4 ms·
If people are choosing to have fewer babies before recessions, their decisions must be made based on some information they have. So looking at pregnancies is i
by mcphage 9y ago
If people are choosing to have fewer babies before recessions, their decisions must be made based on some information they have. So looking at pregnancies is interesting, but at best it shows there’s something still missing. And trying to find that might be a little less intrusive then looking into pregnancies.
- igravious 9y agoWe could make it a law that if you become pregnant you must report it so that the government can use the data to protect all citizens against recessions. If you don't report it it could be made law that you lose your medical insurance or something.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoIs this a joke? Now we're peering inside women's uterus' for some social policy gain? How about, your dick gets hard, you have to report it. How about that? Have a problem with that? Geeze.
- igravious 9y agoI was following the reasoning to its logical conclusion. I thought it was an interesting thought experiment where social values and national interest collide. Would never ever in a million years advocate for something like this. I think individual privacy trumps national interest practically† every time. One can test ideas by stretching them to their breaking point and following lines of reasoning even into surreal territory. † edit: Aaargh, had to give myself some wiggle room. Think I could be persuaded to drop the `practically'.
- jiojfekjl 9y agoWell the test results came back. And it looks like people hate your idea. Thank goodness. Be careful suggesting contemptible ideas in jest. Online, people will think you're serious. And in the HN bubble, you risk normalizing these dangerous ideas.
- randomdata 9y agoIt could be that people having fewer babies causes recessions. Babies, even before they are born, require a fair amount of economic activity to prepare and later care for them. When that activity slows it may be enough to ripple through the rest of the economy. But certainly more research is needed.