4 ms·
An elaboration: Maybe folks have never done this exercise before, and it is instructive and won't step on anyone's toes, so let's go over the rankings for [Sco
by patio11 16y ago
An elaboration:
Maybe folks have never done this exercise before, and it is instructive and won't step on anyone's toes, so let's go over the rankings for [Scott Pilgrim review] and guess why they rank
#1: Rotten Tomatoes. Megabrand in the movie review space, plenty of content, and they aggregate all the other reviews you could possibly want.
#2: http://www.ugo.com/movies/comic-con-2010-scott-pilgrim-review http://www.ugo.com/movies/comic-con-2010-scott-pilgrim-revie... In a just world, this would be probably #1. They have a comic book design for the review. They have better images than most of the reviews, which just recycle the same publicity kit, and they integrate them better. They link to content readers will find quite compelling, such as "Every Video Game Reference in the Scott Pilgrim Comics." A random newspaper reviewer in Kansas isn't chasing that stuff down.
#3: 1UP review of the video game. Three words: "query deserves diversity", which is Google's way of saying "Hey, maybe they actually didn't want a review of Scott Pilgrim the movie. That query was ambiguous. Maybe they meant the videogame instead. In that case, we should surface a few results on the front page so they don't get frustrated." It isn't a particularly compelling review, but it is a less competitive niche and a noted brand.
#4: Internal Google callout for Google News results. This is their sop to a dying industry which has worse problems than you ever will, for similar reasons which are exacerbated by their cost structure. The current best ranked review from Google News is from the University of Dayton's school newspaper. It is as good as one would expect.
#5: Wiki. More pagerank than God. Very, very internally optimized. Content is a poorly written but comprehensive plot summary.
#6 ~ #10: ... you get the idea.
Now, I'm not going to mention your site if you don't want to mention it, but I read your review. Do you have a sense of where a blind oracle with perfect knowledge of content quality would put it in these results? I have an opinion. Be that as it may, can you economically make your review look more like the #2 guys here? If not, why are you competing with them?
- paraschopra 16y agoI wish I could upvote your indvidual descriptions. > #5: Wiki. More pagerank than God. This one would have got most Karma. Wikipedia is an excellent example of self-generating pagerank. More people link to it because anybody can edit it, hence would be "fair" and "comprehensive". And just because a particular Wiki article gets popular, it starts getting more attention (by experts) and hence becomes fair, comprehensive and detailed. The cycle repeats.
- mattmanser 16y ago#4: Internal Google callout for Google News results. This is their sop to a dying industry Google is still pretty awful for breaking news and keeping out-of-date content around. This result is actually more "our results might be aged as we're suddenly seeing more searches than normal". As dismissive as you might be of traditional media, people want to see their results over 2 year old blogs for current news.
- rkalla 16y agoPatrick, After almost 5 years of doing this and thinking the tide would change "any day now" for the better, I can see now that it will never change... sans bits of income here and there, I will never support my family doing this or create the working environment I've always gunned for, for a few dedicated authors. That pretty much blows. Your replies couldn't be more detailed or to the point... or right. I appreciate that... and I might add that you really have a way with words, I agree with the other replies saying you should write this stuff up if you don't already... or give advice to startups or something. I don't have the time/resources to compete with UGO, Tomatoes or 1UP. And no, I have no idea what it would really take to differentiate myself enough to offer that unique pizzaz to cause someone to bookmark and always come back for their movie reviews (or toilet reviews... or whatever the heck I review that day). You described it pretty succinctly and to answer the nail in the coffin: "Why are you competing with them?", I was never trying to... I was trying to do something I loved and turn it into a profession. You know, that crap about "do what you love and the money will follow?" -- but now that I look through your points I realize that I have to face the fact that I am competing with these guys... in as much as I'm trying to make money from this, so I have to get my racing jersey and stand at the starting blocks. I'm gonna read through the rest of the replies now. For what it's worth your words have helped a random dude on the internet take some time to think about what the hell he wants out of all this.
- patio11 16y agoYou can still make money publishing on the Internet. I despair of it for generic commodity content at non spam scales, but half of my SEO buddies are essentially niche publishers. (I probably can't name specific niches, but let's say "Christmas cookies" or "green DIY household projects" or "classic bicycle parts" for rough example of the scale.) My business is niche publishing if you squint at it: I compete directly with Scholastic Publishing on one very narrow product category, bury them at it, and monetize with ads for a related niche software product.
- robg 16y agoto bookmark and always come back for their movie reviews (or toilet reviews... or whatever the heck I review that day) Is your content organized around anything in particular? Only reviews? What's your branding besides you? Care to share?