3 ms·
You skipped a step. Yes, the general relativity prediction of a black hole is solid once it exists. But you have to construct that black hole in the first place
by ars 9y ago
You skipped a step. Yes, the general relativity prediction of a black hole is solid once it exists. But you have to construct that black hole in the first place. And it's that part that's on shaky ground.
- dwaltrip 9y agoThis seem to be a contrarian view. Do you have any sources you can share with us?
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoYou seem to have missed the part where podiki offered the object at the center of the galaxy as evidence that a black hole currently exists. So you're arguing against the evidence when you say (over and over and over) that black holes can't form.
- podiki 9y agoThere are indeed people who closely study the process of forming a black hole from collapsing matter, hoping to understand things like the singularity and event horizon. I have not ever heard of any good results that show that a black hole for some reason cannot be formed, but I'm sure people are investigating. This would be very surprising if found, and there doesn't seem to be any evidence against black holes actually forming. So the mainstream, and as far as we can tell, correct, view is that black holes can, do, and have formed.