10 ms·
Debt Collection Companies Have Hijacked the Justice System
- tachyoff 9y agoThis is disgusting. One of my adult fears is that I’ll wind up on the wrong end of a collections bill or something and everything will go to shit. That being said, our court system was never particularly kind to the poor and destitute (what institution has been?). I’m so thankful that organizations like the ACLU exist and that they continue to do good, solid legal work.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- garmaine 9y ago> That being said, our court system was never particularly kind to the poor and destitute (what institution has been?). I encourage you to imagine a world without the rule of law.
- craftyguy 9y agoWhat, like Mad Max?
- garmaine 9y agoYes. Or just a few hundred years ago when courts were for nobility and the king’s men acted with impunity against commoners like you and me. The point is that the courts and police, although vilified in this day and age, actually by their very nature do help the poor and destitute. Just maybe not as well as they could, ideally.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 9y agoI think you’ve only shown that they hurt the poor less than the other systems you mention.
- craftyguy 9y agoJust because it's better than Ye Ol' Court System does not mean that it is not a discriminatory clusterfuck in 2018. We still have a long way to go.
- meri_dian 9y agoBut that's the point. It's not a discriminatory clusterfuck. You're not accurately representing the system.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoBut it is, but not by race, sex, or age. It's discriminatory purely as a function of money. The more money you have, the "more equal" you are and the more rights you can exert. It also means the less subject you are to criminal laws, as you can mount a powerful defense as opposed to someone who makes 20k/yr in the slums who is statistically likely to be black or hispanic. But our society has spoken, that it's ok for poor people to get sent away and their lives destroyed as a primary function of money.
- dogles 9y agoI’d go as far as say that for the lower class, the difference the modern court system makes is negligible. Whether you want justice or mercy, you better bring cash.
- garmaine 9y agoThere was no old court system. The old system was life was harsh and brutal and there were entire classes above you that could treat you as literal property to be disposed of as they pleased without repercussion.
- benchaney 9y agoJust because the hurt the poor and destitute less than they used to does not mean they are helping the poor and destitute.
- meri_dian 9y agoVery telling that you're being downvoted. So many people seem to have a very biased attitude against our foundational institutions, which is unfortunate because our institutions do a good job of protecting us and and safeguarding justice and order. By "good" I mean that most of the time these institutions do protect the common people. I think much of this bias emerges for two reasons. First, the news we hear is usually bad news. One can only hear so much bad news before developing negative bias. In a large nation like the USA with so many people, abuses of power are almost guaranteed to happen once in a while. It's critical that a free press report on these incidents to keep institutions honest, but an unfortunate side effect of this is negative bias against those same institutions that so often work well and protect us. The second reason is that institutions do have power over us, and look large in our lives. In comparison to them, we are very small. This can be disconcerting and uncomfortable for some.
- kharms 9y agoI didn’t downvote them, but if I had it wouldn’t be for the reason you’re describing, it would be because their attitude is defeatist. It’s like saying “at least there is a minimum wage” in response to “the minimum wage is too low.”
- dogles 9y agoI find it odd that you’re responding (multiple times, copied and pasted) about an article documenting a _pattern_ of injustice and corruption, bemoaning anti-government bias. How is this relevant at all? If you’re arguing the pattern doesn’t actually exist, citations are needed. Otherwise I think this is pretty clear reporting that the courts are not “working well”.
- tachyoff 9y agoI seem to know a lot of anarchists, so I’m very well-acquainted with the idea of a world without the rule of law. Anyway, I think the principles of the American court system are pretty solid. Like all legal systems, it’s made up of flawed humans, and I don’t think it’s impossible to both hold it in some sort of esteem while also acknowledging that it needs improvement. That it is unfair to the poor doesn’t mean the entire system is broken (at least, that would be my argument; I’m sure you could argue that the whole thing IS broken), it just means parts of it need improvement. Let’s not ignore all the ways the court system has succeeded, oftentimes in numerous tiny ways (i.e. cases at the state level that set important precedent and have pretty fair outcomes for the involved parties. C.f. restrictive covenants on deeds. The rulings for my state (Michigan), at least, seem pretty well-reasoned and legally logical.)
