3 ms·
But doesn't that eugenics happen naturally already? Like people of similar race, centers of interest, character or intelligence having a higher likelihood to fo
by cm2187 9y ago
But doesn't that eugenics happen naturally already? Like people of similar race, centers of interest, character or intelligence having a higher likelihood to form a couple and if DNA has anything to do with these characters, re-enforce these traits in their children? All that will change is that people will be aware of it.
- matte_black 9y agoAgreed, people like to pretend eugenics doesn’t happen for whatever reason, but people aren’t just breeding randomly or fairly. They are consciously selecting partners based on traits they like, essentially genes. We have been OK with this for a long time.
- iovrthoughtthis 9y agoWe're sort of reducing evolution to a hill climbing algorithm then if we only start taking into account genetics (which, being easier and faster to measure we probably will). To overcome local minima though you need large sources of perturbation while looking for solutions to approximate anything close to a "global minima". Evolution also automatically focuses it's attention on traits that survive better as the environment changes. Will our assessments continually assess the environment and make changes based on that? Can that ever be truly representative of gene expression that is definitely better for survival? So long as there is constant conflict around this and one side doesn't outright win, I'm ok with it tbh.
- matte_black 9y agoThe struggle of humans today is mostly social survival, not survival in nature. Evolution is not optimal for social fitness because societal factors change much more rapidly than what natural selection alone can respond to. There may be some conflict over this at first, but humans born in a post-eugenics era will not share your view and will likely dismiss it.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Evolution is not optimal for social fitness because societal factors change much more rapidly than what natural selection alone can respond to This sounds like a reasonable hypothesis. Any sources?
- matte_black 9y agoNo. Propose an experiment to be done?
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoThis question has been pondered for a long time [1]. TL; DR Nothing about evolution precludes it from selecting for social fitness. [1] http://joelvelasco.net/teaching/167win10/Hamilton64b-thegeneticalevolutionofsocialbehavior.pdf http://joelvelasco.net/teaching/167win10/Hamilton64b-thegene...
- quotemstr 9y ago> Evolution is not optimal for social fitness because societal factors change much more rapidly than what natural selection alone can respond to. Huh? Evolution produces social organizations of all sorts. Do you think the complex social systems of higher primates come out of their reading Derrida or something? Evolution doesn't operate on social organizations directly, but it can certainly select for the brain structures and personality traits that tend, over time, to result in successful organizations. Why would that not be the case? Any time you have descent with modification and some selection function, you get evolution.
- faitswulff 9y agoNo, not really. Eugenics includes ideas like forced sterilization of "undesirables." I doubt you're advocating for that. You could argue that the opposite of what you describe is happening. health tech means that many selective forces like congenital diseases and birth defects have less of an effect. Online dating also seems to have increased interracial dating. What _is_ happening and has scary ramifications for society is called assortative mating, which normally happens along educational and financial lines: https://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21595972-how-sexual-equality-increases-gap-between-rich-and-poor-households-sex-brains-and https://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21595972-how-se...
- rayiner 9y agoAssortive mating is just mating. Mating has always been based on fitness; the metrics are just now changing.
- colmvp 9y ago> Online dating also seems to have increased interracial dating. Anecdotal but as an Asian male this hasn’t been the case for me at all. I posted my stats on HN a few months ago but from thousands of profile interactions I’ve had practically zero mutual interest from non-Asians. That’s not an exaggeration either, I literally have a zero percent approval rate from white women, the majority ethnicity in my current city. Every single Asian male friend that I know of didn’t meet their non-Asian SO online dating, but met them in person from work/school/group events. Likewise, every non-Asian female I’ve ever dated I met offline first.
- faitswulff 9y agoSince I'm also a straight Asian male, I can empathize: https://www.npr.org/2018/01/09/575352051/least-desirable-how-racial-discrimination-plays-out-in-online-dating https://www.npr.org/2018/01/09/575352051/least-desirable-how... When I was dating, it seemed like anyone interested in me was either an otaku or a weeaboo :p However, the data regarding interracial dating says otherwise: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/609091/first-evidence-that-online-dating-is-changing-the-nature-of-society/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/609091/first-evidence-tha... Note that the future may not have arrived in all places equally at the same time.