6 ms·
I would pay cash money to read an interview with a higher-up about what the fuck is happening at google with all these chat apps. Tech Journalists, somebody, a
by komali2 9y ago
I would pay cash money to read an interview with a higher-up about what the fuck is happening at google with all these chat apps.
Tech Journalists, somebody, ask a C suite or even just a team lead, "why are there fifteen chat apps and what is the google chat app long term strategy." Then link your patreon.
Where are these kids hiding? I'm in South Bay all the time - which bar do I need to and who do I need to feed alcohol to until I get answers? It's to me the world's greatest unsolved mystery.
- JorgeGT 9y agoGoogle's chat strategy is the Mary Celeste of our time.
- thrill 9y agoThese days I feel they're sailing on the Gitche Gumee.
- remir 9y agoAlso, where's Sundar? I feel like he should answer that question.
- jgalt212 9y agoSundar's main job is keeping the FTC and EU at bay. All other matters are rounding errors.
- gervase 9y agoBased on the article from earlier today [0], my new theory is that engineers at Google have realized that the best way to get promoted is to launch a big, shiny product (regardless of need, market fit, etc), and the easiest way to get a big, shiny product is to just re-launch the same projects over, and over, and over. Who cares about long-term product strategy as long as you get your promotion? Seems like a classic case of employees optimizing for local maxima, at the expense of the global maximum. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16483241 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16483241
- justicezyx 9y agoPlease stop forcing business decisions on engineers. Especially given https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16483241 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16483241
- gervase 9y agoNot at all! If that came off as a criticism of the engineers, it wasn't - it's a well-known phenomenon for poorly-managed employees (and/or poor process), since humans will naturally (and fairly!) optimize for their own personal success.
- Declanomous 9y agoI've understood this to be the explanation for years now. I'm not sure if this is common knowledge, but it's what the Google Voice community has come up with to explain why we constantly get shoved to new platforms that absolutely suck. I mean seriously, every time google voice moves to a new platform it loses several features. It's one of the reasons why I avoid Google whenever possible. I went with Office 365 Enterprise over the Google solution for my business, and I use Linux as my primary desktop. Do you know how badly you have to mess up for a Linux user to look at your offerings and say "Well, I trust Microsoft more"?
- georgemcbay 9y agoI remember when I would be excited/happy when Google would acquire some software/service that I use. Surely this means the project will be well supported for the foreseeable future... why else would Google pay XXX million...?! These days the same announcements just fill me with dread and I expect the the software/service to be shutdown or gimped to the point of worthlessness within a year.
- 013a 9y agoAre there any examples of core G-Suite products Google has deprecated? I can't think of any. Reminder that "Core G-Suite" is an official designation, not something I just made up. Right now, their Core G-Suite products are: Gmail, Drive, Docs, Sheets, Slides, Forms, Sites, Calendars, Hangouts, Hangouts Chat, Hangouts Meet, Plus, Keep, Vault, and Jamboard.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I would pay cash money to read an interview with a higher-up about what the fuck is happening at google with all these chat apps. I suspect there are two main reasons: (1) Google will often put two products in the same market where one is relatively low-risk and designed to fit perceived current needs, and the other is aimed where Google thinks the market will be going longer term (and often is part of the strategy to draw the market in that direction.) (2) Google doesn't see “chat app” as a single coherent market that (at least in the short window) has a single solution, but several overlapping markets, and has multiple chat apps for the same reason GM has multiple automobiles.
- leddt 9y ago> and has multiple chat apps for the same reason GM has multiple automobiles. But all of GM's cars (and their competitors) can use the same roads. All those chat apps with their own user bases and incompatible protocols create isolated bubbles, ultimately harming all of them.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> But all of GM's cars (and their competitors) can use the same roads. And all of Google's messaging apps use the same internet. (If you mean to suggest endpoint compatibility, “parking spots” might be better, though that's not entirely true even of the cars, but certainly more true than the analogous thing would.be of Google messaging apps.)
- iriei283 9y agoI’m shocked it’s so elusive to this crowd They want inputs to their machine learning. Who cares what the GUI looks like? They can reskin the same backend to look like 50 chat apps. They’re generating interest with launches and keep ML input coming Google isn’t a product-centric company It’s annoying to the public who are used to going down to Target and buying a toaster. They built a money making analytics machine and need inputs to analyze Tech business models all rely on users using their shit. That’s all there is to Google’s interests
- throw_away_chat 9y agoTheir strategy seems very reasonable to me. - Duo was a bet that stand alone video chat app would be awesome. - Google+ found some traction in groups, so that team built Spaces to extend the organic behavior. They could have built Spaces inside another product, but Google prefers to keep risky projects segregated from each other. That way one project failure does not kill the other one. - Pushing proprietary messaging too hard into Android could anger partners (like carriers who make money from SMS) and raise anti-trust concerns (see recent Android troubles in EU). Because of this, you might want a stand alone SMS app. - The messaging market is huge, and Hangouts is not that successful (even though people in tech use it). Hangouts was mismanaged, unloved for years, has a huge install base, and has some tricky core/structural/infra problems. This made it difficult to change and iterate on. Someone made a judgement call that it would be easier/faster/better to launch Allo than to extend Hangouts.
- azinman2 9y agoSince when is it ok for a company like Google not to have a top-down strategy that they work hard to get right once, instead of launching parallel competing projects because it's "easier/faster/better"?
- throw_away_chat 9y agoThere's no rule/law that says businesses can't compete with themselves. Taking multiple independent bets seems like a reasonable way to put a lot of resources into a market that you are weak in. This is similar to how startups beat big companies, a small focused group sometimes beat a big one. If you fund multiple small groups, you multiply your chances of finding a winner. Microsoft famously killed its Courier project because it competed with Windows. Its now a decade later, and they are still way behind in tablet market share. Maybe if they had built both Windows for tablets and Courier, they would've done better. All that said, Google has done a poor job of earning their user's trust after killing things like Reader. I believe the execs learned their lesson there.
- crowbahr 9y agoI love Allo and all but it still seems like entirely ripping out the android code base of Hangouts and replacing it with Allo's style would've been better. The cost of fragmentation isn't worth simply not writing the new code base, I'd think.
- yorby 9y ago"Throw a bunch of stuff at the wall and see what sticks" is probably the strategy... because Google acts like oil and makes everything fall off the wall in that space.
- rixed 9y agoIf it is already erroneous to expect a single individual to act as a rational economic agent, why should a rational economic behavior be expected from a loose aggregation of individuals? What I've learnt from working in such companies is that individual career trajectory and team politics is the real focus of anyone attention, and that the external world appears as abstract and distant to them as these internal manoeuvers are opaque to outsiders.