3 ms·
Using DNA to predict the likelihood of a behavior or IQ is on a collision course with the ghost in the machine doctrine, which assumes our intelligence, charact
by cm2187 9y ago
Using DNA to predict the likelihood of a behavior or IQ is on a collision course with the ghost in the machine doctrine, which assumes our intelligence, character, what we become is solely or predominantly the result of our environment/culture/education. I wonder how far research in that field can go before it is decided that the potential outcome would be politically unacceptable.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- quotemstr 9y agoModern-day lysenkoism disappoints me. The blank slate model is thoroughly discredited, and people as eminent as Pinker have written extensively about it. While you can still find plenty of blank slate support in polite society, those espousing the idea are operating under something akin to religious faith.
- crowbahr 9y agoI'm genuinely curious: where can I read the disproving of tabula rasa? Are you meaning moral blank slate, intellectual blank slate or some combination of them?
- prepend 9y agoWhat knowledge is unethical to research and discover? Do you want to know what impact genes have (lots and lots with current knowledge)? Or pretend it doesn’t? Knowing will let us take steps as society to equalize fairly (improve below mean hopefully).
- AstralStorm 9y agoYou meant move the median up, right? Make the distribution more skewed to the right? Otherwise you're depriving some people of potential and help. Remember that mean is not the determinant.
- prepend 9y agoI think it should be used to improve all below the mean, not necessarily median. In the since of there are extreme positive outliers that should result in even more research and help to those below the mean. I specifically meant the average intelligence, not the median human. Although I assumed that the mean would be higher than the median since IQ has a lower boundary of zero. If median is higher than mean then I agree with you.