3 ms·
A criticism by way of criticism of an article pushing it - https://fair.org/home/the-radical-dishonesty-of-david-brooks/ https://fair.org/home/the-radical-dish
by majormajor 9y ago
A criticism by way of criticism of an article pushing it - https://fair.org/home/the-radical-dishonesty-of-david-brooks/ https://fair.org/home/the-radical-dishonesty-of-david-brooks... - from a "co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research in Washington, DC" FWIW.
The overall thrust seems pretty damning (given how much technology improved recently, why hasn't that turned into more income and leisure time improvements for many?), enough to seriously dampen my interest in the book itself:
> The problem with the Brooks/Pinker story is that we expect the economy/people to get richer through time. After all, technology and education improve. In the ’50s, we didn’t have the Internet, cell phones and all sorts of other goodies. In fact, at the start of the ’50s, we didn’t even have the polio vaccine.
> The question is not whether we are better off today than we were 60 years ago. It would be incredible if we were not better off. The question is by how much.
> In the ’50s, wages and incomes for ordinary families were rising at a rate of close to 2 percent annually. In the last 45 years, they have barely risen at all.
-- from a bit later:
> Should we celebrate this reduction in poverty rates over the last 33 years? Well, the [child] poverty rate had fallen from 27.3 percent in 1959 (the first year for this data series) to 14.0 percent in 1969. That’s a drop of 13.3 percentage points in just ten years. The net direction in the last 47 years has been upward.
- tryitnow 9y agoI agree with the criticism of Pinker's use of data. However, I think his main thesis still stands: humanism and science are winning strategies for human flourishing. I think this his main idea (the benefits of science and humanism) is an idea worth exploring and defending, but I don't think collecting a bunch of measures of progress and saying "see, humanism + science works!" is the best way of doing it. I'd rather see someone approach the problem by focusing on what is lacking, what are the major outstanding problems and then demonstrate that these problems persist because we have not attempted to tackle them using science to guide practice and humanism to guide our values. This approach seems more mature and sophisticated than just saying "gee whiz! look at all the goodies we got now!"
- wpasc 9y agoNot meaning to offend, but you're kind of leading in to exactly why Pinker writes the book. > (the benefits of science and humanism) is an idea worth exploring and defending He explores and defends those pursuits. > I don't think collecting a bunch of measures of progress and saying "see, humanism + science works!" is the best way of doing it. It's at the very least an objective method that doesn't rely on flimsier propositions. You use the phrase "measures of progress" which are a great way to measure progress... > I'd rather see someone approach the problem by focusing on what is lacking, what are the major outstanding problems and then demonstrate that these problems persist because we have not attempted to tackle them using science to guide practice and humanism to guide our values. He never disputes that there are still issues, he's just saying that if you only ever focused on things that are missing, you might lose an appreciation for the progress humanity has made. If you only watched the news (which he specifically rails against), you'd think we were going to hell in a hand basket. Of course we still have issues, but to buy into the "end is nigh" mentality espoused by the media and plenty of people (and some commenters here!) would be to ignore a wide variety of indications that humanity's scientific and social progress are improving.