4 ms·
I found it extremely difficult to find any employer in Indiana that wouldn't scoff at paying a senior engineer more than $75K in 2015. That is less than my infl
by kevin_thibedeau 9y ago
I found it extremely difficult to find any employer in Indiana that wouldn't scoff at paying a senior engineer more than $75K in 2015. That is less than my inflation adjusted junior engineer starting salary 15 years prior. The entire industry has a problem with fair pay and rushing to the middle is just a way to squeeze more profit from the labor of tech workers.
- throwawayjava 9y agoThis is very true. Even after CoL adjustments, high-tech jobs in the midwest don't typically pay as well as the coasts. Especially in senior roles. Notice that this is especially true for the vast number of coastal-state cities that aren't SFBA [1]. However, this apt observation is not what the article is actually about. Mid-tech jobs are things like "...computer systems analyst, computer network architects, and support specialist...", which are very different jobs from software engineering. [1] As an aside, CoL adjustments between the Midwest and coastal-state cities are extremely favorable to the Midwest in cases where you can actually afford to buy a house (read: not SFBA). If you buy a house in the midwest, you usually have to be okay with treating it as "not an investment". Whereas a house in Portland, Seattle etc. function as both a place to live as well as an investment likely to appreciate handsomely. Personally, I'm OK treating CoL as a sunk cost and not engaging in real estate speculation during my non-work hours. But from an objective perspective, the CoL pay cut suffered in MW cities is often unjustified given the opportunity cost of not living in an area with more and more predictable real estate appreciation. Selfishly, I wish folks in the Midwest had more success convincing their employers that "cheap land" is not a good justification for severely underpaying their labor force.
- Hydraulix989 9y agoHave you taken a look at the real estate markets in Austin, Pittsburgh, or Raleigh? "Buy low, sell high" is the adage of any savvy investor -- the markets in SF have been stagnant for years now.
- closeparen 9y agoWhat? The median San Francisco house is up 6.8% between 2016 and 2017.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- throwawayjava 9y ago> Austin, Pittsburgh, or Raleigh My post was about the Midwest [1]. None of these are in the Midwest [2]. Except maybe Pittsburgh. Pittsburgh is technically not Midwestern because it's slightly more than a commute away from Ohio. But it's also actually not Midwestern because it's not a good prototype for a typical Midwestern city. "The Midwest" does not mean "not the coast". Also, all three of these are in the "coastal states" I'm contrasting with the Midwest. > the markets in SF have been stagnant for years now. Yes, I repeated some rendition of "except SF, which is uniquely terrible even among coastal places" many times in my post. And the problem with SF isn't lack of predictable appreciation. The problem with SF is that you can't afford to make the investment in the first place. [1] https://ces4thgradewiki.wikispaces.com/Midwest+Region+of+the+United+States https://ces4thgradewiki.wikispaces.com/Midwest+Region+of+the... [2] PA and NC are mid-Atlantic and Texas is most certainly in the South.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dmode 9y agoThis is the first time I have heard that SF housing market has been stagnant for years. I made 200k profit on my 600k house in East Bay in 2 years (sold in 2016). That house is up another 100k. So not sure what you are referring to here.
- rdtsc 9y agoThat's why I had to leave the midwest. I was getting low offers and it was even hard to find companies to interview with. As soon as I started interviewing with companies on the coasts and South (TX), I had multiple offers in hand within a few weeks. I would have rather not left family and friends behind but I simply had no choice. One major shift that could happen is if remote work becomes more popular. Imagine if the majority of tech companies were that way. There would be a lot less risk moving back to the midwest or well anywhere knowing that it would easy enough to find another remote job.
- firebones 9y agoIt's hard making this point if you don't have access to capital, but if the talent is comparable, doesn't this represent an opportunity to go after an idea with above-average talent through simply paying globally-optimal market rates and pricing out the competition for talent? It seems that there's an opportunity here to incubate ideas at a discount globally by "overpaying" locally. Are there VC funds that are exploiting this? And I don't mean simply by making margin on the back of exploiting the CoL adjustments, but by drawing on regional talent pools with lower CoLs? I'm shocked there isn't more innovation coming from the upper midwest hub that lies along the belt connecting UICU, Purdue, CMU, etc.
- throwawayjava 9y ago> the belt connecting UICU, Purdue, CMU, etc. Look at the first destinations reports for those CS programs and you'll see what happens. People leave the region after getting the degree. In droves.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- evanlivingston 9y agoWhat's wrong with 75k anywhere in Indiana? As a hoosier myself I'd buy a home in fountain square and have a cush life at 75k.
- throwawayjava 9y agoFor me, the answer would be that in the midwest I have to work for 5-10 extra years. Marginal QoL improvement while doing my 40/wk is less important than accumulating enough to quit the grind. I'd not do SFBA, but other coastal cities with less severe CoL differences pay substantially better than the midwest. You won't be house rich, but you'll be actually rich. And that equals retirement.