8 ms·
The Erdős paradox: When a mathematical number and Wikipedia collide
- matt4077 9y agoThis is the essay the interview references: https://medium.com/q-e-d/whos-important-a-tale-from-wikipedia-a370dc6ef078 https://medium.com/q-e-d/whos-important-a-tale-from-wikipedi...
- thriftwy 9y ago> “were over four times more likely to have their importance questioned” and their pages marked for speedy deletion Deletionists of Wikipedia are just destinied to fall on their face, and embarrass the whole project. Deletionism is the single big thing that makes Wikipedia somewhat sour in my view.
- thriftwy 9y agoHere, I have a Venn diagram to illustrate a point: https://www.meta-chart.com/share/how-wikipedia-deletionism-works https://www.meta-chart.com/share/how-wikipedia-deletionism-w... Two important takeaways are: A lot of stuff on Wikipedia just isn't encyclopedic. For example, there's a lot of sports trivia about obscure teams and local leagues. Such data deserves structured storage and not Wikipedia, and I just don't feel "2013 Richmond Raiders season" is more important than any single matematician who worked with Erdős. Second takeaway, a whole world of topics is just not ever noted by Wikipedia. For examples, you can have whole branches of local music scenes ineligible for note because every single artist fails to "be mentioned in a paper made of paper" (in 2010s, seriously) or "sell 3k discs made of plastic and foil" (again, this is in 2010s). If there's some kind of consistent policy I definitely don't see the value of it.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoThe justification for the policy I have heard is that people should be able easily verify the information. If it's in the New York Times you can probably believe that it's not been created to game Wikipedia, the same cant be said for a random blog. I regularly see people complain about this without mentioning how they would solve this problem.
- ghaff 9y agoThe problem isn't the New York Times though. If someone has been profiled or otherwise written about repeatedly in the NYT, they're probably notable at some level. The issue is mentions in obscure books and local newspapers tend to trump even a significant online presence. I'm not sure what the best answer is either. The closest I've seen is to overlay a more inclusionist Wikipedia with some sort of crowdsourced reputation/quality moderation system. That can be gamed too of course but something along those lines may be the best approach.
- thriftwy 9y agoMost of papers made of paper are absolutely not available for verification. Ditto for research articles behind paywall or just cited as paper sources. You could invent dozens of such credible sources with no chances for anybody to ever check. I can understand "we could not verify this so we are deleting this article", but not "we speedy deleted this article without checking anything". The latter has no excuses except for obvious commercial spam.
- ghaff 9y agoThe correlation between notability and verifiability certainly starts to break down quickly once you get past easily accessible, well-known, and well-regarded sources. No one is going to chase down paper copies of obscure magazines, newspapers, or out-of-print books to verify some statement, especially if it's not highly questionable for some reason. The system does kinda work because most people aren't outright inventing fake references to game the system.
- thriftwy 9y agoWhat would be your criteria for the system failing to work? What can go visibly wrong if Wikipedia would cover different subset of obscure topics than it does currently? We're not talking about faking facts in well-visited articles, since a) that's not what is being discussed, and b) that has been done anyway, getting into news multiple times.
- ghaff 9y agoNotability and related policies kinda, sorta, maybe work on Wikipedia relative to a total free-for-all but they fall down if you start squinting hard at them. Pretty much everything is notable at some level if you get local enough in either geography or subject matter. And, as you suggest, the fact that the high school quarterback or a local diner got written up in some local newspaper that has managed not to go out of business yet doesn't make them more notable in any important sense than, say, pretty much any scientist with a tenured position at a major university. (Or someone who is well known in open source circles or a senior executive in a major company or ...) I'm not sure what the best answer is. We pretty much know that anything goes doesn't really work (see Google Knol). But the current system on Wikipedia is pretty flawed as well.
