4 ms·
This comment should be higher up. It's not the advertisers. It's the ad network not noticing that bad actors (that aren't advertisers) are gaming the system.
by tyingq 9y ago
This comment should be higher up. It's not the advertisers. It's the ad network not noticing that bad actors (that aren't advertisers) are gaming the system.
- na85 9y agoIs that distinction relevant to the user? I'm still blocking ads and javascript everywhere I browse. If the ad networks are the ones distributing this malware, they're either complicit or negligent. Either way, the source of the malware from my perspective as a user is still "ads".
- soared 9y agoI just commonly see users get mad at "advertisers" when in cases like this, advertisers aren't involved at all. Not to say they don't carry some blame, but its blackhats doing the major wrong. Advertisers and publishers should pressure ad networks and browsers to do a better job fighting fraud though.
- tyingq 9y agoIf they want to direct feedback to the right place, sure. Ad networks need the pressure. Advertisers can't do much to help.
- na85 9y agoWell, I don't think most users care about directing feedback. I know I personally would rather just deprive them of the impressions with noscript and/or ad block. I don't have time to be submitting complaints to faceless Internet corporations. I just want to use the web without being bothered.
- tyingq 9y agoYou don't have to, but I suspect your initial reaction is with the publisher anyway (vs the advertisers).
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoFor the user, no. But this is a technology forum so the distinction is relevant.
- Santosh83 9y agoAnd because you don't notice your PC infected by botnet s/w, does that mean you can expect to get a free pass from spam filters? Ad networks operate for profit, they are not charities, therefore they should invest the effort to secure their systems if they want what little goodwill that remains to not evaporate.
- bunderbunder 9y agoThis seems to be an inherent problem with the ad network model. You've got 3 or 4 different parties involved in the current ad system: The content publisher who host the ads, the ad network, the advertisers, and, possibly, the company the advertiser hires to write the ad. And it's not like old school print ads where the content publisher gets to look over a proof before everything gets sent out. Several of these parties either don't or can't really understand how the ads really work and what the final product is going to be like. In this kind of situation, whose responsibility is it to maintain integrity and keep the bad actors out? I'm not sure that it's anybody's. _Maybe_ it's the ad network's, but, realistically, they're sitting on top of an immensely complex system that is going to be very hard to police properly, so they won't spend the money on it unless they're forced to. I suspect that the only way to force them to do it is to have a court find that an ad network hosting a malignant ad is either tortious, or makes them an accessory to a crime.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> In this kind of situation, whose responsibility is it to maintain integrity and keep the bad actors out? Publishers bear liability for serving up malware to their readers; ad networks for serving up malware to the publishers. We're just waiting for an enterprising lawyer/litigation financier to put the pieces together.
- bunderbunder 9y agoI don't know that the liability question is so clear cut. Is there any relevant legal precedent?
- manicdee 9y agoIf someone in the ad delivery chain doesn’t take responsibility, they won’t be selling ads for long. When it’s not malware it’s bitcoin miners. Actually … hang it, just thinking about where the threshold is has taken up too much of my time. I will just block all ads.