4 ms·
This is a pretty good article, though it might be hard for people to grasp who aren't already keen observers of the wine industry., I personally like the so-ca
by cmrdporcupine 9y ago
This is a pretty good article, though it might be hard for people to grasp who aren't already keen observers of the wine industry.,
I personally like the so-called "natural" wines mostly because they are _different_ in a world of same-same. I don't buy the 'natural' designator so much, but I've made wines from my own vineyard in this 'orange wine' style; they are difficult wines to consume but rewarding in their own way. But I use sulfites, so they're not "natural".
The "international style" of wines that has taken over everything since the success of California and Australia on the world market (and the ossification of European wines behind ridiculous regulations) becomes boring to some after a few years of consumption. I have no interest in drinking yet another Cabernet Sauvignon, And as an amateur wine maker in a difficult climate, I can't grow that anyways.
Frankly, if these wine makers in Europe were truly concerned with going eco/natural, they'd eschew the use of the pure Vitis vinifera species and the classic clonal varieties which are sometimes over a 1000 years old (the actual individual plant! cloned millions of times!) and require a continual chemical cocktail of intensive fungicides to merely survive. They're horribly mal-adapted to the actual 'natural' world and die horribly if not constantly coddled. No, instead they'd grow modern hybrids with North American species which have superior fungal resistance and better cold hardiness to boot. In the dry European climate North American hybrids would require almost no spraying. But the EU has made them illegal. For basically awful essentialist quasi-"racist" (to abuse the term) reasons.
But as this article points out, the contradiction here is that "natural" is by no means natural -- there is a peculiar European obsession with a 'pure tradition' which manifests in wine in this constant obsession with traditional varieties and techniques -- when in fact wine as we know it is an entirely Modernist invention. Sure, wine was consumed in the middle ages and Roman times -- but we'd hate those wines, even the natural wine lovers would.
- dejv 9y agoHybrids are not illegal at the EU, those hybrids (say Hibernal or hundreds of other) which are created by cross polination of vitis vinifera with another specie within vitis familly are fine. What is banned is growing non-vinifera vines. Fungal resistance of those grapes are much better than old varietals, but you still need couple of sprays most of the years. The problem with those varietals lay in quality of wine, which is usually not on the par of traditional varietal. Anyway: being Bio/Eco/Natural certified has nothing to do with spraying or adding sulfites (which are created during fermentation anyway). It can mean anything, most of the winemakers go with use just little amount of SO2 and bentonite or egg whites for clarification. No selected yeasts or artifical additive. In vineyard there are many different kind of inputs you have to use, you usually go with sulphur and copper, but there are many other allowed preparations (from herbal teas, seaweed based stuff, yeast derivative kind of stuff).
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoWhat you're talking about (vinifera-vinifera crosses) is not typically called a hybrid but a cross. Though I'm confused because you mention Hibernal, which is an inter-specific hybrid. Except the Germans have done this sneaky trick of calling interspecific hybrids vinifera in certain circumstances to get around their own stupid laws. Staying high vinifera content is pointless because the vitis vinifera species is the problem. It has basically no resistance to the fungal problems that are out there in the real world, which are mostly introduced from North America. But regardless, when I start seeing appellation wines with hybrids in them, I'll be flabergasted. The perception of 'quality' you're speaking of is a subjective/cultural thing. I grow about an acre of modern hybrids. And I do my own hybrid crosses. So I know quite a bit about this. (EDITED for clarity on Hibernal and some grammar)
- myrandomcomment 9y agoThanks for that explanation. What area do you grow in?
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoSouthern Ontario, hobby farm just above the Niagara Escarpment. About USDA hardiness zone 5. Just a hobby, grow a smattering of different things, mostly hybrids bred by the University of Minnesota ("Marquette" chiefly)
- myrandomcomment 9y agoIntersting. Just did some reading on that grape. I am going to have to try to find a bottle of it try. My wife and I have a large wine collection and we always love finding new varieties we have never tried.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoShelburne Winery in Vermont makes a reasonable one. With hybrids, you're always fighting acidity and low tannins, so the wine maker really needs to be excellent. They are not forgiving grapes, and because they are often pitched as cheaper bulk grapes (because they are easier to grow) they are often made into low quality cheap country wines, sweet wines, etc. Which gives them an even worse reputation.
- lazerpants 9y agoI'd recommend you check out Chambers Street Wines if you haven't. They specialize in natural wines with an emphasis on European ones, both traditional and avant-garde. Easy shipping to most places too. https://www.chambersstwines.com/ https://www.chambersstwines.com/
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoYeah unfortunately I live in Ontario, with its prohibition-era mentality about liquor sales and production. I can only buy what is blessed (and taxed and marked up) by our very opinionated Liquor Control Board. They're also doing their best to kill interesting or odd wines produced domestically, too.
- lazerpants 9y agoOh yeah, that's rough. I'll admit to having a strong affection for Wayne Gretsky Estates cabernet though. Mostly because its a total oddity in the US. It also tastes okay.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoThe Wayne Gretzky thing is just yet another label of Andrew Peller, one of the two specially-blessed mega corps that get additional privileges from the Ontario gov't (can have their own offsite winery retail stores, are allowed to import foreign grapes and sell them as Ontario product, etc.). But they're one of the better labels here. The path to financial success in Ontario's wine industry seems to be to dump a pile of money in and produce an OK product that doesn't rock the boat too much (same 4 or 5 grape varieties that everyone else here uses) with a fancy new name for a few years and then sell out to Vincorp or Andrew Peller and then get out. But we have a wanna-be AOC system here (the VQA) that stops you from doing anything interesting. You can't even put the words "Ontario" or "Estate" or "Niagara Escarpment" on the bottle's label if you grow anything other than their mandated list of approved grape varietals (no new hybrids! has to be a fancy European grape that will probably just die here or make mediocre wine anyways). B.C. has a healthier wine industry. Smaller minimum acreage requirements, more experimentation. And there's some interesting new things coming out of Quebec and Nova Scotia. I'd like to have a winery some day. But not in this Can't Do province.