3 ms·
That's one of the reasons I bought the specific dock offered by Dell for my XPS 15. The laptop and dock support thunderbolt, but it's carried across USB-C. Ge
by kbenson 9y ago
That's one of the reasons I bought the specific dock offered by Dell for my XPS 15. The laptop and dock support thunderbolt, but it's carried across USB-C. Getting this all right and knowing it will work as expected was enough for me to pay an extra $30-$40 to make sure I got a well tested docking system.
The article I just read to make sure I had my facts straight before posting[1] said it best I think. USB-C is a connector, which support many protocols (including USB 3.0/3.1 and Thunderbolt 3).
In other words, it's the equivalent to the Ethernet in your network, over which you run a protocol like TCP/IP, or IPX/SPX (not that I think anyone actually runs this much anymore). It's confusing because for USB 1.0 and USB 2.0 the protocol and the connectors were fairly closely linked (although they did downgrade as needed).
1: https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-difference-between-a-Thunderbolt-3-vs-USB-C-cable https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-difference-between-a-Thund...
- monocasa 9y agoAnd yet, I plug an Ethernet cable into a switch manufactured 20 years ago, and it works great, albeit at slower speeds.
- MisterTea 9y agoSame with a USB mouse from 2003.
- kbenson 9y agoTwenty years from now plug a new USB-C cable into something manufactured twenty years ago and it may work too. You know what might not work too great now over Ethernet even if the connector works? An IPX/SPX device, since there's nothing to connect to on the other end. Your Ethernet network will be functioning perfectly, but you'll find yourself having trouble getting internet access because your router/firewall/etc are all running IP.
- monocasa 9y ago> and it may work too It may work. It doesn't even now. And IPX/SPX work just fine. I was actually playing a DOS game over multiplayer the other night.
- kbenson 9y agoMultiplayer on the same LAN (or with translation software to TCP/IP), right? Meaning you connected two IPX/SPX devices over it and they worked together. That's expected. But you wouldn't expect to plug in an IPX/SPX device and DHCP an address and use the internet (which would be possible with a IPX/SPX aware NAT firewall), just as you shouldn't expect to plug a laptop that supports Thunderbolt into a bock that support USB-3.1 over a USB-C cable and expect it to work The medium works in both devices, but there's a protocol mismatch.
- monocasa 9y agoUSB-C's situation is so bad that you have to know which of the identical ports have certain features. Your bridging argument is just a red herring. I can plug two devices together locally over Ethernet and expect them to work. I can't expect that of USB-C. Do you not see the difference?
- leetcrew 9y agoit's definitely a pain to have a single connector that may or may not support several different transport technologies and/or power delivery. on the other hand, it's way less bad than having to carry around a different cable for each of those and having to cram all those different ports on the laptop. my guess is that, in a few years, a standard set of the most useful features will stabilize and it will be cheapest to just offer that all the time. in the meantime we just have to deal with the growing pains and read benson leung reviews so we don't burn our houses down.
- MisterTea 9y ago> In other words, it's the equivalent to the Ethernet in your network, over which you run a protocol like TCP/IP, or IPX/SPX Not a good comparison as those are layer 3 protocols. A better comparison would be two layer 2 links such as USB and ethernet sharing the same plug along with devices offering varying levels of support for one, the other, or both.
- kbenson 9y agoI considered that, and while it's ultimately more accurate in specifics, I think it's much more confusing in general considering I'm not aware of much much competition in the data link layer (or at least I'm unfamiliar enough with it to make me unsure of any argument I might make). I don't think there's much difference in the important points by going up the OSI stack slightly, it's still a physical connection and a protocol over it (even if there may be additional protocols between those).