10 ms·
How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights
- mattnewport 9y agoWhy does the headline say "the Bill the Rights" instead of "the Bill of Rights"? Is this the glaringly obvious typo it appears to be or am I missing something? This is the actual headline of the article, not just the HN headline.
- skookumchuck 9y agoUnfortunately, pretty much all of the BoR is regularly under attack. Those rights have to be constantly reaffirmed.
- flossball 9y agoThe Supreme Court loves to ignore the ninth. Somehow the fourth amendment is about convenience now? If we aren't detained or delayed, the government can copy, search, and scan anything they want. It appears the third now too is gone and the government can do what it wants on your land without permission or compensation.
- aaronbrethorst 9y agoIt appears the third now too is gone and the government can do what it wants on your land without permission or compensation. I'm pretty sure that the United States government has not been forcing anyone to house soldiers. https://constitutioncenter.org/interactive-constitution/amendments/amendment-iii https://constitutioncenter.org/interactive-constitution/amen...
- mindslight 9y agoMitchell vs City of Henderson. They've all been pwnt in one way or another.
- aaronbrethorst 9y agoThe Mitchells lost their case—at least on the third amendment claims.
- kelnos 9y agoIsn't that exactly the point the parent was trying to make? (Having said that, it's arguable that the police were not asking to be "quartered", and in any case, the 3rd concerns soldiers, not police.)
- aaronbrethorst 9y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2015/03/23/federal-court-rejects-third-amendment-claim-against-police-officers/?utm_term=.063992f817e2 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...
- kelnos 9y agoYes, I understand that. Please don't fling URLs around as a substitute for discussion. The court dismissing the idea that there is a 3rd Amendment issue could exactly be what the parent was talking about, if he does indeed believe it was a 3rd Amendment issue.
- mindslight 9y agoYes, exactly. It would be tautological to consider the Supreme Court's decision to be the final word on the truth of the matter - doing so would imply that it's impossible for the government to systematically violate any rights/laws.
- arca_vorago 9y agoActually, this is one of my main retrospective concerns with the tactics we were using in Iraq and I assume Afghanistan. We would literally take over some random families complex at night and dig in for the fight come morning. It was sop, but it wasn't till after I got out and thought to myself, hey that seems like a violation of the 3rd amendment even if it's in another country during a time of war.
- exabrial 9y agoOn their defense, people mean well, but 'the road to hell did paved with good intentions' as they say. 1st Amendment is being attacked by liberals, with pronoun laws, hate speech regulations, equal opportunity laws, forced cake baking, many other things. The 2nd is also being attacked from a variety of ways by liberals, which as said before, is well intentioned, but ultimately destructive. Thank goodness the 3rd isn't an issue! The 4th amendment is being attacked by both conservatives and liberals in a variety of ways. From NSA data collections on Americans under Obama, to DEA/BATF sponsored civil asset forfeiture under Bush, and unlawful searches by ICE under the current administration, this Amendment is very important but is being chipped away by both authoritarian ideologies. Ah, our 5th amendment has been weakened by both liberals and conservatives. From No Fly lists and travel bans you can't get out of, to waiting periods on firearms, we've truly let this very important amendment become weakened. I like all of the amendments. I don't want to see any single one of them weakened any more and some of our rights restored.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoThe first is being attacked by conservatives. Attacking the Bill of Rights isn't exclusive to one end of the political spectrum.
- notMick 9y agoSeriously? The only people keeping the first amendment there are the conservatives! The left are trying to remove it with their various 'hate speech' laws (already done in many countries, say the 'wrong thing' on Facebook in the UK and you have the police coming to arrest you in hours) which can be applied to anything the left simply don't want you to say - and silencing you is fundamental to far left ideology.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoYou have Donald Trump trying to undermine the news media, attacking people for expressing their opinions by refusing to stand for the anthem, calling for stripping the citizenship from those who burn the US flag, and wanting a ban on Muslims entering the country. Attacks on individual liberties are not limited to a particular political ideology.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoIt wouldn't be worth having the bill of rights if they weren't. That's their entire point.
- skookumchuck 9y agoIt's an interesting argument. I sure get distressed when otherwise intelligent and educated Americans sincerely tell me: "Sure I believe in free speech, but you can't let that guy say those things!" They'll throw it all away for some insignificant gain.
- ben_w 9y agoI hear that. Counterpoint: propaganda is a thing, how do you get the benefits of robust (and I don’t mean loud or rude) debate to find the best policies without the risks of propaganda? How do I know I have not fallen for propaganda myself when I argue for or against some policy?
- skookumchuck 9y agoYou don't know. You accept that when you accept free speech. Besides, propaganda vs truth is like porn vs art. It's impossible to define, and there's no human I'd trust to make such decisions (not even myself).
