> If the HN experiment has worked for so long ... HN is relatively good for an Internet forum, not for scientific literature. It's not even good professional I

> If the HN experiment has worked for so long ... HN is relatively good for an Internet forum, not for scientific literature. It's not even good professional IT work product - that's not an insult; it's not what the forum is intended to be. I'd be very concerned if the quality of scientific research and review dropped to this level.