- garmaine 9y agoI think you were misreading my statement. I was certainly not advocating for anarchy! Quite the opposite. Life was miserable, brutal, and short before the very progressive step was taken to have police, courts, and he rule of law for common people. It is quite ironic to complain that police brutality and court machinery are oppressing the poor when in fact it is precisely those institutions that prot ct what liberties they enjoy.
- GavinMcG 9y agoI think you're being downvoted primarily by people who read this as an endorsement of a world without law. That is, they're reading it as "since no institution has totally succeeded, I encourage you to imagine a better approach" rather than "while no institution has totally succeeded, I encourage you to imagine how much worse it could be".
- Cw67NTN8F 9y ago>>I encourage you to imagine a world without the rule of law. When you issue loans at xxx% interest, non payment for a lot of borrowers is baked in. Plus, collection should not free (taxpayers money)
- Simon_says 9y agoI think maybe collection should be free. If I loan you $10 and you don't repay it, it's never going to be worthwhile for engage the legal system to reclaim that money. If there's no realistic threat of coming after somebody for $10, then no $10 loans will be offered. I think it's nice to have an environment where legal remedies are accessible to everyone for little to no marginal cost. It promotes pro-social behavior if everyone knows that everyone knows that contracts are always enforced regardless of the economic standing of the participants.
- tachyoff 9y agoExcept clearly that doesn’t work, and clearly some people who take out loans like this aren’t doing it in bad faith. The idea that the threat of punishment is effective at stopping “bad” behavior has, I believe, been thoroughly debunked by psychology. It’s not as simple as “someone borrowed $10 and didn’t pay you back”, typically. Even personal bankruptcy is available to people who borrowed in good faith and couldn’t make the ends meet. But when there is an entire system that is designed and exploited to make it hard or impossible to pay people back (e.g. payday loans or usurious rental contracts), no amount of punishment will get the desired behavior you want because the system itself is broken.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoEverything has flaws. Exhibiting an institutional insecurity by making a take it or leave it response upon criticism, reducing the world to binaries, shuts down any attempt at improvements.
- tehlike 9y agoSame fears, and same conclusion.
- jeffmould 9y agoBack in 2003, I had this happen to me in Florida. I was struggling financially, fell behind on a debt, had a collection agency file a lawsuit, and I took the default judgment. Didn't think much of it and honestly just figured they would garnish wages after that I ignored the judgment (big mistake). About a year later I got pulled over for speeding and they had filed for a warrant. After a night at the police station, I was released on bail, that was actually more than the original debt (prior to interest). I had a hearing scheduled with a magistrate judge to review the debt between myself and the creditor. I appeared for the hearing only to have had the debt sold to a different collection agency and no one showed up. The judge dismissed the judgment against me. The entire hassle cost me not only time but more money than the original debt (and at this point after attorney fees, etc... the amount was more than the original plus interest. Rewinding a bit, when I went for my hearing though I was talking with my attorney and the magistrate that was handling the case. She expressed a great displeasure that this happens all too often and that most judges in civil cases will just rubber stamp what over a creditor files if there is no one there to oppose from the debtor side. Separately my attorney told me that Florida laws/courts make it very easy for creditors to do this.
- tachyoff 9y agoI’m really sorry this happened to you. I’m glad it ended up working out eventually (it seems). I wonder how much time, money, and tears we could save if there were an easier way to simply reach people in these situations to let them know of their options. Of course, a better solution is legislation like that proposed by the ACLU. Hope all is still well with you. Edit: just read your profile. I think you’re doing fantastic work!
- jeffmould 9y agoThanks! Yes, rough time but things usually work out for the better in this case. Definitely learned some important life lessons in a 4-year stretch during that time though. Many of those lessons are being applied directly to my current endeavors. Personally, I think people get scared or have a fear of facing a debt collector in court. I believe that when it comes to small claims judgments (i.e. under $10K) there should be a more personal approach that encourages resolution instead of fear. Maybe instead of "default judgments" that are rubber-stamped by judges, the courts move to a more hands-on approach with hearings between mediators, the creditor, and the debtor. While this may require manpower, the time/cost savings of jailing debtors would be savings in the end. I hope the ACLU is successful in getting legislation passed.
