7 ms·
Or perhaps more positively, "e-waste production falls". It's not surprising that the market would reach a saturation point; manufacturers are running short of
by userbinator 9y ago
Or perhaps more positively, "e-waste production falls".
It's not surprising that the market would reach a saturation point; manufacturers are running short of ideas to improve their products, and even starting to resort to removing features.
Especially in the low-end/unbranded smartphone segment, I've noticed newer models aren't actually getting better. Several years ago they practically all had removable batteries, microSD, dual SIM, and a full complement of sensors; now it's nearly impossible to find such a complete combination anymore --- they're all missing one or two things.
- dredmorbius 9y agoIn Energy and Civilization, Vaclav Smil points out that in terms of embedded energy, an automobile, with over 1,000x the mass of a smartphone, has only 100x the embedded energy. Given replacement cycles, humanity now invests more energy in creating smartphones (life expectancy: ~2 years) than automobiles (~10 years). By year-of-use embedded energy, autos use only 30% of the resources of smartphones. (p. 344, box)
- davidgay 9y ago> In Energy and Civilization, Vaclav Smil points out that in terms of embedded energy, an automobile, with over 1,000x the mass of a smartphone, has only 100x the embedded energy. Assuming embedded energy means "battery / fuel capacity" this seems very wrong: - typical compact car (~3000 lbs, ~1360kg) / Samsung S8 (155g) = 8800 - 50L fuel tank = 475000 Wh / Samsung S8 battery 11.55Wh = 41000 So that's ~4.6x more stored energy per kg, not 10x less.
- holri 9y agoI think he means gray energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embodied_energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embodied_energy
- dredmorbius 9y ago"Embedded energy" is the total energy of manufacturing and processing, not the energy storage of a device or vehicle itself. On that basis, the automobile has many, many, many times the storage of a cellphone. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embodied_energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embodied_energy
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gooseus 9y agoVery interesting, I guess that's another book on my reading list... Do you know if this relates, in any way, to the energy economics and diminishing marginal returns from increasing complexity that Joseph Tainter[0] covers in The Collapse of Complex Societies[1]? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Tainter#Diminishing_returns https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Tainter#Diminishing_ret... [1] http://wtf.tw/ref/tainter.pdf http://wtf.tw/ref/tainter.pdf
- dredmorbius 9y agoGenerally, yes, though Smil doesn't really develop the concept of complexity and collapse as Tainter does. Tainter is cited in the book, though unfortunately the citations / notes format is one that makes it exceedingly difficult to sort out where (this is one of my few complaints with this book, and Smil's writing generally -- he follows a social sciences citations format of (Author <year>) inline, which makes finding, and identifying, references tedious -- I'm the sort of cat who really likes either section-based endnotes or page-based footnotes for tracking things). That said: Smil's citations are excellent, and his books are worth buying for the references alone. They're also far more worth buying (or reading) for the actual text, but good refs are a very strong bonus. If you're interested in Tainter's view, I would suggest taking a look, if you can find a copy, at Manfred Weissenbacher's Sources of Power, published in 2009, and covering much the same concept. Weissenbacher's approach is similar to Smil's, and the latter cites Smil's earlier book, Energy in World History (1992) extensively. Weissenbacher looks far more into the political aspects of energy regimes, particularly in the 19th and 20th centuries, and arguably to a fault. The book is also extensively researched, though far-less-evenly written than Smil's. Neither author is a native English speaker, but Smil has a far better command of the language, and the discipline and/or editorial assistance to tighten up and clean up his writing. That said, despite the similarities, the works do complement one another. Another author I'd recommend is William Ophuls, particularly Ecology and the Politics of Scarcity (1977, revised ~1994), which predates but also anticipates much of Tainter's work. Ophul's background and focus is politics and polity, but through the lenses of ecology and Limits to Growth particularly. His forecast of political developments strikes me as particularly good, capturing much of what actually did transpire, with few failures, save the quite notable one that we have so far managed to avoid an absolutely devastating general famine. But his national / regional assessment strikes me as pretty true -- it's based on the US, EU, USSR (still a thing, though he saw trouble for it), China, India, Africa, and Latin America, generally.
- cameldrv 9y agoIf a car is 100x the embedded energy and lasts 5x as long, then the car takes 20x as much energy per useful year. This doesn't count the energy to run each of them, which is more lopsided obviously.
- forapurpose 9y ago> This doesn't count the energy to run each of them Or to manufacture or to dispose of them.
- dredmorbius 9y agoEmbodied energy is specifically the manufacturing cost, and may include total product lifecycle costs, other than use. That would include disposal.
- forapurpose 9y agoThanks for the education; that's a useful concept. > Embodied Do you mean "embedded"? I'm not nitpicking; I want to make sure I understand. Where does one find the embedded/embodied energy for a product? I'd be surprised if it can be calculated - the energy required to mine, transport, manufacture, dispose every bit of every raw material that eventually goes into all the parts of an automobile (or other complex modern device)? It would be a very valuable but daunting task. How is it done and who does it?
