3 ms·
> No amount of pressure can prevent a black hole from forming And yet suns with far more mass than is needed to make a black hole exist. Because simple heat pr
by ars 9y ago
> No amount of pressure can prevent a black hole from forming
And yet suns with far more mass than is needed to make a black hole exist. Because simple heat pressure keeps the black hole from forming.
Remember that the black hole doesn't just suddenly appear - to have enormous gravity the density must go up. If you prevent that from ever happening you can stop the black hole from ever starting in the first place.
You are talking assuming the black hole is already there, and saying quark degeneracy can't resist that, but you forget the black hole has to form first.
> No, it doesn't. It just means that light signals from very near the horizon take a long time to get out.
It also means mass takes a long (infinite) time to get in. So the black hole may never form.
- podiki 9y agoRegarding your last point: that depends on your reference frame. From the outside it does appear to take "forever" to get into a black hole, but if you were the one falling in...it happens much quicker, certainly not taking an infinite amount of time.
- ars 9y agoThat's true. But it's things from the outside that are falling in, and that make a black hole. Since they take an infinite amount of time to fall in, the black hole never forms in the first place. (I'm less sure about this paragraph, but I believe that) An object falling in also never sees a black hole, since the other things falling in are dilated relative to him, so there's still not enough mass to make a black hole, even for the object falling in.
- saagarjha 9y ago> But it's things from the outside that are falling in, and that make a black hole. Since they take an infinite amount of time to fall in, the black hole never forms in the first place. See this excellent answer on Physics StackExchange: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/5031/can-black-holes-form-in-a-finite-amount-of-time#146852 https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/5031/can-black-h.... In a nutshell (if I'm interpreting this correctly), yes, to an outside observer you never observe the black hole form since it would take an infinite amount of time for light signals from the newly formed black hole to reach you. However, to any observers that fell into the black hole (and so were in the same frame of reference), the black hole would form in finite time.
- monocasa 9y agoExcept Hawking radiation means that it doesn't exist for an infinite amount of time. So an observer falling in would just see it fizzle away as they get closer to it.
- pdonis 9y agoEven in the presence of Hawking radiation, this statement is not correct. An observer falling in would fall right through the horizon and be destroyed in the singularity; then, much, much later (something like 10^70 years for a black hole of 10 solar masses), the hole would be fully evaporated away by Hawking radiation and some of the light rays in that outgoing Hawking radiation would carry information about the observer falling through the horizon 10^70 years before.
- short_sells_poo 9y agoYou seem to misunderstand the way an event horizon works. From the infalling object's (and the hole's) reference frame, the object crosses the event horizon in finite time and falls into the singularity. It is only from an observer's perspective that the object never seems to cross the horizon.
- ars 9y agoNo, that's exactly what I understand. But we don't care about the infalling object. We care about the observer, because any infalling object initially is an observer, and because we (us humans) are observing the black holes. Since from an observers POV nothing can actually fall into the black hole, no black hole can form. The fact that an infalling object reaches the black hole makes no difference to us. Because of time dilation, we can observe no black holes. So our telescopes will never see a black hole.
- teamonkey 9y ago> Since from an observers POV nothing can actually fall into the black hole, no black hole can form. The event horizon isn't really a physical boundary in that sense. It's the mathematical boundary at which, according to general relativity, a particle must have velocity equal to the speed of light in order to escape. A density change inside the star can change the size and shape of that boundary without things falling into it in the usual sense. In the same way, a density wave can 'travel' faster than the speed of sound (or light) in a medium because the wave is a mathematical construct that emerges from a physical situation.
- grkvlt 9y agoA better way of thinking about the event horizon is that it is the boundary beyond which events happening cannot be assigned a 'when' in our universe - i.e. the object falling 'in' to the black hole is never seen to pass this horizon, but to the object it seems that they do, however those events happen to it after an infinite time in our universe, i.e. never, due to time dilation. The contents of a black hole are the events that occur outside/after our universe relative to that boundary. I found these explanations on an awesome PBS youtube video [0] about black holes and space-time. 0. https://youtu.be/vNaEBbFbvcY https://youtu.be/vNaEBbFbvcY
- dragonwriter 9y ago> But it's things from the outside that are falling in, and that make a black hole. Since they take an infinite amount of time to fall in, the black hole never forms in the first place. They only take an infinite time to fall in once a black hole has formed; OTOH, unless I misunderstand, the time would asymptotically approach infinity up to that point, which seems to have a similar effect.
- pdonis 9y ago> They only take an infinite time to fall in once a black hole has formed No, they don't. See my other comments upthread.
- 4ad 9y agoYou keep repeating this misconception even though you have been repeatedly been corrected over and over again. What you don't seem to realize is that the choice of coordinates in GR is arbitrary and local. There are types of coordinates that are singular at the event horizon, and there are others which are not. This has nothing to do with infalling vs. the exterior observer. You seem to think that time is somehow fixed for the exterior observer, but that couldn't be further from the truth. This is really, really trivial and really basic GR. I don't really know what to suggest apart from MTW[1], except maybe this basic course from http://theoreticalminimum.com/courses/general-relativity/2012/fall http://theoreticalminimum.com/courses/general-relativity/201.... If you understand what Penrose diagram are, and how to compute them, the answer is immediately obvious. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitation_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitation_(book)
- r-bryan 9y agoI can recommend: Bernard F. Schultz, _A first course in general relativity_ It's accessible to undergrads! (who have studied SR, vector calculus, electrostatics).
