4 ms·
Is anyone else not enthused about the single screen for all instrumentation? I was talking to friends about it this weekend, and as someone that works in techn
by kbenson 9y ago
Is anyone else not enthused about the single screen for all instrumentation? I was talking to friends about it this weekend, and as someone that works in technology I have quite a bit of distrust in the idea of one screen for all your essential driving information, including fuel capacity, speed, warning indicators, etc sharing space with the entertainment and navigation system when operating something as fundamentally dangerous as an automobile (even if we often forget how dangerous it is).
* I don't want to be at the whim of some designer's ideas as to whether when I switch navigation screens my fuel gauge and current speed should shrink or move to a separate area for better design flow. I want them at the same location no matter what.
* I don't want the added complexity of the entire entertainment and navigation system working against the stability of the system. I don't want poor quality of some random widget crashing my only information display.
* After the Jeep hacking a few years ago where there wasn't enough separation between the internet connected devices and features essential to operation of the vehicle, many commenters here were saying anything without an air-gap between the internet and CAN-bus is a security problem.[1] That may or may not be extreme, but putting everything together like this means I really want to know what steps they've taken to segregate and secure high-importance data channels in the car. I really hope the answer isn't "we have software that is responsible for firewalling access." When it comes to something like this, I really want some physical and/or hardware level separation.
1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9921557 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9921557
- mwilliaams 9y agoTeslas get OTA updates, so I'm pretty sure they're always connected. A big downside in my opinion
- nicolashahn 9y agoIs there a way to control that? Can you run your Tesla in airplane mode?
- mwilliaams 9y agoI've no idea
- crooked-v 9y agoThe single screen and the underwhelming on-wheel controls are the reason I’m avoiding the Model 3 despite distinctly looking forward to it for a while.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoYep, I've commented on this before. It's a safety hazard and is bad UX. Having seen and dealt with the Model S screen before, no thank you, not interested.
- greglindahl 9y agoIt's worth noting that Model S can control a lot of things from the steering wheel buttons. (You may already know this, but many commenters in the past haven't.)
- ebbv 9y agoYes the single touch screen instrumentation is a deal killer for me. I will not buy a Model 3 for this reason, the Chevy Bolt has a much more traditional interior that I prefer. As does the Nissan Leaf.
- cmurf 9y agoAirplanes with glass cockpit still have analog instruments. Doubly redundant, separate visual reference and separate meausurement.
- kreetx 9y agoWith no hard evidence, but still: wouldn't you think they've already thought of these issues and have addressed these? I.e no designer whims, and good software separation on whatever runs in the car. One would think they have, since many if not most are concerned -- perhaps more so among us on the software front since there are many devs here who know more about ins-and-outs.
- kbenson 9y agoI would have thought that Jeep had thought of that too, and yet they had vehicles that could be hacked through OnStar. When it comes to security, safety and remote control by someone else of a vehicle weighing almost 2 tons and able to reach freeway speeds in a few seconds, assumption is not what I want to rely on.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pvelagal 9y agoIMHO, Lack of a proper dashboard/steering wheel controls in Model 3 is a dealbreaker for me too. It is not even available as an optional package. Audi has a virtual cockpit, model 3 should have some thing like that.