4 ms·
"Do they do so in a compelling way?" I'm not even remotely a Shelly scholar, and really don't know all that much about Frankenstein's authorship, so I'm not su
by pmoriarty 9y ago
"Do they do so in a compelling way?"
I'm not even remotely a Shelly scholar, and really don't know all that much about Frankenstein's authorship, so I'm not sure my opinion counts, but from skimming The Man Who Wrote Frankenstein I found the arguments interesting. I think it'd be worth reading for someone interested in the topic. I haven't read the other book.
As for whether the arguments were compelling... well, many of them sounded reasonable to me. But I don't know enough to judge whether many of the claims were true or not.
For example, (if I remember correctly) the book alleges that Mary was not educated, either formally or informally. That seems to argue for her lacking the education to write Frankenstein. But is it true? In another thread on HN someone claimed that Mary got an excellent education from her father. Did she? I don't know.
Another example: The book says that many of the subjects covered in Frankenstein, like science and the Gothic, were interests of Percy's but not Mary's. Also, I think the author claimed that those interests were in evidence in much of Percy's other work, but not Mary (if I recall correctly). If that's true, it would again argue for Percy's authorship of Frankenstein. But is it really true? I don't know. I've never read anything else by Percy or Mary, and don't really know anything about their lives.
It would be great if some reputable Shelly scholars substantively and honestly engaged with the arguments presented in these books and either refuted or substantiated their claims, point by point. But as far as I know that's never been done.
"What do they say about the manuscripts written out in her hand?"
Mary transcribed many other works universally recognized as authored by Percy and dictated by him to Mary. So just because they're in her hand doesn't mean she was their original author.
- christudor 9y agoLast month I was chatting to the guy who is editing the 1818 edition of Frankenstein for Penguin and he said that the consensus is that Mary wrote F., not Percy.
- TillE 9y agoClaims of secret authorship always fascinate laypeople, you see it especially with Shakespeare. It never gains traction with academics because there's no serious evidence. People are basically suspicious because she's a woman who only produced one good work, but that's not uncommon! Harper Lee and S. E. Hinton spring immediately to mind.