4 ms·
Most judges now just seem to be rubber-stamp operators anyways, particularly in pre-trial proceedings and in situations where someone doesn't haven an opportuni
by sathackr 9y ago
Most judges now just seem to be rubber-stamp operators anyways, particularly in pre-trial proceedings and in situations where someone doesn't haven an opportunity to defend themselves against the action (such as in the case of a search warrant).
They suffer from the same plight as the majority of the public-side of our legal system. Too much work and not enough workers.
Judges, prosecutors, police, public defenders, etc...
They all have such a great case load that to examine every single document in detail would grind the entire machine nearly to a halt. The system needs an overhaul but it will not get one in the current political climate. The judicial branch is supposed to operate independently of the legislative and executive branches, but control lies with the controller of the budget.
Reminds me of an outrage a local newspaper reported on several years ago. A fire-rescue/EMT operation had a target response time of X, and had actually been responding in about half that time. This was seen as an indication that they were overstaffed or had too much money/equipment, and the proposal was to reduce the staffing/budget/equipment levels until the response time more closely tracked the target.
- Cw67NTN8F 9y agoYp, your life might get ruined but for the judge it's just another day at the job. Need to clear the docket, meet Jeff for lunch and then plan his golfing weekend. Oh, he owes $127 and he's not here? Arrest warrant!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoOr your fate may hang in the balance of the time the decision is rendered. The person who has their case heard right before lunch generally is given the least amount of sympathy and understanding
- edanm 9y agoThis has been really questioned, and I think largely debunked. The "effect" shown in the study that demonstrated this was probably caused by batching of certain kinds of defendants/cases by time of day, e.g. put the longest (most difficult) cases first, then have a bunch of easy no decisions right before the break. (That's not what really happens, it's just an example, I don't remember what really happens).