2 ms·
> My point being that the "hierarchy" in wine is, to my mind, at least a local optimum or close to it. The problem I have is with the implication (not made by
by lisper 9y ago
> My point being that the "hierarchy" in wine is, to my mind, at least a local optimum or close to it.
The problem I have is with the implication (not made by you, but made by the wine industry in general) that if your tastes don't align with this hierarchy that there is something wrong with you. There isn't. My wife and I are semi-serious oenophiles. We drink about 100 bottles/year. We have a 200+ bottle cellar, which tops out around $150 (I refuse to pay more than that for a bottle of fermented fruit juice on general principle). We've tried wine from all over the world, and we keep coming back to California reds. We like jammy, fruity deep dark reds, and California does them better than anywhere else.
One of our favorite wines is Barefoot cabernet, which retails for about $6 a bottle. We discovered it in a blind horizontal tasting of California cabs, where the Barefoot was put in as kind of a joke. But among 12 people participating in the tasting, all of them (including us) picked the Barefoot as their #1 or #2 favorite of the lineup. The top-end wine, a Silver Oak, came in dead last. 20 years later, we still like it. (We had a similar experience years later with a delicious white that was served to us and six other people at a B&B that turned out to be Gallo Rhine Wine in a box.)
Despite this, we would still be a little embarrassed to serve Barefoot to guests. To some extent, wine is a Veblen good. It really is more than just fermented fruit juice. It's steeped in history and ceremony. There's value in the sound of a popping cork and in the joy of exploration and discovery. But the most important thing is to never ever let someone else tell you what you're supposed to like.
- coldtea 9y ago>My point being that the "hierarchy" in wine is, to my mind, at least a local optimum or close to it. The problem I have is with the implication (not made by you, but made by the wine industry in general) that if your tastes don't align with this hierarchy that there is something wrong with you. It's very democratic and individualistic (and fashionable) to say that there isn't, but I like to entertain the idea that many times, there is. Even in matters of taste, people can be crude and ignorant -- and oftentimes, they have little familiarity with a field to be anything else anyway. This is not the same as them saying 2+2=5, they are not wrong in the absolute sense, but they're still wrong in a similar way within their country's or global culture -- they same as someone that openly farts during a first date diner is doing something wrong.
- lisper 9y ago> Even in matters of taste, people can be crude and ignorant That is certainly true. But it does not follow that there is a universal quality metric for everyone. Whatever your tastes are, you can get there from a position of ignorance, or you can get there from a position of knowledge. But just because you got where you are with knowledge doesn't mean you're going to end up in the same place as everyone else.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>To some extent, wine is a Veblen good. To me it feels like it's 100% Veblen over $120 and partially Veblen if it's > $25. IIRC in blind taste tests ordinary people tend to prefer cheaper wines and even the most obsessive oenophiles and sommeliers will not show consistent preferences for bottles that cost more than about $120.