12 ms·
The Dropbox Comp
- 013a 9y agoI wonder if Dropbox has the capability of entering the PIM space like G-Suite. I get the feeling that there's room for another custom domain email provider beyond the monoculture of Gmail. They had Mailbox at one point. Email is definitely a hard space to get into, but I'd certainly move my domain to it if the price is right and it bundled in a calendar. Paper has been a huge change in the way my team collaborates on documents, between the very easy sharing and super fast interface. I'd love to see what they can do for email and calendars.
- inthewoods 9y agoPaper is interesting but boy have they missed the opportunity so far imho. Paper doesn't come close to what Quip has been able to do, and they failed to capitalize on email. My impression, right or wrong, is that they are very slow at development compared to their competitors. What I think the article gets right is that Dropbox focused on files - which are being abstracted away. At my current company, we have Dropbox and Google Drive, but it's clear that if we're going to use G-Suite then Dropbox needs to go. What they could do: with their new-found public status, they could buy Smartsheet to get a solid Google Sheets competitor. I'm sure they can find a calendar provider. Of course, I'm not confident that they should point their ship into the eye of Office 365 and G-Suite - I just don't see what their other options are.
- dasil003 9y agoI can't speak to the business side, but I certainly like Paper much much more than Quip as a product. In general I find integrated multi-function suites to feel janky and half-baked compared to their single-function competitors.
- inthewoods 9y agoDo you use G-Suite or O365 alongside it? I don't see significant improvement over a Google Doc.
- dasil003 9y agoYes, I use all three. Paper's focus on content vs formatting make Paper feel more elegant and more "meaty" for product development/engineering purposes. Admittedly it's a tough sell over Google Docs for much the same reason that Google Docs was a tough sell of O365 a few years ago—it just doesn't have the functionality to fully replace it. That said, Paper has an elegance about it as a product that reminds me of Facebook vs MySpace ca. 2006, or Slack vs HipChat ca. 2014, where it serves a modern use case in a fundamentally better way, less of a local maximum if you will.
- danieldk 9y agoPaper's focus on content vs formatting make Paper feel more elegant and more "meaty" for product development/engineering purposes. And the support for equations makes it great for sharing research notes as well.
- inthewoods 9y agoMy team has been using https://jupyter.org/ https://jupyter.org/ for this purpose.
- inthewoods 9y agoAgreed on tough sell - I just don't see enough value in Paper to make it worth it. Same is true for Quip by the way.
- 013a 9y agoThey've clearly spent a significant amount of product development on building out their enterprise functionality. The functionality there is pretty powerful. Dropbox has a lot going for it. While the concept of a "file" is constantly being abstracted away by The Powers That Be, its still the most general form of data storage and sharing, and its something every power user will always need. Dropbox has proven that they have unique organizational expertise in this area; competitors have had years to come up with something as powerful as Dropbox Sync, and no one has yet. I'd argue Google is the only company close, and its still not as good. I might be in the minority, but I am fine with Dropbox's product development speed. They could go out and buy new companies, but I'm afraid they'd start approaching "Atlassian-style" product development; silos of products that only work together through tightly defined integration paths, bad user experiences, promoting a piecemeal "we use Jira but nothing else because they're not the same product" approach instead of a single "Dropbox Experience". What I'm not fine with is their product direction. Enterprise features are great! But Showcase? Why did they have anyone working on that? They should be focusing on attacking the team collaboration space. Maybe that means building out knowledge base functionality like Quip or Confluence. Maybe that means more Paper-like document types, like powerful spreadsheets or spreadsheet/database hybrids like Airtable. Maybe that means enterprise chat like Slack! Or, maybe foundational PIM tools like email, calendar, contacts, custom domain management, etc. I don't know. But they definitely do feel like they're in a period where they're not sure what direction they should be moving in, and I hope they fix it.
- brightball 9y agoI’m a big fan of Paper, personally. I wish they would make it into a Docusign/Ecosign replacement. They have all of the tools needed to do it well.
- TarpitCarnivore 9y agoI think with Paper, Dropbox is going more for a collaboration tool than a full suite replacement. When they were trying to do more with Carousel & Mailbox is when things began to feel like they were losing site. I haven't used Paper, but based on the video it appears to be much more straight forward in team approach than Quip or GDocs. To me Gdocs feels like it's a more full featured replacement to Office and Quip is too simplistic of an approach. Paper seems to perfectly hit the middle ground.
