7 ms·
Los Angeles’ homelessness crisis
- jakecrouch 9y agoPeople at the top of our economy are generally oblivious to how bad things are for the bottom half. The top 0.1% commands the same wealth as the bottom 90%. Historically wealth inequality finds its outlet in political unrest, and there is probably more of that to come in the next decade. In the last election a socialist and a populist both got suprising amounts of support, even though the broader economy was supposed to be doing well. The next recession will hit the bottom 50% hard, and we could see truly strange things if that occurs near an election.
- ShabbosGoy 9y ago> People at the top of our economy are generally oblivious to how bad things are for the bottom half. Generally oblivious or willfully ignorant with malice?
- throwaway1748 9y agoThat's an easy statement to make, but I don't think it holds true for most wealthy people. Especially wealthy people in Silicon Valley. If anything, most wealthy people I know are extremely aware of how bad things are for the bottom half and regularly vote against their economic self-interest for progressive candidates. Runaway inequality isn't due to some evil conspiracy by rich people to hoard money from everyone else. It's due to the leveraging nature of technology and the plummeting demand for unskilled labor
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jjeaff 9y agoIt seems that rather than trying to fight the laws of economics with rent controls, special housing, and welfare programs, the focus should be relocation and job placement in less expensive areas. It's unrealistic to try to get someone a low end job that will support them long term in one of the most expensive cities in America. With the $1.2B bond measure, you could rent housing for every single homeless person in LA for a good 5 years in middle America. (less than $500 a month all in).
- stevenwoo 9y agoGiven that about a third are mentally ill, that would not be adequate - the other states would undoubtedly object - so some sort of interstate pact or national program would be required for that sort of plan.
- jernfrost 9y agoIsn’t the problem that republican controlled midwestern states chase all their homeless people out to democrat controlled big cities? They are not willing to pay anything to help the homeless. They are not even willing to look at them. They want it to be somebody else’s problem. I think that is a problem with having open borders between states but not equal social programs. It leads to a race to the bottom.
- newfoundglory 9y agoNot exactly - the bigger problem is that all the republicans controlled midwestern states are shitty economies and so people move to places where they hear that people can get jobs (functioning liberal states) and when that doesn't work out they end up homeless in the new city. (Various polls of homeless people in Seattle have found that most of them were already in the area immediately before they became homeless).
- refurb 9y agoNot sure you made it a Republican/Democrat thing when I can think of several high unemployment/poverty Democrat states and low unemployment/poverty Republican states.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoNot surprisingly, facts don’t back that up, at all... https://www.bls.gov/web/laus/laumstrk.htm https://www.bls.gov/web/laus/laumstrk.htm
- dfee 9y agoThis is a very curious comment. Troubling, too. The answer you’ve offered up for confirmation reflects a perspective that is as bad as the one you’re demonizing.
- maximexx 9y agoEvery living being on this planet should have the basic right for a house. It's a primary need. Houses should not be part of the "free" economy and should not be allowed to be traded for profit. If this pyramid scheme continues the future will look very grim for billions of people.
- kenhwang 9y agoBut does that house need to be near the beach? Why not Kansas?
- Johnny555 9y agoPerhaps if you said "home", I'd agree with you. Not everyone needs, or even should have a house. But everyone should have housing.
- Torwald 9y agoI strongly disagree with everything you just said. (Except the overall notion that all people should get to their rights.)
- prostoalex 9y agoCan the house be mobile?
- mirimir 9y agoReading this, I'm reminded of hobo life during the Great Depression. Hoovervilles. And in those days, you could at least get around on freight trains. I'm also reminded of my own time living on the road. In my late teens through early 20s, as an illegal immigrant. And indeed, I spent some of that time in LA and SF. But mostly in the Pacific Northwest. Living in the forest, and squatting. But it wasn't that bad, because I had many friends. And it was fun to drift aimlessly. But eventually, I went to college and grad school, so hey.
- sshine 9y agoI was homeless for a year in my late teens. But I also felt it didn't hurt me because I was young enough to still feel that it was a choice of my own, and I did go to school. As the article points out, only a third of homeless are addicted, so the problem is not really about the homelessness itself. It's about losing hope and being alienated by your own community. I always wondered why so many homeless people like to flock around where it's crowded.
- mirimir 9y agoI didn't actually feel "homeless" in a bad way. Someone we knew usually had a place where we could crash. And some source of food and money. Weed and LSD were always available, and sometimes psilocybe and peyote. But then, this was decades ago, before "homelessness" became a thing.
- robert_foss 9y agoI write software for a living, and have on more than one occasion had the opportunity to live and work in California. Seeing the poverty and, how the poor are treated in San Fransisco, Los Angeles, and every other large US I've been to, is so degrading and offensive that the idea of participating in the financial system that sustains it is unacceptable. Surely I can't be the only one who feels this way.