- dredmorbius 9y agoApparently both terms are used. I feel slightly less stupid. http://www.appropedia.org/Embedded_energy http://www.appropedia.org/Embedded_energy
- dredmorbius 9y agoSo, I managed to goof the account above a few ways. First, cars weigh 10,000 times, not 1,000 times, more than a cellphone. Embodied (not embedded) energy is 100x greater for the automobile. The units produced annually is a major factor: 2 billion for mobile phones, 72 million for automobiles. That plus product life skews the number toward phones a lot. I did manage to get the bottom-line value right: autos use 0.72 exajoules of energy per year of use, 30% less than mobile phones. A longer version of the example was published in IEEE Spectrum in 2016: https://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/environment/your-phone-costs-energyeven-before-you-turn-it-on https://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/environment/your-phone-cost...
- Yhippa 9y ago> and even starting to resort to removing features. I'm usually the positive guy when it comes to change but boy do I miss the headphone jack on my phone. Bluetooth is such a pain.
- bornonline1 9y agoAmazing how easy it is to make people accept horrible options.
- antisthenes 9y agoThen why'd you buy a phone without a headphone jack?
- dredmorbius 9y agoNot all decision implications are immediately apparent. Alternatives to physically jacked connections are sold as something they're not. Disappointment happens. I strongly recommend Robert Merton, "unintended consequences". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_K._Merton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_K._Merton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unintended_consequences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unintended_consequences http://users.ipfw.edu/dilts/E%20306%20Readings/The%20Unanticipated%20Consequences%20of%20Purposive%20Social%20Action.pdf http://users.ipfw.edu/dilts/E%20306%20Readings/The%20Unantic...
- Yhippa 9y agoBecause I thought I could do without one?
- tachyoff 9y agoI’ve even considered ditching my smartphone entirely here and there. I’m not convinced its utility outweighs its use as an ad-driven anxiety rectangle constantly vying for my attention. Combined with the steady loss of features, I’m wondering if this decide is really a tool or a burden. Something to ponder, I suppose.
- robin_reala 9y agoI rarely see ads on my phone, I guess through a combination of using an adblocker in Firefox and mostly paying for ad-free apps. Is it really a major problem?
- suprfnk 9y agoTurn off all notifications. Delete all non-tool apps; you know, the apps that want you to spend time in them. Keep only the tool apps. You won't spend 30 minutes scrolling through your navigation app, or your music app, or through the pictures you made, or looking at the weather forecast, or... These are all very useful features. I wouldn't throw out the baby with the bathwater.
- enobrev 9y agoThe Galaxy S8* has a "Do Not Disturb" mode which allows you to whitelist contacts for incoming calls and messages, and apps that can create notifications. It's meant to be a temporary setting, like to turn on while in a meeting or while sleeping, but I have it set to run 24 hours a day, only allowing people in my "favorites" to call me, everyone in my contacts list to message me, and only allowing notifications from a couple apps. I just set it up a week ago, and I absolutely love how little I'm bothered by my phone now, including no more calls from bots, which I was receiving around 4-6 times a day. * I assume most recent Samsung equivalents have this feature as well. My S6 had it.
- ddalex 9y agoLineageOS as well has this feature. Put it on a Oneplus (to get rid of Chinese Spyware TM), add an Adblocker and True Caller (leaks agenda information, but we used to have phone-number books) and you'll have an actually decent smartphone experience. When I'm testing new smartphones in stores, I'm shocked at how crappy the experience is compared to the LineageOS, both in terms of UI, and in terms of interruptions and notifications and ads shoved down the user's throat
- odiroot 9y agoI have the same impression recently. It's nearly impossible to get a good compact phone. My last one was Sony Xperia X Compact. XZ1 Compact is basically a clone with slightly better specs, no point to upgrade. XZ2 compact while getting beefier lost the headphone jack. I'm basically waiting and hoping for Xiaomi to release some nice compact in 2018.
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y ago> nearly impossible to get a good compact phone Psst: iphone SE. Cheapest Apple around. (Windows phone orphan here, making do.)
- odiroot 9y agoThat's (iOS) not a solution for me. EDIT: Also, it's only 4in display with even worse screen-to-body ratio than Xperia.
- reacweb 9y agoIf you do not care about version of android, https://fr.aliexpress.com/item/ASUS-Zenfone-MAX-ZC550KL-Android-5-0-Quad-Core-1280-720-5-5-inch-Qualcomm-MSM8916/32753291949.html https://fr.aliexpress.com/item/ASUS-Zenfone-MAX-ZC550KL-Andr.... For me, it is feature complete (one of the most important feature being the small price tag).
- flyinghamster 9y agoAnother thing I hate seeing is that even when you have an unlockable bootloader (like my LG Stylo 2 Plus), good luck finding a custom ROM for it. LineageOS? I can only wish. For the most part, only LG's flagships get any love - and even if it became available I'd have to hope that it doesn't implode the way CyanogenMod did. I don't have the free time to port it myself, either. At least LG's Android skin isn't bad. I spent a while on XDA, and that whole scene seems horribly broken. I ran an older phone rooted for a while, but keeping up with root and security updates got to be a real pain.