2 ms·
> We don’t actually know if there’s a singularity within the event horizon. Not if we take quantum effects into account, no. I was describing what classical GR
by pdonis 9y ago
> We don’t actually know if there’s a singularity within the event horizon.
Not if we take quantum effects into account, no. I was describing what classical GR predicts. I agree that GR also predicts that it should break down in the regime close to the singularity.
It's also worth noting that there is a school of thought among physicists that says that quantum effects are non-negligible even at the horizon of a black hole of stellar mass or larger. This is the "firewall" debate that is currently ongoing. I personally don't find the arguments in favor of a "firewall" convincing, but it is an area of ongoing debate.
- IntronExon 9y agoAgreed on all points, and the firewall is interesting, but I can’t see how it doesn’t somehow create a privileged frame of reference. It’s still very cool/terrifying, even in the already notoriously cool/terrifying realm of black holes.
- qubex 9y agoThe whole controversy about the firewall hypothesis is that I’d does create a privileged frame of reference, directly contradicting general relativity (that indirectly forms the basis for predicting the firewall’s existence).