3 ms·
Imagine you were driving a car with a stuck accelerator an no brakes. The car always moves at 100 MPH. So you can't change the car's speed, but you can change
by lisper 9y ago
Imagine you were driving a car with a stuck accelerator an no brakes. The car always moves at 100 MPH. So you can't change the car's speed, but you can change its direction. So you can drive north, at which point your east-west velocity is zero, or you can drive east, at which point your north-south velocity is zero, or you can drive in some other direction, which will give you a mix of north-south and east-west velocities. The faster you move east-west, the slower you move north-south and vice versa.
You are kind of like that car. You (and everything else) are always moving at the speed of light, but through spaceTIME, not through space. When you move through space you are not changing your speed through spacetime, you are only changing your direction. The faster you move through space, the slower you move through time, and vice versa.
- wakkaflokka 9y agoThis is fascinating to think about, and easy to understand. Thanks. I'd like to read a book on this subject written a similar manner. I remember trying to read The Fabric of the Cosmos as a leisure reading book (I like nonfiction) but it got super tedious halfway through and I had to put it down.
- pixl97 9y agoFor those into videos, check out PBS Spacetime on Youtube, they have a few videos on the subject.
- whatshisface 9y agoThe bug in your explanation is that turning the steering wheel performs a rotation (which moves vectors along the edges of circles) on your velocity vector, but in spacetime that would be a hyperbolic rotation (which moves vectors along hyperbolas). The result of this is: If I am an outside observer measuring your position with a very long ruler and your time with my wristwatch, all while watching your dashboard clock, I have access to three numbers. (Your clock, my watch, your position on my long ruler.) There are three ways to compare these numbers. If I compare my watch to your position down the ruler, I will obtain "classical speed." The behavior of this number is very confusing when it is high. I may also compare your dashboard clock with my ruler position, or your dashboard clock with my watch. Both of these can lead to a "speed," in the sense of one number changing at a certian rate with respect to another. If Vx is the rate of change of the ruler position with respect to your dashboard clock, and Vt is the rate of change of my wristwatch with respect to your dashboard clock, and c is the speed of light, then it turns out to be always true that c^2*Vt^2 - Vx^2 = c^2. If you graph this you will see that it is a hyperbola. In the parent's example, the car situation would obey V(north)^2 + V(south)^2 = 100mph^2. If you graph that it is a circle, as it differs from the above by the minus sign.
- lisper 9y agoYes, I know that, but I think this inaccuracy is a price worth paying to achieve an initial intuitive understanding. As a student reflects more deeply on what it can possibly mean to "move more slowly through time" the negative sign on the time dimension can be introduced. But as an initial intuitive picture to get a student out the the Galilean rut I think the circular rotation works well.