- 013a 9y agoGDocs is definitely a full office suite replacement. It could capture the same use case of Paper, but it tends to be too heavy and focuses too much on formatting. Quip is a definite competitor. It tends to do better for knowledge base style collaborations, whereas Paper is better for ephemeral collaboration. But it is lightweight and focused enough to be useful for both. As a sidenote, I really think Google is missing an opportunity here. Drive could really use a Paper-style competitor. Start with the collaboration foundations of Docs, but remove all the cruft. No font changing, no formatting beyond what's in markdown, remove all the menus, streamline the interface, add some integrations like embedding Sheets-style spreadsheets. They'd capture a lot of marketshare that has G-Suite domains, but reaches out to other tools to manage ephemeral collaborations and knowledge bases.
- danieldk 9y agoWhen they were trying to do more with Carousel & Mailbox is when things began to feel like they were losing site. But Carousel was really consumer-focused, whereas Paper is clearly (presented as) a business tool. I think that they realized with Carousel that most Pro users use Dropbox for work, so that is where the money is. As someone who also uses Dropbox for work, I think that they could make Dropbox even more attractive by adding some services. They should not try to compete heads-on with full office suite, but I can imagine that Paper + Calendaring + Chat could really be awesome for work.
- gfosco 9y agoConsistently amazed at how many words he can write without saying much of anything.
- fullshark 9y agoI think it’s unfocused but there’s a lot of interesting ideas/lessons in here imo.
- swyx 9y agowriting about high level tech and strategy is an art form. you probably want to see deeper detail, more in depth examples? me too. but although he isn't saying much of anything to you, (and sometimes I struggle to understand it too), be careful of dismissing things you don't understand that have gained a lot of validation. The crowd may not always be wrong and I like the challenge of understanding a different mindset from my day to day level of thought.
- akchin 9y agoI found the article very insightful. I spent the weekend reviewing Dropbox's S1 and had the same issue - they are not being completely honest about their cohort retention numbers. They have created some new metrics/charts that show increasing value but doesn't show the real metrics - what is specific cohort churn etc. This article mentions that very clearly. Don't get me wrong - Box's initial S1 also had some very abstract cohort metrics. They took some very early cohorts and extrapolated from that. I think they are more open now as there is more stability in those metrics and they are moving in the right direction.
- tptacek 9y agoThat's interesting. I got a lot out of it: - He seems to believe Dropbox is superior technically. - Box is Dropbox's closest competitor. - Fundamentally there are two ways of making money from storage, enterprise direct-sales and consumer self-service. - Box has self-service as a loss-leader for direct-sold enterprise accounts, and accounts for the operating costs of its self-service accounts as a marketing expense. - Dropbox doesn't; we don't really know Dropbox's cost of customer acquisition, which is a big deal for a consumer product. - A much greater percentage of Box's accounts are paying customers - Box can put together customized offerings for enterprise customers in ways Dropbox can't and so Box has negative churn. - On the other hand, running the business this way means that the early investors in Dropbox (including Drew Houston) kept a far larger part of the company for themselves. - Box is outperforming Dropbox in the market. - Atlassian is outperforming both of them. - File storage is probably not the strategic high ground for enterprise computing, something Thompson used to think. Dropbox is about to go public. An analysis that suggests they're a niche company is a big deal. Dropbox's investors will be betting that they're not.
- KarenSatantsby 9y agoPlease comment - I cant understand this at all.. So Box - I thought was dead.. is better than Dropbox because it has less customers who pay more..I pay for Dropbox.. Dropbox is better than the other things like dropbox that I can remember that I have used. Onedrive which is like a guy who puts his pants on backwards. Creepy uncle Google drive - Hey look I made a neato book of your kids at the beach. Box.. Hello where are my pictures from my phone.. oh.. you dont want these. Dropbox is like that guy who means well and is very efficient. He wants nothing to do with your pictures other than that they are safely part of backed up stuff.
- kevinios 9y agoI recently sent an email to Dropbox support, asking/begging them to let me pay for their service. But at a normal price for a lambda user. Dropbox is the only cloud service that I absolutely love since it was released, the only one I really want to support... and the only one I am not paying for. I pay for iCloud and for Google Drive, 2-3$/month each. As a normal user, I do NOT need 1 To of storage for 10$ a month. I need a few hundreds Go, and am happy to pay 2-3$ a month for those. I understand there are reasons to focus on "Entreprises", but still... My money is just waiting to be taken and has been for years. This year, I gave up on waiting for them and started paying for Google Drive, and unloaded some old files from Dropbox to Drive. I would just like the exact same features I've been using since years, but with a few more Go of space available. That's all I am asking for. And that's 25$ a year I would be willing to give Dropbox, instead of me being a free-rider since years.
- braderhart 9y agoG Suite annual plan is $99 and includes unlimited storage.
- kevinios 9y agoTo clarify, I do not need more storage, I already have what I need with Dropbox + Drive (that I already pay for). But I need more storage on Dropbox, because that's my preferred way of handling Cloud storage (having the files on my computer at all times) and I love that Dropbox has been pioneering the field with a great product. I want to support them, but not at 5x the price of competitors.