- bernardom 9y agoOne of the biggest problems with winding up on the wrong end of a collections bill is that the lender is usually long gone, having sold the debt to some sketchy collections agency that ignores the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA). The FDCPA has some real protections! Some features: * You can't contact someone other than the debtor (like their boss) and mention a debt. (You can only say that you're "trying to confirm X's phone number" etc.) * You can't call after 9pm * If the debtor asks to not be contacted in any channel other than mail, you must acquiesce immediately (though I think it needs to be in writing) * If the debtor asks not to be contacted at work, you must respect that The CFPB has a page on protections: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/category-debt-collection/ https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/category-debt-colle... And wikipedia has more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_Debt_Collection_Practices_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_Debt_Collection_Practices...
- jopsen 9y agoSounds like a few criminal investigations could clean up industry practices.. Of course that's expensive and only fixes it until the next sketchy business guy comes along...
- ttul 9y agoAnother reason not to live in the US. Jesus.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 9y agoI strongly suspect that whatever country you live in also issues arrest warrants for failure to show up in court.
- GalacticDomin8r 9y agoProbably, but the ones you'd want to live in would notify you first.
- rayiner 9y agoIn the U.S., you'll usually get a notice of the issuance of the bench warrant sent to your last known address. Poor folks often don't have a reliable mailing address. And that's unfortunate. But do other countries handle notice any differently?
- yoklov 9y agoFor the interested, there's a lot more info in the ACLU's report: https://www.aclu.org/blog/racial-justice/race-and-economic-justice/debt-collection-companies-have-hijacked-justice-system https://www.aclu.org/blog/racial-justice/race-and-economic-j...
- sathackr 9y agoMost judges now just seem to be rubber-stamp operators anyways, particularly in pre-trial proceedings and in situations where someone doesn't haven an opportunity to defend themselves against the action (such as in the case of a search warrant). They suffer from the same plight as the majority of the public-side of our legal system. Too much work and not enough workers. Judges, prosecutors, police, public defenders, etc... They all have such a great case load that to examine every single document in detail would grind the entire machine nearly to a halt. The system needs an overhaul but it will not get one in the current political climate. The judicial branch is supposed to operate independently of the legislative and executive branches, but control lies with the controller of the budget. Reminds me of an outrage a local newspaper reported on several years ago. A fire-rescue/EMT operation had a target response time of X, and had actually been responding in about half that time. This was seen as an indication that they were overstaffed or had too much money/equipment, and the proposal was to reduce the staffing/budget/equipment levels until the response time more closely tracked the target.
- Cw67NTN8F 9y agoYp, your life might get ruined but for the judge it's just another day at the job. Need to clear the docket, meet Jeff for lunch and then plan his golfing weekend. Oh, he owes $127 and he's not here? Arrest warrant!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoOr your fate may hang in the balance of the time the decision is rendered. The person who has their case heard right before lunch generally is given the least amount of sympathy and understanding
- edanm 9y agoThis has been really questioned, and I think largely debunked. The "effect" shown in the study that demonstrated this was probably caused by batching of certain kinds of defendants/cases by time of day, e.g. put the longest (most difficult) cases first, then have a bunch of easy no decisions right before the break. (That's not what really happens, it's just an example, I don't remember what really happens).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 9y agoThis is a problem with trying to enforce the law against people who have no money. This is quite a problem with traffic violations. In many states, people get sent to jail over unpaid speeding tickets, not because speeding tickets are punishable with jail time, but because they don't pay the ticket, don't show up to court to address the ticket, don't respond when their license gets suspended, and eventually get pulled over for driving on a suspended license. On one hand, it doesn't seem like people should go to jail for this sort of thing. On the other hand, how exactly are you supposed to encourage compliance from people who can't afford to pay fines and penalties?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 9y agoThis isn't just poor people; it also me. For the past 15 years or so, the only tickets I've ever gotten are for compliance violations, like out-of-date license plate stickers. But because paying tickets is such a pain in the ass, and once you screw it up it gets weirdly hard to pay them without going to some special 2 hour triage line at a very specific DMV, I've had my license suspended multiple times. (Once, I just waited it out; eventually, they sent me mail saying my license had been reinstated). Also: I get so much goddamn junk mail that we can barely keep up with paper mail (I try to have the important stuff sent to my office instead). And a lot of municipal and state process gets routed through paper mail, which is my least effective communications mechanism.