- podiki 9y agoAlso, did we forget of LIGO's recent observations of black hole mergers, in perfect agreement with the GR calculations? Nothing else (known, or proposed) can match that.
- PeterisP 9y ago"If you prevent that from ever happening" is the key part here. There's no magic that can prevent that - there are a number of factors (e.g. heat pressure, rotation, neutron degeneracy pressure, etc), all of which we can estimate, and which generally increase as the star shrinks/collapses. An active main-sequence star can be very large without collapsing, as the nuclear reaction inside sustains its size. But for a neutron star the limit is much lower - under a certain mass limit, the stable size is still sufficiently large, but above a certain mass a neutron star can not be larger than the expected event horizon, there's nothing sufficient to prevent the collapse from happening, and it will collapse to a black hole.
- zaarn 9y ago>And yet suns with far more mass than is needed to make a black hole exist. Because simple heat pressure keeps the black hole from forming. A star has internal fusion/fission that keeps it's mass from collapsing. Once a supermassive star runs out of energy, the entire thing comes rushing centerwards (and some of it gets explodified as supernova) >You are talking assuming the black hole is already there, and saying quark degeneracy can't resist that, but you forget the black hole has to form first. Blackholes aren't magic. To form, a certain matter density must be reached in a certain volume of space (which can be surprisingly low; the blackhole at the center of the milkyway is not much more dense than water at normal atmospheric pressure). Once you have reached this specific point, you get a black hole. From an outside perspective, being pulled into a blackhole looks like being redshifted out of existence and torn apart, for the infalling object, nothing happens (unless the BH is small enough). The black horizon around a black hole is not a simple line, it's a smort of smudge leading up to the real border; the closer you get the more redshifted everything becomes. Thus, for the naked observer, it might appear as though the object has been swallowed even though it might not have yet crossed the event horizon.
- qubex 9y agoFirst and foremost: GR guarantees that an event horizon will form. Oddball exotic states of matter (quark stars, fuzz balls, whatever) might form in proper time within the event horizon, halting collapse before it reaches the singularity state of infinite compaction. (Since time freezes at the event horizon, these states would occur infinitely far in the future from the perspective of any external observer and might therefore very reasonably be considered ‘unphysical’.) Second, and this is surprisingly subtle: we often discuss black-hole formation in terms of mass, but it's really a matter of relative density: the 2.7 solar mass limit only pertains when one is considering a mass in a void, if for example one found oneself in an infinite universe with an undisturbed uniform density of (say) 2.7 solar masses per metre cubed the tug of gravity would be uniform in all directions and there would be no impetus to initiate gravitational collapse towards any specific point. Once perturbed, however, average density somewhere would rise, and the collapse would begin.
- pdonis 9y ago> Oddball exotic states of matter (quark stars, fuzz balls, whatever) might form in proper time within the event horizon, halting collapse before it reaches the singularity state of infinite compaction. No, this is not correct. Once an event horizon forms, everything inside the horizon will hit the singularity, because the singularity is not a place in space, it's a moment of time, which is in the future (and the not too distant future for holes of reasonable size--the time from horizon to singularity for a black hole of 10 solar masses is about 100 microseconds) for everything inside the horizon. > time freezes at the event horizon No, it doesn't. This is a common pop science misconception, but it's still a misconception. The correct statement is that the horizon is a null surface: a surface generated by outgoing light rays. To someone falling through the horizon, the horizon looks like any other surface generated by light rays, and nothing unusual happens there.
- IntronExon 9y agoWhile I’m totally in agreement with the second part of your comment, the first part may not be true. No, this is not correct. Once an event horizon forms, everything inside the horizon will hit the singularity, because the singularity is not a place in space, it's a moment of time, which is in the future (and the not too distant future for holes of reasonable size--the time from horizon to singularity for a black hole of 10 solar masses is about 100 microseconds) for everything inside the horizon. We don’t actually know if there’s a singularity within the event horizon. GTR predicts it, but that’s in the context of the breakdown of the predictive power of the theory. Until/Unless we have a viable theory of quantum gravity what is inside an EH is speculative. Quark stars or any form of conventional matter are right out obviously, but Fuzzballs or some other novel “structure” can’t be ruled out yet. Having said that, I’m not a string theory adherent, I’m just pointing out that within the event horizon we need a complementary theory to augment GTR and QM.
- pdonis 9y ago> And yet suns with far more mass than is needed to make a black hole exist. Because simple heat pressure keeps the black hole from forming. Ok, if you're going to quibble over irrelevancies, let me restate more carefully: in situations where kinetic pressure is negligible, no amount of pressure can prevent a black hole from forming if sufficient mass is present. And kinetic pressure is always temporary, because it depends on having a heat source, and all heat sources eventually run out. > to have enormous gravity the density must go up. If you prevent that from ever happening you can stop the black hole from ever starting in the first place. You can't prevent it from ever happening. You can only prevent it from happening for as long as a heat source is available. And that will never be forever. See above. > It also means mass takes a long (infinite) time to get in. No, it doesn't. The proper time for an object to free-fall to the horizon, and on inward to the singularity, is finite. Outgoing objects and light behave differently from ingoing objects and light in the presence of gravity.