4 ms·
World's most high-profile climate change skeptic does U turn on global warming
- confuzatron 16y agoFlagged for misleading headline. As far as I can see, he hasn't changed his position on global warming. (But also upvoted because it's an interesting article) "Howard Friel, author of the book The Lomborg Deception, said: "If Lomborg were really looking for smart solutions, he would push for an end to perpetual and brutal war, which diverts scarce resources from nearly everything that Lomborg legitimately says needs more money."" With enemies like that, Lomborg really doesn't have much to worry about.
- zeteo 16y agoWell, first of all the "world's most high-profile climate change" label is extremely dubious. Unlike the opposing view, skepticism doesn't have established institutions, and a multitude of "leaders". When I read that title, the only person I could think of was actually Steve McIntyre from climateaudit.org. Second, U turn?! Let's be serious. Bjørn Lomborg has always believed that global warming is one of the top global problems, but that it's too expensive to tackle it and we should spend our money on other issues instead (e.g., in his 2007 TED talk http://www.ted.com/talks/bjorn_lomborg_sets_global_priorities.html http://www.ted.com/talks/bjorn_lomborg_sets_global_prioritie...). The only difference is that now he appears to believe that global warming can be stopped with less than 0.5% of the US Federal Budget.
- anigbrowl 16y agoAh, Bjorn Lomborg gained global fame for a book published in 2001 disputing claims of climate change's long-term significance. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Skeptical_Environmentalist http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Skeptical_Environmentalist
- zeteo 16y agoRight, so the Wikipedia summary that you link to verifies what I said about his previous position: "Lomborg's main contention involves not the science of global warming [...] He [argues] that the economic cost of the restrictions [...] is impractically high [...].He proposes that the importance of global warming in terms of policy priority may be low compared to other policy issues such as fighting poverty and disease [...]."
- anigbrowl 16y agoIf you had been following the issue back then, you would recall that Lomborg spent a good part of his book disputing the significance and credibility of 'climate change,' essentially suggesting that many adherents of the the theory preferred doom-mongering to solving any present problems. He and his book were extremely popular among skeptics at the time; I got tired of being (metaphorically) beaten over the head with it. Look at the media articles archived at the bottom of the wiki article for a list of contemporary articles documenting his popularity among skeptics. By 2007 he had moderated this position substantially, but still held to the view that climate change was such a large-scale issue it was beyond our economic scope to really mitigate, and we should instead follow strategies of adaption. This latest news is noteworthy in that he is now saying that it can be mitigated, it's important enough to be mitigated, and that it won't be all that expensive to do so. But hey, don't believe me. take it from Lomborg himself: The Skeptical Environmentalist In The Skeptical Environmentalist Bjørn Lomborg challenges widely held beliefs that the global environment is progressively getting worse. Using statistical information from internationally recognized research institutes, Lomborg systematically examines a range of major environmental issues and documents that the global environment has actually improved. He supports his argument with over 2900 footnotes, allowing discerning readers to check his sources. and Cool it - The Skeptical Environmentalist's Guide To Global Warming A groundbreaking book that transforms the debate about global warming by offering a fresh perspective based on human needs as well as environmental concerns. Bjorn Lomborg argues that many of the elaborate and expensive actions now being considered to stop global warming will cost hundreds of billions of dollars, are often based on emotional rather than strictly scientific assumptions, and may very well have little impact on the world's temperature for hundreds of years. Rather than starting with the most radical procedures, Lomborg argues that we should first focus our resources on more immediate concerns [...] http://www.lomborg.com/publications/ http://www.lomborg.com/publications/ The top headline on his news page is from the Guardian: 'Bjørn Lomborg: the dissenting climate change voice who changed his tune.'
- Robin_Message 16y agoIn terms of looking at energy use and production, I cannot recommend David MacKay's excellent book Sustainable Energy – without the hot air highly enough (http://www.withouthotair.com/ http://www.withouthotair.com/, also available in dead tree form.) It's not clear that Lomborg changed his mind; it seems like he fudged the process the Copenhagen Consensus was using to get a politically acceptable result - 'Lomborg said he then decided to consider a much wider variety of policies to reduce global warming, "so it wouldn't end up at the bottom".' He's always advocated development spending should be cost-effective, which makes sense. To that end, he has always said we should ignore climate change for now and concentrate on things that are profitable now, then cut heavily latter if we need to. However, I think this is the wrong way to discount the far future. On the one hand, we have relatively little certainty about what our culture will be like in a hundred years. On the other, we are fairly certain man-made climate change is happening now and will have increasingly damaging effects. To wait for some point in the future where research and development will make the problem go away cheaply is irresponsible and naive - '"This is not about 'we have all got to live with less, wear hair-shirts and cut our carbon emissions'. It's about technologies, about realising there's a vast array of solutions."' Clever solutions appeal to clever people, and no-one wants to wear a hair-shirt, but that's not an argument against actually making some compromises. Or, to put it another way, he got five economists to make long-term predictions about sustainability and they said "increase energy efficiency, do some R&D spending, business as usual." How surprising.
- benkant 16y agoThe comments in response to that article are a microcosm of the problems we've seen with this debate. When this issue entered the public consciousness it was as if everyone had made their minds up before there was any evidence for or against AGW. There's evidence for and against, and instead of doing analysis we seem to just be slamming the table, condescendingly dismissing dissent and calling each other names. Of course there are probably people out there doing real science, but from what I can see (ok, from the media) it's people making up their minds and then finding the data to back it up. That's not science. I thought Lomborg's initial stance was refreshing. Hopefully it's just the media making drama out of it and real work is being done to get to the bottom of it. Here's to hope.