- oldcynic 9y agoIt seems to boil down to opinion. To an extent it has to. Though even when there's dozens of citations possible or articles on paper, and verifiable, entries can go because of an admin opinion. (I've no doubt this isn't the policy, but it sure seems like it sometimes. The one time I started to read into it I gave up.) Plenty that really doesn't seem to pass the sniff test manages to stick around. Though I'd prefer too many edge cases than too few. There's already a mechanism to mark pages with a caveat for needing cleanup or expansion after all.
- ghaff 9y ago>It seems to boil down to opinion. To an extent it has to. There are certainly plenty of cases that would seem to be at one extreme or the other. National political figures, professional sports teams, etc. etc. are clearly notable. The random person whose name is only visible on the Internet on their own website probably not. But in between those poles are published but not well-known books, minor league baseball players, little-seen low-budget movies, random board games, amateur bands etc. Whether, for example, every book that has ever been published could potentially have its own Wikipedia article is ultimately an opinion/philosophy about whether there should be some limits on content that's just very obscure on Wikipedia even if it's theoretically verifiable to at least some degree.
- thriftwy 9y agoI just din't see any value in such limits. Do you? As long as article is well-written and not a self-promotion, it should be in.
- posterboy 9y agoIsn't it mutual and hence the other way around? Mathematicians don't seem to care much for wikipedia, sceners likewise. While sports fans might see editing, well, as a game.
- NoahTheDuke 9y agoOoo, another chance to link to Gwern's excellent 'In Defense of Inclusionism'[0] essay. [0]: http://www.gwern.net/In-Defense-Of-Inclusionism http://www.gwern.net/In-Defense-Of-Inclusionism
- contravariant 9y agoJust playing devil's advocate here, but with the numbers given in the essay (10 out of 250 male entries tagged for deletion vs 2 out of 12 female entries) I got a p-value of approximately 10% [1]. By most criteria this wouldn't qualify as statistically significant. This doesn't immediately disqualify the entire essay, but the claim that women are 'over four times more likely to be deleted' is somewhat dubious. [1]: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1+-+(1+-+12%2F262)%5E12+-12+(12%2F262)(1+-+12%2F262)%5E11 http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1+-+(1+-+12%2F262)%5E12...
- stareatgoats 9y agoThere are many things that are not statistically significant, but still interesting when it seems likely* that a larger sample would give a similar result. Only 17.47% (as of 26 February 2018) of the English Wikipedia's biographies are about women: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:WikiProject_Women_in_Red https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:WikiProject_Women_in... EDIT: I rechecked the quote from the article about the likelihood of deletion and found it to be "in this cohort of Erdős Ones, the pages for women were over four times more likely than men’s to be nominated for speedy deletion." (my italics). FYI.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Only 17.47% (as of 26 February 2018) of the English Wikipedia's biographies are about women: Wikipedia being a tertiary source may, through unbiased processes, simply be reflecting bias in the secondary sources. Biographies of pre-modern women are far less common than of their male contemporaries, IME; that's less true of my modern and especially extremely current figures, but Wikipedia isn't exclusively focused on current figures.
- posterboy 9y agoThere is no such thing as a tertiary source. Either you have a primary source, or you have hear say.
- 9y ago
- carlmr 9y agoI'd like to see a bit more analysis past the Erdös number. What could other (measurable) notability indicators be. Number of publications, length of scientific career, number of citations, number of people they taught, ...? Her analysis here seems very shallow and already operating from the preconceived mindset that this must be misogyny. I'm not saying it's not, but the argument is weak.
