3 ms·
This analogy doesn't hold water. We have hundreds of thousands of soldiers and sailors, and can muster more if/when needed. If we only had a dozen, then the
by CamperBob2 9y ago
This analogy doesn't hold water. We have hundreds of thousands of soldiers and sailors, and can muster more if/when needed. If we only had a dozen, then the fact that they can be killed by a 20-cent bullet would indeed be a HUGE problem.
That's what a carrier is: an irreplaceable multi-billion-dollar sitting duck. This was adequately demonstrated by Lt. Gen. Paul Van Riper, who (IIRC) spoiled a major wargaming exercise by spamming the enemy's capital ships with speedboats, USS Cole-style. Of course, the military's response was to change the rules to disallow Zerg rushes. Hopefully the Chinese, Russians, and/or Iranians got their updated copy of the rulebook.
- j9461701 9y agoRiper used his personal access codes and authority as a US general to cheat the test. He also exploited the wonky weapon allocation rules in the game to load down speed boats with several times their weight in heavy weapons - which outside a game would either sink them or make them utterly sluggish. He also communicated with his men using civilian phones, but then claimed he was using "motorcycle couriers" and therefore he should be totally immune to all surveillance. Motorcycle couriers who happen to travel at the speed of light, use no gas, and took none of his men to operate. He basically was trying to pull of a peasent railgun, and then got pissy when people told him he still had to obey the laws of physics with his strategies whatever other rules the navy's scenario involved. https://1d4chan.org/wiki/Peasant_Railgun https://1d4chan.org/wiki/Peasant_Railgun The idea of "spamming the enemy with speed boats" as a tactic is over 130 years old at this point. It was called "the young school" of naval thought, or Jeune École in its native French. It failed spectacularly in the real world, because militaries need only invest in a few destroyers armed with rapid fire cannons and the entire plan goes belly up. A hundred speed boats were simply no match for one destroyer armed with machine guns.