3 ms·
That does seem like a direction to go that might work, but I'm not sure it's the only possible way to run a successful league. That's essentially the "socialist
by _delirium 16y ago
That does seem like a direction to go that might work, but I'm not sure it's the only possible way to run a successful league. That's essentially the "socialist" way of running a league, from the perspective of the league itself as an ecosystem: central planning, redistribution of income, limits on competition between teams (mainly on salary competition). The goal is to make an egalitarian society of teams where everyone has an equal playing field, unsullied by capitalist considerations, and nobody can "buy" success due to being richer, because that's more interesting for fans.
Europe's soccer leagues have gone in the exact opposite, hypercapitalist direction, though, where teams bid huge amounts for players, compete vigorously for media contracts, any tycoon can pour as much of their own money as they want into a team (just like, in the US, they can pour money into election campaigns and whatnot), and so on. In some leagues, teams can actually even "fail" if they fail to compete well enough (in the sporting sense), being relegated to lower leagues if they don't win enough, and replaced by the top teams from the lower leagues, who get to move up. That model also seems massively successful as a sport.
- mattmaroon 16y agoWell, I can't say it's the only possible solution, but of the many that have been tried, it's the one that works best, and it's the sole reason the NFL has achieved such dominance. Socialism works great for small groups, such as 32 team owners. FWIW, NFL teams don't share all revenue. They still compete on ticket and merchandise sales. They also get bonuses for winning. Some teams profit much more than others, so it's still very capitalist. In the end what the NFL realized that the MLB didn't (and the NBA did but couldn't enforce for political reasons) is that what fans love is parity. A league with parity will eventually eclipse one without, every time. Parity only comes from a salary cap. Otherwise the teams that make the most (without true socialism, some teams will always have far more revenue than others) will simply buy the best players, as the Yankees do, leading to a self-perpetuating dynasty. You might be able to get there with incentive structures instead, allocating large enough amounts of money to winning teams and fining perpetually losing teams, but I'm always leery of that as incentives can be gamed. A salary cap is quick, easy, effective, and unless a team flagrantly violates it by funneling money to a player under the table (which is rare since not many NFL owners want to risk their ownership) totally enforced.
- Travis 16y ago@mattmaroon a salary cap has worked in football, but the CBAs and relative strengths of players unions are very different between the sports. It wouldn't work in baseball (read my post above). Worth repeating the Gammons quote: "In those 30 years, 20 different teams have won World Series titles, and it would likely be 21 without the 1994 strike that cost the sport’s best team -- the Montreal Expos -- a chance to win it all. In those 30 years, 14 different teams have won the Super Bowl, 13 have won the Stanley Cup, nine have won the NBA championship."