- dchuk 9y agoMaybe their product is worth the price because the features you just rattled off aren't provided by other companies to a satisfactory degree and therefore Dropbox is 5x better than competitors for you?
- dotsh 9y agoThey make great software, service and hire very talented people. Everything costs and you are not will to pay merely $10 a month? It's just silly.
- williamstein 9y agoThis article is about the low-touch versus high-touch tension of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16421438 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16421438, illustrated by Dropbox versus Box.
- rrggrr 9y agoThink back to about 2009... there was a company called drop.io that was purchased by Facebook and their product summarily executed. It was a simply and elegantly executed Dropbox, Slack, Box, Discord-ish all-in-one solution. It was about 5-10 years ahead of its time. There is room for Dropbox to expand and grow revenue beyond file storage/syncing. One hopes the billions they will raise after IPO will be applied to a more drop.io-ish offering.
- PrimalDual 9y agoI love dropbox but one of their biggest problems is their refusal to support more than 300,000 files in their sync clients. I have considered moving to google but I need local copies since I often don’t have internet connection but I still need my files. Either way, they have a useful product even if they won’t dominate the enterprise or consumer market.
- zawerf 9y agoOh wow I didn't know about that limitation. Doing `find . -type f | wc -l` I have ~270000 so I am about to hit it. It would be great if they can implement a .dropboxignore so I can get it to stop syncing node_modules folders. I really wish I could agree with the others saying "It just works" for dropbox sync. I have ran into many other issues around filename casing, file permissions, symlinks, etc in the past.
- xzel 9y agoThis is a great idea. The only current ability I've found to hide files is by entire folders and per machine. Its also less of an ignore as a don't download here. Its really limiting and creates weird folder abstractions I don't need just because I want something to be able to be excluded on a specific computer.
- Kagerjay 9y agoshouldn't you be putting your code repositories in something like c:/www folder, and using purely git to track it? There's lots of 3rd party solutions for .dropboxignore personally I've used many of them and am not a fan of it (perl scripts, 3rd party apps, etc). I wish dropbox would natively implement .dropboxignore, but its probably never going to happen since only a small % of users voice their concerns for it. Average dropbox user probably doesn't care or doesn't know what a .dropboxignore is.
- zawerf 9y agoI do use git too. But it's nice to be able to jump between multiple computers without needing to push an incomplete commit to remote (when I get tired from sitting in front of desktop I switch to laptop to code in bed). Also dropbox's 30 day version history did save me a couple times when I accidentally deleted something before committing. And not having to worry about losing the day's work even if your computer fails is good for peace of mind. That said this hits a lot of edge cases with dropbox syncing since it's not built for this kind of workflow. Every time you do npm install it will cause thousands of files to sync. I have had the .git folder get corrupted when I start using it before it has fully synced. Or git would handle syncing internal symlinks/permissions/casing differently and I would need to rely on git to restore.
- mankash666 9y agoDropbox keeps getting compared to atlassian, which confuses me. I portend it's VCs lying to themselves about Dropbox's price-to-earnings ratio to justify their $10B fantasy as pricing Dropbox with box's P/E would value it around $7B, a whole 30% lesser than they'd like
- padobson 9y agoI think one of the opportunities Dropbox missed was being unwilling to replace FTP. I've built dozens of HTML/Flash/Java uploaders on dozens of different infrastructures, and there's always a host of issues that need to be dealt with. When a product's UX doesn't work with FTP, it requires a lot of extra engineering. But allowing your customers to move files around with their Dropbox account completely eliminates this problem. The HTML5 File API has largely solved this (though it still exists, I still have to occasionally restart YouTube uploads. YouTube!), but Dropbox could have been the solution, and I can't imagine how many startups weren't built on top of Dropbox because they didn't want to be in the replacing-FTP business.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoI had dropbox for awhile and I answered a good question which they gave me ~300GB. It was convienent for a few years but I slowly started to not use the service. Collaboration with friends moved to other services. Now, I plan on moving my files off of it to Amazon. I only paid for the pro version for version history. I think its nice as a free service but now since I have so many Apple products and Airdrop I don't really have a need for the product at all. Also, if I want to share larger files or work documents I would always use google docs (now moving to aws work docs). I hope to be off of both Google services and dropbox soon as I really only use Dropbox for archiving stuff I don't want to lose. I think my answer is biased due to the 300GB unlimited account I have though.
- yueq 9y agoit is a dying business in all means. The brand name might worth something though.
- foxh0und 9y agoI'd move back to them if they could implement something similar to Spider Oak, where I can choose where to sync individual folders on the machine. (IE, preserve my /home/username/<documents/pictures/downloads>)