5 ms·
I think part of this lies with the fact that Stalin and especially Communism had a lot of highly placed admirers in the West. One of those was Walter Duranty, w
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
I think part of this lies with the fact that Stalin and especially Communism had a lot of highly placed admirers in the West. One of those was Walter Duranty, who even won a Pulitzer Prize for for his work as the Moscow Bureau Chief for the New York Times. He worked to deny and discredit those who tried to tell the world about the atrocities of Stalin.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Duranty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Duranty
https://www.nytco.com/new-york-times-statement-about-1932-pulitzer-prize-awarded-to-walter-duranty/ https://www.nytco.com/new-york-times-statement-about-1932-pu...
- gnarbarian 9y agoIt continues today in the social sciences: "Overall, Marxism is a tiny minority faith. Just 3% of professors accept the label. The share rises to 5% in the humanities. The shocker, though, is that as recently as 2006, about 18% of social scientists self-identified as Marxists" http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2015/03/the_prevalence_1.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2015/03/the_prevalence_1...
- blackbagboys 9y agoMarxism and Stalinism are different things.
- gnarbarian 9y agoYes I agree. Just as there is a difference between theory and practice. Marxism is to Stalinism as theory is to practice.
- goldenkey 9y agoMarxism doesn't have to be undemocratic. Isn't the losing pattern here - dictatorship vs democracy, not Marxism vs Capitalism?
- gnarbarian 9y agoDo you have any examples of lasting democracy in communist states? Maybe the Democratic People's Republic of Korea?
- goldenkey 9y agoIsn't North Korea aka DPRK a dictatorship? Pretty much every authoritarian regime calls themselves a Republic / Democracy. It's become a long standing joke by now.
- Tech-Noir 9y agoHe's being sarcastic. He could answer his question with a five second Google if he had a genuine, sincere interest in learning about the subject.
- Fins 9y agoYou can also find a "proof" that the Earth is flat after 5 seconds of googling. Finding a non-dictatorial marxist state in real life would be slightly more difficult, as such a thing had never existed.
- Tech-Noir 9y agoIf you have difficulty accepting anything that doesn't confirm your bias then, yes, I can see it might be difficult, otherwise it's really quite easy to accept that, for example, the current Prime Minister of Nepal is a Communist. Good luck with your flat Earth stuff though.
- Fins 9y agoIs Nepal a marxist country? Nice try with a total non-sequitur, though? Still no example of a country simultaneously democratic and marxist, though. Probably because they only excist in that mythical universe where communists are any better than nazis.
- blackbagboys 9y agoI'm not sure whether gnarbarian is trolling or just operating outside his range of understanding, but those with an honest interest in the subject will find that Marxist-inflected schools of thought of course comprise many diverse and lively intellectual disciplines, which have influenced many politicians and leaders in decidedly non-Stalinist nations around the world, from MLK Jr. to the probable future Prime Minister of Great Britain. The other obvious rejoinder to the parent comment is that if Stalinism is "Marxism in practice", than in equal measure the wholesale genocidal slaughter of millions of Native Americans, Koreans, Vietnamese, Latin Americans, Iraqis etc. carried out by the United States can be said to be capitalism in practice, not to mention the century plus of horrific atrocities committed by the capitalist nations of Western Europe and East Asia (of course, many Marxists would say that this is exactly right).
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoThis. I was going to comment, but this says it better than I could have this morning.
- fabianhjr 9y agoNo! Marx in Das Kapital and other works dedicated a great deal to make a philosophical framework to study the Capitalist Mode of Production as a phenomenon in Industrial Revolution England. Additionally, he made arguments about how the material conditions shaped human society. (Which you can in retrospective say it was obvious, but it wasn't so at the time and even nowadays history is taught in the Great Man Theory - https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Great_Man_theory https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Great_Man_theory ) Marx predicted an uprising in England from Factory Workers, not in agricultural Russia and it was a big source of head scratching for Marxists at the time. The Bolshevik Revolution was at odds with Marxist theory. (Which doesn't mean he was wrong with his description of capitalism at the time) At least read the wikipedia ( https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Marxism https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Marxism ) page before attempting to disparage a theory with strawmans.
- lucideer 9y agoI can imagine some conflation happening in the 1930s, but at least today, there's a stark differentiation between Stalinism and Marxism. 18% of social scientists do not identify as Stalinists.
- thedailymail 9y agoIt's important to note that in the 2006 study that Caplan cites, which reported that 18% of social scientists identified as Marxists, the other options offered were all about political affiliation rather than economic views (although there is certainly significant overlap between these categories). The prevalence of self-identified Marxists in social sciences, particuarly sociology, may reflect the important role Marx's commentaries on the social outcomes of 19th century capitalism has had in areas like history, sociology, and cultural studies, rather than a commitment to communist economic structures. There are plenty of Marxist scholars who use Marx's methods of analyzing social phenomena without subscribing to his statements about the inevitable triumph of socialism. Marx is generally recognized as a better diagnostician than a prescriptionist, and for fields involved in critical analysis of social-political-economic phenomena it is not surprising to see people who identify (politically) with his work and world view.
- simula67 9y agoFrom the linked SlateStarCodex piece : > Conservatives always complain that liberals “deny human nature” > But here I have to give conservatives their due. As far as I can tell, Marx literally, so strongly as to be unstrawmannable, believed there was no such thing as human nature and everything was completely malleable. So, it is possible Marx's economic prescription came out of his social diagnosis
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DanAndersen 9y agoFor anyone interested about the attitude of various Soviet-sympathetic people in the West during the 20th century, I'd recommend reading Scott Alexander's book review of "Chronicles of Wasted Time" [0]. I admit I haven't read the book itself but the review seems to do a good job summing things up. Basically it's the autobiography of Malcolm Muggeridge, who grew up in a socialist background, becomes a journalist and goes over to Stalin's USSR to report on the amazing new progress being made, only to realize just how false all the reports are -- and what's more, how unwilling his target audience would be to hear it: [quotes from the review] >although it is clear to him that the Soviet economy is struggling, every dispatch they are given to send home declares that things are better than ever, that the Workers’ Paradise is even more paradisiacal than previously believed, that the evidence is in and Stalinism is the winner. It doesn’t matter what he makes of this, because anything he writes which deviates from the script is rejected by the censors, who ban him from sending it home. He is reduced to sending secret messages at the bottoms of people’s suitcases, only to find to his horror that even when they successfully reach the Guardian offices back in Britain, his bosses have no interest in publishing them because they offend the prejudices of its progressive readership. [...] >His final break with the rest of the enlightened progressive world comes when he decides to do something that perhaps no other journalist in the entire Soviet Union had dared – to go off the reservation, so to speak, leave Moscow undercover, and see if he can actually get into the regions where rumors say some kind of famine might be happening. The plan goes without a hitch, he passes himself off as a generic middle-class Soviet, and he ends up in Ukraine right in the middle of Stalin’s Great Famine. He describes the scene – famished skeletons begging for crumbs, secret police herding entire towns into railway cars never to be seen again. At great risk to himself, he smuggles notes about the genocide out of the country, only to be met – once again – with total lack of interest. Guardian readers don’t look at the newspapers to hear bad things about the Soviet Union! Guardian readers want to hear about how the Glorious Future is already on its way! He is quickly sidelined in favor of the true stars of Soviet journalism, people like Walter Duranty, the New York Times‘s Russia correspondent, who wrote story after story about how prosperous and happy and well-fed the Soviets were under Stalin, and who later won the Pulitzer Prize for his troubles. [0] http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/08/11/book-review-chronicles-of-wasted-time/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/08/11/book-review-chronicles-...