4 ms·
Anecdotal, but I've heard the same from most women (those that know me well enough to share) in tech. The worst female bosses they've had were far worse than a
by tyingq 9y ago
Anecdotal, but I've heard the same from most women (those that know me well enough to share) in tech. The worst female bosses they've had were far worse than any single male boss. The story usually boils down to some version of "I succeeded in a harsher environment, suck it up".
There are a few exceptions, of course. Some people have risen through the ranks mostly based on tactics like fear and intimidation. Some male, some female.
Edit: Fwiw, I'm male, but with a decent track record of my female hires surpassing my success.
- jancsika 9y ago> The story usually boils down to some version of "I succeeded in a harsher environment, suck it up". Mm, that quote characterizes the root of a lot of evil in the world (or at least propagates a lot of evil). Anybody know a graceful way to disincentivize that kind of thinking?
- tyingq 9y agoI'm not sure, but some version of pointing out that men are being held more accountable these days? That is, success shouldn't be dependent on some innate ability to fend off, deflect, or ignore sexual advances and other forms of gender discrimination?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- stcredzero 9y ago> > "I succeeded in a harsher environment, suck it up" > Mm, that quote characterizes the root of a lot of evil in the world (or at least propagates a lot of evil). That quote isn't a root of evil. It's a statement that has originated in something good, which can be co-opted for evil. My own parents have said that to me. In many instances, their using that idea was for the good. However, there are some instances where the trauma of their occupation/wartime experiences showed, where they used this idea for something bad. Also, one of my professors told me something like that, when it came to my first exposure to C programming in the early 90's. Sometimes you are in a harsh environment, and you do have to suck it up and get on with it. Knowing that others have done objectively better than you are now in an objectively harsher environment is good and useful data to have. Anybody know a graceful way to disincentivize that kind of thinking? Thoughtcrime? Sorry, but seeking to prosecute thoughtcrime is far, far worse than just receiving information others have done better with less -- even if it is being used as a means of aggression.
- fapjacks 9y agoHey I just wanted to post in solidarity with you about the truly harsh environment (and having to suck it up) of learning C programming in the early 90s. I still to this day tell people in interviews that the most difficult and challenging technical experience of my life was cutting my teeth on pointers in C by myself in the early 90s with nothing but the K&R book.
- AgentME 9y ago>Thoughtcrime? The other user is just asking how to encourage people to be nicer in a specific circumstance, not seeking to literally criminalize things.
- stcredzero 9y agonot seeking to literally criminalize things. You don't have to have legal support to create an environment of oppression and toxicity. If one's goal is solely focused on suppression of a certain kind of thinking, then it's doomed to fail. It's like not thinking about white elephants, writ large. It's the Streisand effect. It's far better to focus on positive goals. Build bridges between people. Encourage what you want to see more of. If one is considering thought policing, then it's a sign that something has failed.
- wyattpeak 9y agoThis is such a broad interpretation of thought policing as to be absurd. By your definition obligatory anger-management or even general counselling would seem to be thought policing. You can demonstrably control particular types of thought, that's pretty much the basis of clinical psychology. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ironic_process_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ironic_process_theory - which you're describing - is a specific, immediate, psychological effect. It doesn't imply that thoughts can't be suppressed on a longer scale.
- stcredzero 9y agoThis is such a broad interpretation of thought policing as to be absurd. No, your interpretation of it is absurd. The key is, are you trying to coerce people to hide their true thoughts, because you just want to control them? Anger Management should be something that is entered into consensually, because all parties know it's to their benefit. You can demonstrably control particular types of thought, that's pretty much the basis of clinical psychology. Sure. But suppressing others against their will for the sake of political power is immoral. I don't see that as a proper aim of clinical psychology, and the above context certainly wasn't what I was thinking about.
- debt 9y agoI can confirm similar that women in tech I've spoken to have said some of the worst interactions they've had have been with other women.
- lkrubner 9y agoThis was already discussed on Hacker News, but there needs to be an accounting for the fact that women's participation in the tech industry peaked in the 1980s and has declined since: http://www.smashcompany.com/business/why-are-women-being-pushed-away-from-the-tech-industry http://www.smashcompany.com/business/why-are-women-being-pus...
- tyingq 9y agoThe data in that article is compellingly. I wish I truly understood the issues. I've had several female understudies that seemed destined for rising to the top. None of them, except one, have. They've come close, but backed out here and there. For reasons that seem unrelated to male influence. That doesn't necessarily point to an issue, mind you. I backed out myself for personal issues. Could have had big roles, but declined them for non work related considerations. I'd like to think their reasons were similar, but it's hard to tell.
- stcredzero 9y agoI've had several female understudies that seemed destined for rising to the top. None of them, except one, have. They've come close, but backed out here and there. For reasons that seem unrelated to male influence. I'm very skeptical of some cries of conspiratorial male oppression. (Though not all.) However, I do think there is something in the structure of our society which acts as a powerful disincentive to women at a certain point. I did an architectural walk-through awhile back, and spoke to the CEO/architect of the small company that designed that building. My take-away from her was that, in order to "have it all," she basically had to build a smaller company that dealt more on a personal level with clients with doing smaller projects, as opposed to a larger company which could take on much higher-profile projects. I think there is a significant element of the communal which is vital to human well-being and high functioning, and that this missing element has something to do with what seems like unreasonable demands placed on working mothers and the frequent decision taken to reduce career emphasis to raise children.
- stcredzero 9y agothere needs to be an accounting for the fact that women's participation in the tech industry peaked in the 1980s and has declined since The data in the article is by percentage. By numbers, I'd expect women's participation to be up.