6 ms·
Connecticut Hunting Down Online Shoppers Who Didn't Pay Sales Tax
- k2enemy 9y ago“Usually we don’t have the data, but in several cases companies have said … we’ll squeal on our customers and you can beat up on them,” Sullivan said. “The people who sold to them have ratted them out.” Seems like a weird thing for the commissioner of the tax department to say if the tax department is trying to solicit the cooperation of said companies.
- giarc 9y agoI agree, I had to read that sentence a few times to make sure I wasn't missing some end quotes. I imagine this is a case of a tax guy not used to the spotlight, finally getting in the spotlight and not using PC language.
- natecavanaugh 9y agoThat was exactly the first thing I noticed. I think it's incredibly odd, but revealing, that even the tax man knows there's a common feeling of being beat up by taxes. Then again, I'm not sure if tax commissioner is a position that usually attracts the politically savvy.
- heartbreak 9y agoIf you come to the comments without reading the article, just know that Newegg.com is the last place you want to go the next time you need a part for your PC. They turned over at least 4 years of customer sales data to the State of Connecticut evidently without any real pressure applied by CT, and now CT residents who made purchases on Newegg as far back as 2014 have received a tax bill.
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoOnly sounds like a problem for people who want to break the law.
- dgzl 9y agoOr, put another way: who needs trust and privacy when you do nothing wrong?
- larrik 9y agoIt's a stupid and relatively unknown law.
- lostcolony 9y agoStupid, yes, unknown, no. Every piece of tax software I've used has asked "Did you make purchases online without paying state sales tax?", and in saying "Yes", will ask you how much you spent. Now, obviously, I don't keep receipts, so I just estimate, but paying an extra $30-50 at tax time just to ensure that it looks good to the IRS, -and- if something like this happens it looks like I paid, is worth the piece of mind.
- js2 9y agoThe IRS doesn’t care about state sales tax. Your state agency is probably called something like the Dept of Revenue. Overpaying taxes “just in case” seems like an odd strategy to me. It’s hard to believe anyone doesn’t know they are responsible for paying their own sales tax on out of state transactions. It’s on the state tax forms, the tax software asks about it, your tax preparer will ask about it, etc. It was also big news when the states were going up against Amazon for collecting sales tax. Besides that, ignorance of the law is never an excuse for breaking it. Anyway, NewEgg has to have known that some consumers were purchasing from them to avoid sales tax and that this will lead to reduced sales.
- Blackthorn 9y agoHey can you tell me how to spell "pedantic"? Thanks.
- dgzl 9y ago> It’s hard to believe anyone doesn’t know they are responsible for paying their own sales tax on out of state transactions. I really wish you were being facetious. I get the feeling you'd be very surprised to learn about your fellow citizens and their knowledge of American tax laws. > Ignorance of the law is never an excuse for breaking it. I disagree. From the perspective of someone who doesn't know the law, how are they supposed to follow it? Even an intelligent and competent person doesn't know all the laws, especially in America. I would wager that every person in this forum has broken at least one law without knowing it.
- wlesieutre 9y agoI've read on reddit that the letters have gone to people with $2000 or more total over those years, if anyone sees one for less I'd be curious to know how much it was for. I've bought stuff on Newegg and haven't received a tax letter, but I didn't spend $2000.
- AdmiralAsshat 9y ago>“Newegg Inc. has provided the Department of Revenue Services records of your online purchases during taxable years 2014, 2015 and 2016,” the letter reads. “According to these records, you made purchases from Newegg in at least one of these years but were not charged Connecticut sales tax. Therefore, you owe state use tax on the items you purchased because you did not pay sales tax to a retailer.” Well, that's the last time I'm using NewEgg.
- dahdum 9y agoYeah...they used to be the good guys fighting against bs patents. Now they are ratting out their customers?
- atomical 9y agoSo not related at all then.
- BoorishBears 9y ago“Ratting out” “Following tax laws”
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Yeah...they used to be the good guys fighting against bs patents. Now they are ratting out their customers? I'm pretty sure the state of Connecticut is to blame here, not NewEgg. It's not NewEgg's job to violate tax laws on its customers' behalf. If Connecticut-based customers dislike the actions of the state (which I hope they do), it's on them to make that known to the state. The only language that makes NewEgg look like they are proactively giving up this data comes from a spokesperson for Connecticut itself, who has a vested interest in making it look like NewEgg is to blame, not the state.
