3 ms·
When I was 17, I thought I was really beautiful and I wanted to be a model. By which I mean I imagined it would be easy money and I never seriously pursued it.
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
When I was 17, I thought I was really beautiful and I wanted to be a model. By which I mean I imagined it would be easy money and I never seriously pursued it.
I imagine many people who want to be a YouTuber are kind of like that. It sounds like easy money and they aren't ever going to work that hard at learning their craft, etc. So it shouldn't be terribly surprising that a lot of them aren't doing particularly well.
On the other hand, I'm a writer and it is the same thing: A few big name stars raking in the dough and a whole lot of losers struggling to get by. And I get told all the time to go get a real job if I want a middle class income.
I don't know where people think these real jobs are. We are seeing the rise of the gig economy. There are fewer full time jobs with benefits and more gigs.
I am medically handicapped. Doing gig work has overall worked better for me than a corporate job. I hit $50k in debt while working a corporate job. I paid a lot of that off while homeless and doing freelance writing and struggling to eat.
I don't know what the answer is. Historically, middle class jobs did not just magically happen. Society designed them that way. Most were designed under the assumption that it was a man supporting a family whose wife would do the cooking, etc, so he could focus on his job. Under that model, you didn't need everyone to make a middle class income. You needed the primary breadwinner to have a good job with benefits that supported his whole family. Society was designed around a nuclear family model and jobs were designed with that in mind.
The world has changed and the nuclear family is not the default expectation. Plus regular jobs are getting scarce.
So I think we need to take it seriously that there are systemic problems here. We are allowing a system to develop with a few big winners, a lot of losers and little or no middle class.
At the same time, we need to accept that not all content is equally worthwhile. However, if we want some form of UBI, I would be much more comfortable with the idea that if you have some kind of YouTube channel or similar, you should have some kind of basic income from it than with "free money for everyone."
- contingencies 9y agoI think we need to take it seriously that there are systemic problems here. We are allowing a system to develop with a few big winners, a lot of losers and little or no middle class. I believe Marxists see this as the inevitable endgame of capitalism... by rewarding hoarded capital, there is no possible conclusion except the centralization of wealth to enormous levels of disparity. Even for those of us who travel across boundaries, in some parts of the world I personally feel ridiculously wealthy (which objectively I am) whereas I can't afford to raise my kids in the manner and environment in which I myself was raised (which was not considered particularly wealthy at the time). Politics seems to have failed us on most fronts, and the big problems are really international and therefore beyond the scope and reign of political animals, even naively assuming they cannot be bought out or sidestepped. Perhaps then, fundamentally as individuals we can only analyze the net effects of our actions and try to contribute to positive change instead of perpetuating a self-serving culture. More snarkily, "Oh, you can't make a good living producing content on the internet with $1000s of dollars of e-toys?" ... this is perhaps something of a first world problem, where others are still down the bottom of Maslow's Hierarchy.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYes, it's a first world problem. That doesn't mean it isn't a very serious problem. We are seeing stresses that have millionaires scared of where this goes. If the first world can't figure out how to turn this wealth of tech and knowledge into widespread middle class comforts and devolves into revolution and can therefore no longer send aid to developing nations with "real problems" I think things will get really ugly globally.
- themaninthedark 9y agoAt some point rather recently we made the decision to get rid of all the icky blue collar jobs and replace them with service economy job. The people who protested this change were branded as backwards hicks and their concerns were hand waved away along with promises of retraining. The gig economy is just more of the same but we get told that wages are rising in other countries so we should be happy, as we subsidize some startup with our cars or our houses. But hey, we are getting rid of the 9 to 5 right?
- skookumchuck 9y ago> Society designed them that way No it didn't. It just happened that way because it was convenient that way.
- DoreenMichele 9y agohttp://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/2014/01/03/history/post-perspective/ford-doubles-minimum-wage.html http://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/2014/01/03/history/post-p... Henry Ford was a big believer in paying his people adequately and was hugely influential on modern America to a degree most people fail to grasp.
- skookumchuck 9y agoFord found that raising wages reduced turnover and worker shortages, leading to increased profits. I suspect the rest was just reframing it as being generous.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThe fact that creating a middle class improves one's business in no way changes the fact that it was done on purpose and was not some weird freak accident.
- skookumchuck 9y agoHe did it explicitly on purpose to improve his business, not for a social agenda.
- gowld 9y agoHenry Ford raised wages, but the long bloody war that unions fought had a much larger influence.
- igravious 9y agoOn the back of an article pointing out how the well known "starving artist" profession now includes a "starving YouTube artist" category you make an interesting semi-sequitur into the social ill of economic inequality. The thing is. The world is getting better for pretty much everybody. What is happening is that for the certain differing quantiles the world is not getting better at the same rate. For some quantiles in feels like you are not keeping up with the Jones's and you'd be right, you are in fact very much not keeping up with the Jones's. As global wealth increases who then are the losers and who are the winners relatively speaking? I know that's hard to believe, but it is only (and I used the emphasis advisedly) the very very poor wherever they live and the lower middle classes in the developed nations that are being left behind. The famous elephant curve† on inequality explains it visually far better than I could. (I know in my case that I have only maintained my living standard with help from family and for me this is a source of constant shame. I haven't been able to afford to take my kid on holiday in years. If anything goes wrong with the car I can't afford to fix it. Am I to blame though? You judge. I refuse to do many sorts of jobs that I consider too repetitive or boring. I am completing a PhD which at the moment is basically more money out than money coming in. I do this because I want to spend my life doing something I value (philosophy/coding). I have no idea how representative my case is. All the major tech companies are in my country, I could turn my back on philosophy but I choose not to.) Steven Pinker in his new book Enlightenment Now uses data, stats, charts, diagrams, info-graphics to show that by any reasonable measure life is getting significantly better all the time for vast swathes of the world's population. We in the developed world need to remind ourselves that illiteracy is still a thing in some countries. Child mortality is still a thing. And so on. But, and this is important, growing economic inequality is a very real social ill. Pinker dismisses economic inequality because globally so much good is being done. This ignores the daily hardship of 100s of millions. It ignores the fact that as the world gets wealthier there'll be _less_ people doing better relatively as they move up the food chain so to speak. If things keep going the way they are going we are going to have a class of 100 billionaires while some people still live without proper sanitation and running water. The situation is already untenable and disgusting, it's only going to get more so. Jordan Peterson recognizes that social and economic inequality of a truly vicious social problem, one that predates capitalism. (There's a name for these truly intractable problems, it's not coming to me just now.) We need to figure out collectively how to architect a society that isn't punitively restrictive on people's ambitions to succeed but that still manages to redistribute wealth in a manner that is fair for all. I sympathize with your lot Doreen. For a certain type of person who is unwilling to "play the game" society as it is architected means you do something you hate and keep your head above water or you follow your heart and drown a little bit more every day. † https://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/21707219-charting-globalisations-discontents-shooting-elephant https://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/2170721... (this was the first link for the search term <elephant curve inequality> so you could and should look for other sources of info.)