- olliej 9y agoOk, so the fundamental issue the blog references is "women who worked with Erdos are significantly more likely to be tagged for early deletion", that statement is backed up by the actual stats. So the question is, what is the cause for this discrepancy? It is possible that the women who worked with Erdos were much more likely to be irrelevant than the men -- by a factor of 4 -- in which case this would be reasonable. The alternative (her claim) is that they were marked for deletion because other editors default to assume that women are less relevant than men, unless proved otherwise. My question is: are the people who are tagging these articles for deletion field experts -- mathematicians or whatever -- who can actually understand the relative importance of individuals, or are they running through a checklist? If they're just running through a checklist does their checklist just reinforce old stereotypes? For example, old newspapers would not bother interview women engineers, scientists, etc, and even if they were historically women were absolutely kept out of those fields, so even if interviews were random, statistics would ensure low public visibility. Hence relying on the existence of published biographies is not sufficient, and is arguably less relevant than the Erdos number. Does it treat an Erdos number as being proof of importance in some cases, but not in others? If your default view is men are real mathematicians, and women are not, it is easy to interpret a low Erdos number as evidence of importance (it confirms your belief of relevance), but if you start out with the converse -- this person isn't relevant or important -- then it's just trivia.
- stareatgoats 9y agoHard to bring any hard 'proof' other than the circumstantial evidence brought to the table by the articles mentioned in the wiki article on gender bias on Wikipedia [0]. So since we are speculating anyway, let me add some of my own: Is it possible that a significant number of Wikipedia editors involved in the maths field have never experienced discrimination against women (perhaps because they are males)? Is it also possible that they are so proud of their own genus (or insecure in their gender-role), and/or so convinced that women should not involve themselves with such a "male" activity as maths, that they (probably subconsciously) assume that women could not have contributed in any significant way? In my own anecdotal experience such reasons have often seemed to me to be behind the urge to interrupt, minimize and in worst cases, harass, women in man-dominated professions. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_bias_on_Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_bias_on_Wikipedia
- astrodev 9y agoThe article has it backward. As a staunch deletionist, I can attest that articles about non-notable women are much harder to get deleted than articles about non-notable men.
- brazzy 9y agoCan you support that with any kind of concrete data? The article may rely on a small sample, but at least it does have evidence to support its claim.
- astrodev 9y agoNothing but anecdotal personal experience from participation in more than a thousand deletion discussions. At one point I analyzed my "Articles for deletion" stats (how often my vote matched the community decision) and found that in order to keep my match percentage high (~95%) I needed to use more stringent criteria for males than for females.
- nkurz 9y agoIt seems so unlikely that you'd have already analyzed your deletion statistics for males vs females that I think you have to be trolling, but I'd love to understand your worldview if you are not. Could you provide a link to your Wikipedia deletion activity?
- astrodev 9y agoSorry, everyone in the Wikimedia community is so obsessed with preserving their anonymity that "outing" myself here would put me at a significant disadvantage. I don't think I am trolling. There are multiple tools to analyze the statistics, e.g. [1], and the female biographies stood out for me. Everybody checks the deletion discussion stats since a high accuracy (in terms of one's vote matching the consensus) is a de facto requirement to become an admin. I don't think there is anything sinister going on, simply a few editors with extremely inclusionist views tend to patrol articles about females [2]. Since the average deletion discussion has only ~3 participants, this results in a bias. [1] https://tools.wmflabs.org/afdstats/ https://tools.wmflabs.org/afdstats/ [2] I kid you not, for example Megalibrarygirl, who's recently become an admin, is only involved in articles about women [3] [3] https://tools.wmflabs.org/afdstats/afdstats.py?name=Megalibrarygirl&max=500&startdate=&enddate=&altname=&nomsonly=false https://tools.wmflabs.org/afdstats/afdstats.py?name=Megalibr...
- tomtimtall 9y agoThis is not good for the woman in science campaign. You are not notable just because you had at minimum one collaboration with a famously notable person. She seems to be dissatisfied that she can’t just use the Erdos number as an argument alone to add thin bios for every female collaborator he had. And then goes on to complain that there perhaps exist equally unimportant woman who would not fit into this catagory “just because they didn’t collaborate with Erdos” but just as in-notable as the not notable collaborators... Stop judgeging notability by Erdos number if that is you singular claim to fame then the correct action is speedy deletion independent of sex.