- ben_w 9y agoThere is only one truth, there are many possible propagandas. If the truth cannot be known, then we don’t have democracy, we have government by highest advertising budget.
- pixl97 9y agoSorry, the truth can't be known. There are likely some physics laws that can explain this better than I can, but the farther in time you get from a physical event, the more information is lost (entropy leaving your light cone). This leads to 'evidence' that allows multiple valid interpretations.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- IIAOPSW 9y agoThis article is critical of the "cult" of the bill of rights. But look at China the other day and how their constitution was changed on a whim. Look at Russia which has Putin despite of a fairly modern and standard constitution. Constitutions and laws are mere pieces of paper until the society within which they live endow them with sacred status. Without the "cult" and the moral indignation at violations surely civil liberties would erode at a much faster rate. As another comment says "Unfortunately, pretty much all of the BoR is regularly under attack." If the BoR didn't have the same nearly religious status one of those attacks would have succeeded by now.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoYes, people get these things arse-backwards. They notice that laws are just pieces of paper, and think that's a reason to disrespect them. But so long as the law is worth having, the fact that it is a mere defenceless piece of paper is the very reason while people have a duty to act them out in the real world. And what's worst is that the "it's only a piece of paper" argument seems to be trotted out mostly against laws, such as constitutions, which underpin important, time-tested rights. No one is so eager to point out that the latest act granting power to this-or-that official is also just a piece of paper.
- freddie_mercury 9y ago> If the BoR didn't have the same nearly religious status one of those attacks would have succeeded by now. I don't think this follows at all from the article. After all, one of the main points is that there WASN'T a cult until the 1940s...yet those rights were able to stand for 160 years without a religious status supporting them. Your argument that the Bill of Rights had a religious status for all 200+ years of its history seems a direct contradiction of one of the book's central claims and I don't see that you've presented any arguments in support of your counter-claim. If the Bill of Rights didn't have religious status for those 200+ years then your subsequent claim that the religious status is a necessary part of keeping it intact would seem to wither.
- tlrobinson 9y ago
- Meekro 9y agoReading the Soviet Bill of Rights is pretty instructive because it'll show you how much such a thing is worth on its own. Here is just a subset of the rights guaranteed by the USSR Constitution: speech; press; religion (both to profess and refuse to profess); assembly (including a specific right to demonstrate); participation in lawmaking; inviolability of the person (from warrantless arrest) and of the home (from unlawful entry or search); privacy of all correspondence (including phone conversations); right to challenge actions of government officials and bodies in court; right to a job; work week limited to 40 hours; free medical care; welfare payments in old age, sickness, or disability; free housing; free education; academic freedom for scientists. It's a very good list, and what I listed above isn't even half of it [1]. Precisely none of those were actually respected by the government. Having a Bill of Rights is great, but having a tradition of limited government, checks and balances, and rule of law is what gives those guarantees any weight. [1] https://www.departments.bucknell.edu/russian/const/77cons02.html https://www.departments.bucknell.edu/russian/const/77cons02....
- dragonwriter 9y agoNote that the rights in the Soviet Constitution have an important explicit limitation in Article 39: “Enjoyment by citizens of their rights and freedoms must not be to the detriment of the interests of society or the state, or infringe the rights of other citizens.”
- adrianratnapala 9y agoThis sort of thing is common in well run democratic countries too. European constitutions are full of provisions that say "Such and such a right is inviolable, except when it's not". Or "except when it is violated according to the law". And it works! That's because (in recent decades) the political reality in Western Europe has been basically in favour of democracy in freedom -- and so they limited basic rights only in corner cases like Holocaust denial. Constitutional texts can help people focus on what is needed for democracy and freedom (and US the Bill of Rights does a good job of this), but what really counts is how people live out the text, rather than the mechanics explicit in the text.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoI am no American, but I think Americans are wise to revere their Bill of Rights partly because it is a reasonably good model for rights that everyone should have but also because Americans have lived for a long time with those particular and have made them mostly work. And as the article makes clear, the Bill of Rights didn't really just happen in 1789, it has evolved and (mostly) improved over 200+ years. And that's a good reason to be skeptical of worries about "fetshising" it and dreams of how you could "remake the legal and political world". Big changes happened after the Revolution and the Civil War, how could they not? But evolution has happened at at all other times.
- protoplant 9y agoIn the post, Magglioca says that the bill of rights was not what people of the time thought a bill of rights looked like. Well I find it is not accurate to say that since many ideas were lifted from the English Bill of Rights 1689. No standing armies in peacetime, freedom of speech of parliament, peasants bearing arms, no cruel unusual punishment, no excessive bails, no taxes without parliament. I hope that I am missing something in translation, because it is unsettling that he would overlook this. The Virginian Bill of Rights mentioned in the story took from this as well. In other words, it set a standard.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoIn New Zealand we don't have a constitution. But rather we have a Bill of Rights defined in law, which can be changed by an act of parliament, and a series of laws defined around this bill of rights. It's not the constitution that makes a country free, but the people fighting for their rights. New Zealand gave women the vote before any other country in the world, and we didn't need a constitution to do it, but rather the willpower of the people.
