3 ms·
GCP charges pennies for storage; they auto-dedupe on the backend too. Although I imagine the bandwidth is a high cost. Speaking of cost, Apples war-chest is no
by dijit 9y ago
GCP charges pennies for storage; they auto-dedupe on the backend too. Although I imagine the bandwidth is a high cost.
Speaking of cost, Apples war-chest is not small- if anyone can afford a premium, it'd be them.
- nik736 9y agoI am not sure what you mean with pennies, they charge the same as AWS, and Dropbox just showed that doing everything inhouse saves them millions of $$.
- muninn_ 9y agoSure but when you take all factors into consideration it may not be worth the cost.
- epicide 9y agoWhen you are one of the largest companies in the world, millions really isn't all that much (for your infrastructure).
- IncRnd 9y agoWhat is the measure you are using for Dropbox being one of the largest companies in the world? In the beginning of 2017 Dropbox claimed a $1 Billion dollar run rate, however at the end of 2017 Dropbox had a net loss of $110 Million. When your entire year is a loss of $110 Million, saving $75 Million is very important to the companies survival.
- sleepychu 9y agoThe dedupe would be ineffective here unless there's key re-use since Apple AES-128s every chunk before it goes to 3rd party storage.
- lultimouomo 9y agoIt appears they derive the chunk encryption key from the chunk content, so dedupe will be possible if they don't randomize the IV or nonce ([0], page 53). The guide also mention convergent encryption, which would confirm this. Personally, I find it sketchy privacy wise. [0] https://www.apple.com/business/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf https://www.apple.com/business/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf
- IncRnd 9y agoThese types of busy-work machinations are often done by cloud providers around encryption. The purpose is apparently to say they use ciphers but also keep the keys in order for decrypting data. Cloudkit and iCloudDrive use Account Keys, but it isn't clear if those are key encryption keys or data encryption keys. It also isn't clear if those are protected from information only from the client, or if the cloud is able to freely read them. The differences are massive in regards to privacy, and this document really doesn't have the needed technical information to make an informed decision.
- 013a 9y agoDoes GCP GCS really autodedup? I haven't seen anything in their documentation that suggests they do, and generally deduplication is known to have unavoidable performance characteristics, especially if you're in a very distributed environment.