3 ms·
Ask HN: What's your take on the homeless crisis of San Francisco?
Hey HN. I've been wanting to see some discussions on HN about poverty in San Francisco. I've been planning to move to San Francisco for a lot of obvious reasons, but the current state of the high number of homeless in the streets and safety in the city has been making me think a lot about this decision.
I wanted to know how poverty is perceived in SF and the bay area, and what are the different organizations that are set up to help. I wanted to know if this is a problem that has sprouted start ups or involvement from big tech companies.
Also, is this problem a state problem or a federal one? Is there a solution being planned? Or is there already something in place that sets to reduce the number of homeless in the region on a 5/10-year period?
Thanks!
- ardit33 9y agoThere is no true political good will to reduce the number of homeless people in SF. It takes a two pronged approach, both 1) advocating compassion and help, and also 2) enforcement of laws. Help must be in the form of guarantee of food and some sort of basic shelter for people into a tough spot, and enforcement for people that regularly break laws, sleep/urinate/defecate on the streets, etc.... Non-profits are not inclined to do anything about 2, and often will decry-hamper any effort to fix this. Here is some food for thought: Why does San Diego, which has much better weather than SF, has a much lower level of homeless people? TLDR: Non-profits, and radical liberals, have created an environment where homeless folks are encouraged to move into SF and nothing is truly done for their condition. As the joke goes: If you are homeless, move to SF, as your friends are already there. Most of homeless folks are people that came from other states, and not Bay Area locals, which means SF has become a collection point (or dumping point), of most homeless people from all other cities of the west coast. The cynic would say follow the money: and if you follow it, non-profits have no real incentive to fix the problem. On the other hand, building more housing is so tough that this situation is guaranteed to get worse/or stay the same, and never improve in the near or mid term.
- justboxing 9y agoSan Francisco resident since 2006 here. I love it here, but your observations are correct, the homelessness situation has gotten out of control. The homeless population is largely 'contained' within the Tenderloin District[1] of downtown. By contained, I literally mean that you'll find cop cars parked at the corners and edge of that district (see map). This area contains a majority of the homeless population and the cops patrol it along the edges day and night in an effort to 'contain' crime and violence within that 10 block area. I used to volunteer at San Quentin to help non-violent offenders find jobs when they re-enter society. Almost all the ones that were getting paroled would end up in the Tenderloin. I was told that there are about 60 Liquor stored in that area. Add to that drugs, it's a recipe for re-offending and coming back to the Big House. The homelessness has been a problem even before the tech boom. The media and the non-techie residents like to blame the tech scene for it, cos it's a nice big juicy target. The situation has been exacerbated by Nevada dumping 500-ish mentally ill patients into San Francisco.[2]. So you'll find a lot more homeless people who are also mentally ill, and acting it out in public. I recently had an incident where a mentally ill person claimed my motorcycle was his, and pulled a knife on me when I tried to leave. He even quoted some random VIN number. Had to call cops, prove that I was the owner, and then had him arrested. That said, it was the single incident in over 10 years, so I think I've generally been safe with the homeless population around me. YMMV. Because of the mentally ill homeless population, you may sometime find yourself in the middle of sidewalk with some nutty guy yelling on the street or generally acting crazy, and that un-nerves some people. Also, in the summer if temperatures go over 70 degrees ( somewhat rare), the whole downtown smells like a giant urinal, from the homeless people defecating on the streets, sometimes even in the public transport [ BART ] stations [3] Regarding 'solution being planned', I've found that the current Mayor(s) and Supervisors just kick the can down the road, leaving it for the next Mayor or Supervisors to deal with. They make new building and Condos designate a specific set of units as BMR (Below Market Rate) but even a BM 1 BR 600 Sq Ft or so costs over 300K, so not really affordable even to qualified working people. [1] Tederloin District Map: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Tenderloin,+San+Francisco,+CA/@37.7839295,-122.4174298,16z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x8085809068ae37cb:0xb65a70d852b4620a!8m2!3d37.7846598!4d-122.4145058 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Tenderloin,+San+Francisco,... [2] SF reaches $400K settlement proposal in Nevada patient-dumping case: http://www.sfexaminer.com/sf-reaches-400k-settlement-proposal-in-nevada-patient-dumping-case/ http://www.sfexaminer.com/sf-reaches-400k-settlement-proposa... [3] Human waste shuts down BART escalators https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Human-waste-shuts-down-BART-escalators-3735981.php https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Human-waste-shuts-dow...