- arca_vorago 9y agoI ctrl+f'd "natural rights" and came up with nothing, which is how I knew from the start this wasn't a very good article on the subject. Look, here is the thing that people have forgotten, or were never taught (due to a failing civics education system): People have natural rights, independent of any government, and governments are formed among the people in order to protect those rights. The government does not grant rights! It can not take them without due process! This is the fundamental principle of what I consider real American exceptionalism, and why American government at least in principle is the most free system of government in existence. (despite it's failings to live up those principles often) It's why Christopher Hitchens became an American and called it "the last revolution that stands a chance". This was the original debate about the Bill of Rights in the first place. That by listing a few important rights the government would then think anything not listed would be allowed for the government to violate. Hence the "right to wear a hat" argument. That's not how things work though, and that's not what our government was founded on. I'll give you a good example. Locke calls the right to self defense the first natural right. I agree. The second amendment is about defense against a tyrannic government. You could take it away and I would still have a right to bear arms independent of the (theoretically) absent second amendment. Both parties hate stating this sort of thing out loud though because what they both are is authoritarian. For the conservatives, it would undermine all kinds of their moves like the drug war (unconstitutional abuse of commerce clause, states rights), and the same can be said of the left. This is why I get tired of all the cries anytime someone sees through the bullshit and calls them both equally corrupt, which they are, and are immediately hit with logically fallacious half-retorts of "whataboutism" and other rebuttle du jours. I swore an oath to the Constitution, and I stand on those principles even when they make me uncomfortable. I'll give you another example. I always thought FDR's New Deal was one of the best things ever, a brilliant move we should seek to emulate in the modern day. When I dug into it though, I have to admit I have seen enough evidence that many of the New Deal policies were unconstitutional that I have an entire reading list prepped just to dig into the matter. So you can see how for someone who really wants more wealth equality how difficult it is to potentially admit minimum wage just might be unconstiutional. At least I am meeting those hard questions head on though, instead of burying my head in the sand.
- kelnos 9y ago
- DanielBMarkham 9y ago"...And he worries that this process of reinvention may have stalled, with Americans now fetishizing the Bill of Rights, having lost sight of their own ability to remake the legal and political world..." And I'm beginning to seriously doubt my time commitment to this article. The actual history of the Constitution and Bill of Rights is quite interesting and involved. It covers everything from classical literature and history to The Enlightenment and the Thirty Years' War. Just talking about how some folks revere the docs so much now and didn't in the past is breathtakingly shallow. As an example of how short-sighted this is, note that the BoR wasn't supposed to say anything that needed saying. Some questioned the need for them at all. The government wasn't constructed to get that overpowering and intrusive into all of our lives. It's made not to do that. Why should we start making lists of things it can't do? It obviously can't do anything we didn't tell it to do. The founders in the U.S. dispassionately threw together a huge chunk of natural science, philosophy, and history, made a ton of compromises, and did the best they could. You don't have to worship or deify the folks or the documents they made. Just understand what was done and why. That's much more useful than going on at length about how unhealthy some segments of the population are being. This article is a political polemic, not a history lesson (unless you consider it a lesson on how things get more and less popular over time, which says absolutely nothing about the BoR) I love political essays that show how public thought changes over time. These kinds of essays tend to be difficult to discuss in large diverse online groups -- and many times, sadly, their purpose is to create false, simplistic narratives that can take the place of understanding. Best consumed in small doses and with lots of context.
- ataturk 9y agoI stopped at "fetishization." The BOR is the last thing Americans have standing between us and technocratic tyranny and we're losing badly even then. ETA: It makes me so sad to read that anyone would support the repeal of the 2nd Amendment. I think maybe you haven't researched the subject enough and are using emotional reasoning to guide your thinking versus taking a really hard look at history, not just American, but WORLD history and realize that governments can't be trusted and that they are merely the monopoly of force that eventually seeks to overwhelm all reasonable restrictions on them by their very nature. Government is our monster, but when it gets out of control that monster kills millions in a single bite. 1st Amendment -- the right to speak your peace without fear of reprisal 2nd Amendment -- the ability to enforce ^ even if you don't win, you still stuck it where the sun don't shine, proverbially speaking. 3rd, 4th, 5th, ... -- All the lessons learned from dealing with the British Crown and their minions in the colonies. I guess all of them are, actually, when you think through it. Those were bad times and I hope we don't visit them again although I'm sure we will since it is human nature to forget important lessons.