- devinl 9y agoNo this is an issue with Newegg. They had the option to either "Begin collecting sales tax from Connecticut customers going forward and send that money to the state, or turn over the records." They chose to give their records to the government which causes a major hassle for those users (and increases the likelihood that those records get breached, infringing on users' privacy). They did this at the expense of potentially hurting future Newegg sales because they'll have to honestly show users the tax while they are buying things, rather than having the government hunt down users later on.
- throwaway2016a 9y agoI have a relative who lives in Connecticut and was telling me he got an email from New Egg with three years worth of purchase history on it and a notice saying that they would be sending a copy to the state. Starting to collect new taxes is one thing but collecting back taxes for three years just doesn't seem right. This isn't behavior CT invented, though. I live in New Hampshire (that has no sales tax) and would often hear stories of Massachusetts state police camping out at the border doing spot checks to make sure people paid their taxes. No idea if they were "boogey man" stories or real though. The sales tax system in the US is horribly complex. That's why while companies have popped up to help online retailers navigate it.
- bsg75 9y agoIf those troopers are the same state police who are primarily charged with traffic enforcement and public safety, using them as revenue agents sure seems like a misuse of public resources. I wonder if they collect enough tax revenue to cover salary.
- tlrobinson 9y ago> misuse of public resources Is it still misuse if it’s net positive for the state?
- bsg75 9y agoI guess it depends on perspective, and how the net is measured. If net positive _revenue_, and your perspective is stage budget (or you benefit from state funding) its a win. If the net is a calculation of revenue, public safety, and overall community, maybe not. Troopers are generally traffic and criminal law enforcement agents - public safety. Tax law enforcement may be the jurisdiction of state police in that region, but its rare to use patrol to enforce those laws. There is typically a division specific to revenue. Taking focus from patrol away from the enforcement of criminal and traffic laws and pivoting that to securing the state budget would be considered by many to be a misuse. If troopers are looking for unpaid taxes, who is looking for reckless or drunk drivers? Who is conducting area patrols where visibility is a much a crime deterrent as actual arrests? What probable cause is used to stop any car at the state border and look at receipts? Traffic violations do not provide for vehicle searches, and IIRC there are no dogs that sniff out undocumented expensed. Such divisions in jurisdiction are in place so that the "long arm of the law" does not get too long.
- larrik 9y agoI was already pretty unhappy with both Newegg and Connecticut, and then I got this email from Newegg. It's very frustrating.
- DanCarvajal 9y agoI mean, most states do have some sort of Use Tax, and if you don't pay it you can get in trouble.
- neverminder 9y agoMaybe this sounds naive, but as a European I'll never understand this, why doesn't US just implement country wide VAT?
- gph 9y agoThis is about state-level tax revenue, not federal-level. Plenty of states don't have a sales tax.
- neverminder 9y agoI guess what I was trying to say why don't they just scrap all state sales tax in favor of one country wide tax like VAT.
- abfan1127 9y agobecause we are a federation of states, with whats supposed to be a thin layer of federal government intended to only make sure the states play nicely with eachother, provide a post office, and a national defense. Clearly, we've gotten away from these basic services.
- ceejayoz 9y ago"New" Federal taxes in the US - even if they make sense and just replace a different one - are basically a non-starter in the current political climate.
- gph 9y agoWhy doesn't the EU scrap all state level VAT for an EU wide VAT?
- ergothus 9y agoUS attitudes and logic about taxes are quite different, particularly in the last 30 years. In my mind, the main difference is the attitude about the role and benefits of govt - see the "you didn't build that" debate, that I believe would viewed as obvious in most European countries and yet was used as fodder for political attacks in the US. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/You_didn%27t_build_that https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/You_didn%27t_build_that
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoWhy isn't CT going after NewEgg for failing to incoporate sales tax into their checkout process? No one expects to be personally responsible for sales tax, considering all of the transactions they're used to have the seller incorporating sales tax into the price paid. Pushing that burden to the consumer and surprising them with a demand for unpaid taxes they didn't know existed is unethical.
