2 ms·
On Twitter I follow and am followed by a lot of HN users and I know a lot of HN users independently and.. I can recall fewer than 10 times anyone has ever said
by petercooper 16y ago
On Twitter I follow and am followed by a lot of HN users and I know a lot of HN users independently and.. I can recall fewer than 10 times anyone has ever said "check this out and vote it up?" Sometimes I do, sometimes I don't - it entirely depends on if I'd vote it up anyway.
It saddens me, then, that there are "voting rings" which, I'm assuming, rely on people voting up each other's stories in a mutually beneficial way. I hope this can be curbed but, I fear, innocent groups of friends or popular HN users could fall foul of it merely for consistently submitting or voting up each other's stuff in an unorganized fashion.
- tptacek 16y agoThe nice thing about dampening collusive votes in code is that we don't have to sit around in threads like this arguing about the "ethics" of voting and searching our souls. The nice thing about having a benevolent dictator behind the site is that we can just have things like this fixed automatically. I suggest: stop worrying, vote however you want.
- petercooper 16y agoThe ethics of voting are not my focus. My concern is the potential collateral damage of the "punishment." Google has had to take similar actions with its algorithms and even their best efforts yield collateral damage - I suspect this is why it takes them so many people and so much time to make improvements. The voting system on Hacker News is small beans compared to Google rankings (which can make or break entire businesses), but it doesn't negate the validity of showing concern for a site from which I get much of my daily reading material.