/super-fuze/ : > Under the cover of an otherwise legitimate life-extension of the W76 warhead, the Navy has quietly added a new super-fuze to the warhead that dramatically increases the ability of the Navy to destroy hard targets in Russia and other adversaries. ... > “As a consequence, the US submarine force today is much more capable than it was previously against hardened targets such as Russian ICBM silos. A decade ago, only about 20 percent of US submarine warheads had hard-target kill capability; today they all do.” ... > In the article we conclude that the SSBN force, rather than simply being a stable retaliatory capability, with the new super-fuze increasingly will be seen as a front-line, first-strike weapon that is likely to further fuel trigger-happy, worst-case planning in other nuclear-armed states. There are three factors to consider with "unstoppable super-missiles": 1) The US pulled out of the ABM treaty. This was predicted to destabilize things, because it implies the US might want first-strike capability, with the ability to prevent a retaliatory response. Since the US upgrades mean we can take out hardened targets, that means Russia will have to switch to launch-on-warning rather than launch-on-impact. 2) There has always been a strong argument against ABM systems because they are extremely expensive, they don't work well, and the counter-measures are cheap. 3) The "unstoppable super-missiles" are what you must have if you believe that a retaliatory second strike is a deterrent against a US first-strike attack. We have only to look at history to see how high-level people in the US have wanted to use nuclear weapons. The current president appears to be one of those. On the flip side, consider the nuclear drone torpedo. This cannot be used as a first-strike attack because it can only destroy coastal cities. It cannot take out the US nuclear triad. It therefore more effective for retaliation, by the threat of destroying millions of Americans should the US decided to nuke Russia.
- pvg 9y agoThis is more less the same thing I said, with lots and lots of details. Similar things were taking place during the Bush administration. There is a lot of realignment, a lot of posturing, it is certainly a risk but it very much does not amount to a 'nuclear arms race'. If that's a nuclear arms race, the nuclear arms race never stopped. That's not an entirely unreasonable position but if you take that position, for you, the mere existence of a nuclear arsenal of any sort on either side constitutes a perpetual 'nuclear arms race'.
- eesmith 9y agoI disagree. I think I am saying something quite different. I think the current arms race started in 2002 when the US pulled out of the ABM, followed by the "upgrades" which started under Obama. (The research for those upgrades of course started long before - it's the deployment I'm interested in.) I think adding super-fuze to US nuclear weapons - "In the case of the 100-kt Trident II warhead, the super fuze triples the killing power of the nuclear force it has been applied to. https://thebulletin.org/how-us-nuclear-force-modernization-undermining-strategic-stability-burst-height-compensating-super10578 https://thebulletin.org/how-us-nuclear-force-modernization-u... - is an example of not just of the "mere existence of a nuclear arsenal", but a determined effort to tilt the balance very much in favor of the US. Why did we need that upgrade? I think the US has developed its systems far enough in that direction that Russia is now forced to spend money to keep up, as otherwise MAD is no longer effective. And that's why I call it an re-uptake of the arms race. What would you expect to see if there were a new nuclear arms race?
- pvg 9y agoWhy did we need that upgrade? There are about a zillion reasons you can come up with for that, to match the entire spectrum of political outlooks and levels of cynicism, none of which have to include 'to start a new nuclear arms race'. What would you expect to see if there were a new nuclear arms race? Well, for one thing, I'd expect the race to include at least two parties. If Russia truly believed something on the US side is actually putting the global strategic nuclear balance in question, I imagine their response would be more robust than running a missile-naming competition on the internet. The reporting on these issues always stresses the risk of starting a new nuclear arms race - the NYT piece you linked to does, as has much of what has been written over the last 15-odd years at least. The risk is surely real but this does imply that we have not, in fact, been in a nuclear arms race. So far.