- giarc 9y agoRTA >The issue of imposing sales tax on out-of-state purchases ultimately may be settled by the Supreme Court. >In a 1992 case dealing with a mail-order office supply company, the court ruled that states could not require companies that did not have a physical presence in their state to collect sales tax. It goes on to say that South Dakota has passed a law saying out of state retailers need to collect state sales tax, but that the supreme court has agreed to hear a challenge to the case.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoRight. What I'm arguing is that if they can't make the sellers collect sales tax, then they can't collect sales tax at all. Expecting consumers to keep track of sales tax themselves for every little purchase (often hundreds per year!) is nuts.
- BoorishBears 9y agoWho said no one expects to be held accountable for use tax? There’s a field right there on your tax forms for it, it’s very clearly explained: http://www.ct.gov/drs/cwp/view.asp?A=1510&Q=270228 http://www.ct.gov/drs/cwp/view.asp?A=1510&Q=270228 I wonder how many people are going to be caught pants down if they go after more companies...
- throwaway2016a 9y agoNewEgg doesn't have to unless it has nexus (a physical location) in the state. If it does not have nexus it is up to the consumer to pay their own taxes. It has been this way since the mail order days.
- 9y ago
- DisgracedCarrot 9y agoThe tiny little conspiracy theorist in me wonders if these records will be used to establish probable cause to search for people who may be mining Crypto and not reporting the income. Why else, of all places, would they start the fight with Newegg? Either way, this state is broke and will do anything to dig themselves out of the grave they've dug.
- giarc 9y agoRTA "Newegg and other companies gave up their customer records in response to letters that the state tax department sent last summer to about 150 online retailers that have significant sales to Connecticut residents."
- zrm 9y agoThis is incredibly ham-fisted. If you're going to go through the trouble of doing the accounting and submitting the numbers to the state, just collect the sales tax and remit the money. Doing it this way has no apparent advantage at all and several disadvantages. It's worse for privacy, because if you remit sales tax then the state knows your total for the state, not who your customers are and how much they spent with you (obviously a problem for specialty retailers). It's worse for bureaucracy and waste, because instead of automatically paying at the time of purchase, everyone has to fill out separate paperwork and pay separately. And it's worse for small businesses, who now retroactively have to waste time unscrewing this because Newegg just told the state that they owe a bunch of sales tax they may not actually owe, because the parts they bought were either resold to customers not in Connecticut or resold in Connecticut where the small business itself already collected the sales tax.
- giarc 9y agoThe advantage to Newegg is that they don't have to add 6.75% to their prices. Things look cheaper.
- zrm 9y agoDisguising the true cost of a purchase is not something I would file under advantages, and neither will Newegg when their customers stop doing business with them after discovering that they've unnecessarily foisted this accounting burden onto the customer.
- giarc 9y agoIt is an advantage since they, and their competitors are not required to collect the sales tax. Therefore if a person is price comparing across two sites, 1 with an extra 6.75% and 1 without, the person is likely to choose the lower price, even if they are required to pay the tax personally down the road.
- zrm 9y agoThe market value of putting off paying $18 in sales tax for six months at 2% interest is $0.18. Not a lot of people will be signing up to fill out paperwork for ~$0.18. Especially when, because it happens at scale, it only means the state has to raise the tax rate by that amount to raise the equivalent revenue to cover the bond interest it has to pay because it didn't get the money sooner.
- mhb 9y agoIs it possible to pay anonymously and ship to a non-home address (e.g., P.O. Box or locker)?
- ars 9y agoIf you're going to do that, just ship to a state without taxes and then go pick up the item.
- tfandango 9y agoOklahoma state tax always had a line item for internet purchases, where you either had to tell them a total amount spent, a promise that you spent nothing online, or an agreement to just pay a small percentage of your taxable income. I always thought this was stupid as I buy a bunch of little things online. I always grudgingly paid the percentage but recently the state stopped asking this because something like 90% of people said they don't buy anything online. Amazon does charge OK tax now.