3 ms·
I think that the user expectation when clicking Like next to an antelope chair is to register approval of an antelope chair, not to sign up for the I-can't-beli
by patio11 16y ago
I think that the user expectation when clicking Like next to an antelope chair is to register approval of an antelope chair, not to sign up for the I-can't-believe-its-not-mailing list about antelope chairs. Your savvier users probably understand that Liking is semi-public rather than anonymous, like HN upvotes are. (Your savvier users clearly do not include some of my younger cousins, grumble grumble.)
Compare Antelope Furniture's desire to deliver news about its new sales to their legal requirements for handling things like email. Someone has typed in their email address (which is only used for receiving communication): can you assume they want to hear about your sales? No. Someone clicks a thumbs up. Can you assume they want to hear about your sales? ... Really?
I mean, pretend for a second that HN makes its upvote buttons into functionally equivalent copies of Facebook like tomorrow morning. Do you think the #1 thread in the morning will be titled "Wow, cool"? (Particularly after somebody with multiple kilokarma gets the bright idea to hit the broadcast button?)
- mikeknoop 16y agoThat might be the expectation of certain "Like" buttons floating around the web, however Like buttons (aka "Become a Fan") within the Facebook context have always allowed that Page or Open Graph Object owner to publish messages into your main news feed. Why would you want to create two different user experiences tied with one common button?