- Johnny555 9y agoWhere have you seen the poor and homeless treated better? It's a hard problem to solve, even by throwing a lot of money at the problem. Part of the problem is that some people want to be homeless (for a variety of reasons (or a combination of reasons) like not losing their independence, not trusting the system, wanting to continue a drug/alcohol habit, bad experiences with the system previously, mental illness, etc). In a country that values individual rights, it's not clear how you help that person get off the streets without forcing them. In a city with relatively mild climate like LA or SF, it's even harder to get the homeless into shelters where social services can more effectively help them. Granted, there are plenty of people that do want to get off the streets, but not everyone living on the streets is willing to make the sacrifices to do so.
- robert_foss 9y ago> Where have you seen the poor and homeless treated better? In most countries with functional social security networks. Canada, Germany and Sweden. So while the above are leaps and bounds better, they aren't flawless. Canada has lots of mentally ill people on the streets due to _very_ poor mental health care available to them. And Germany and Sweden have people from Romania begging on the streets, since they're part of a group of people that have been historically (and currently are) mistreated in their homeland. > In a country that values individual rights.. If you want people off the streets, offer them free housing. There is even (and remarkably so) an example of this from Utah, where free housing was provided to the ones in need. And the city saved money doing it, since fewer other services were needed as a result. Also, separately, I find this argument to be a bit of a straw man, since the treating homeless people decently and having strong individual rights aren't fundamentally opposed. In America some things are done well collectively, in the interest of everyone, like providing roads.
- jernfrost 9y agoGood example of how private charity doesn’t work. The US has gotten ever wealthier, or primarly the 1% the exact portion of the population who should have been most capable of funding charity. Yet this problem grows. Charity is able feed people but not turn around people’s lives. You need comperhensive government programs for that.
- refurb 9y agoSF spends $150M on homeless and it's one of the worse cities for homelessness. You really think money is the problem?
- Letmesleep69 9y agoAm I alone in thinking that 150 million is not that much? When I was in SF i saw so much poverty and suffering I could not believe my eyes and I have seen homelessness plenty before. Build more affordable, high density homes and give them to the homeless for free for a few years with high amounts of care if you want to solve the problem.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- refurb 9y agoI don't have the exact number, but if you divide $150M by the number of SF homeless it's more than $30,000 per person. I would argue it's what we're doing with the money that's the issue, not how much money there is.
- prostoalex 9y agoThe economically disadvantaged are the easiest to help as they cling to every opportunity to get their life back in shape. But then you have the mentally ill, mentally disturbed, drug addicts and the criminals to abet them. A coordinator for a local charity in Santa Ana had a post on a local NextDoor mentioning that their charity was running below capacity. Few reasons people would refuse any help and continue tenting by the river included: * general requirement by the charities to have drug- (which includes alcohol-) free zones * people didn't want to be "in the system" whatever that meant, many did not want to be tracked by government or agency of any sort * some homeless objected to the religious nature of some charities * for some easy access to drugs was paramount (and concentrated encampments enable this to great degree) * other mental issues Not sure these can all be solved by more money.
- kenhwang 9y agoSo, the thing that always bothers me about how Los Angeles is reported on is the lack of normalization for population. LA is really big with a lot of people. It will naturally have higher population of homelessness. 57k/10.2m is ~0.56% homelessness, which is about par with Seattle (11.6k/2.1m = ~0.55%), but significantly better than SF (7k/870k = ~0.80%) or NY (77k/8.5m = ~0.90%). Given LA's unrelenting rapid gentrification, wealth, and income inequality, I think the situation can easily get much worse. But at least we're trying, trying to make the situation better, or at least slow down its progression. I'd hate to see us give up and invest in anti-loitering securitybots instead. The wealthy here haven't become that out of touch and scornful yet, but keep writing articles like this and maybe they might.
- ShabbosGoy 9y ago> I'd hate to see us give up and invest in anti-loitering securitybots instead. Why would you need securitybots? Orange County police departments already do it for free by dumping homeless people in Long Beach. > The wealthy here haven't become that out of touch and scornful yet I guess you’ve never interacted with people who live in Newport Beach. Or LA for that matter. Are you sure you’re from LA?
- cylinder 9y agoIt's an example of major cities taking on what really is a federal problem. NYC and LA run welfare programs using local tax dollars. This is so obviously a federal-level problem that requires a massive federal project to solve. Putting this burden on the local residents of LA, SF, NYC etc is incredibly unfair. It's also inefficient to build homeless shelters in dense LA county when there is so much cheap land throughout the country (with people looking for work, too).
- Bucephalus355 9y agoAll of this reminds me of the modern version of the Great Depression. Economists have gotten smarter this time around and have covered up the unemployment rate and CPI, but it’s mostly the same. Studs Terkel, probably the most famous interviewer / oral historian who’s ever lived, wrote a book containing hundreds of oral histories about the Depression. It sounds just like today: Hard Times: An Oral History of the Great Depression https://www.amazon.com/dp/1565846567/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_Yh8KAb3VAXQCK https://www.amazon.com/dp/1565846567/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_Yh8K...
- grondilu 9y agoIt's a bit paradoxical that homeless people can be a problem in a specific geographic area. By definition, it should be easy to relocate them.
- RickJWagner 9y agoIt's a really hard problem. Some people are down on their luck and can be helped. Some people are out of control, there is no way to babysit them to normalcy. Money won't solve it.