- rayiner 9y agoAnd at least you have a stable mailing address. Most poor folks don't have one. (Heck, many wealthier younger folks don't have one.)
- morgante 9y ago> Heck, many wealthier younger folks don't have one. This is a huge problem and I really wish more institutions would switch to email/phone services. Mail is incredibly unreliable. Last year I had a medical bill which I completely missed due to a changing address. It was something I could've easily paid, but I didn't even know it existed until I got a large ding on my credit score.
- meri_dian 9y agoIt's important that we have an independent press and groups like the ACLU to hold our institutions accountable and bring this sort of abuse to light. However it's also important to keep in mind that we only ever really hear news about these institutions when something goes wrong. We only ever hear the bad, not the good. This bias is unfortunate because our institutions do a good job protecting us and and safeguarding justice and order. By "good" I mean that most of the time these institutions do protect the common people. I think much of this bias emerges for two reasons. First, as I said before, the news we hear is usually bad news. One can only hear so much bad news before developing negative bias. In a large nation like the USA with so many people, abuses of power are almost guaranteed to happen once in a while. It's critical that a free press report on these incidents to keep institutions honest, but an unfortunate side effect of this is negative bias against those same institutions that so often work well and protect us. The second reason is that institutions do have power over us, and loom very large in our lives. In comparison to them, we are very small. This can be disconcerting and uncomfortable for some.
- Slansitartop 9y agoThis is a very weird submission in which to be posting a comment like that. Those foundational institutions should be held to high standards, and it's good that there are people who will call them to account when they fail to "product the common people," especially when the failure is systematic.
- meri_dian 9y agoI agree with you. The institutions should be held to a high standard, and there should be people to hold them accountable. However there are many people, many people on HN who, if asked, would say that our institutions are fundamentally broken or, as a comment elsewhere on this post says, a "discriminatory clusterfuck". My point is that this is a skewed and biased understanding of reality produced by constantly being fed negative news. Are our institutions perfect? Obviously not. Is there room for improvement? Of course! But do most people who interact with our institutions get treated fairly and according to the letter of the law, a law that itself is for the most part fair and just? I believe so.
- jwfxpr 9y agoSeeing this appearing alongside "How poverty changes your mindset"[0] on the front page helps to explain why the issues covered in both articles are so problematic. [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16461773 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16461773
- dadkins 9y agoBoth this article and the ACLU report it's based upon are ridiculously misleading. You don't get arrested for owing a debt. You get a bench warrant issued for not showing up to court when you've been ordered to do so. Debt collectors sue to get a court judgement against people who won't otherwise pay, so they can use the power of the state to garnish wages, levy bank accounts, etc. It's no surprise that they win in court. The debts are usually valid. It doesn't help debtors' cases when they don't show up. Then they get a default judgement. Even with a judgement against you, you still won't get arrested for not paying. But if you don't, the creditor can then request a debtor's examination to which the court requires you to show up. At the examination, you'll be asked about your assets and income, so the creditor knows how to collect by force. What happens if you don't show up to a debtor's examination? The creditor can ask the judge for a bench warrant against you. What happens next depends on the state and county. Sometimes the sheriff knocks on your door and gives you a piece of paper telling you to come to court, or else. Sometimes they do nothing until you get pulled over for some other reason and the warrant comes up. In any case, what's happening to some people is that they're being sued over debts they owe, not showing up to court to defend themselves, getting default judgements against them, still not paying, getting summoned to court for a debtor's examination, not showing up for that, and then getting a bench warrant issued. If you don't show up for jury duty, the judge can issue a bench warrant. They probably won't, but they can. If you get subpoenaed and don't show up, bench warrant. All this is to say that far from the courts criminalizing debt or being manipulated by debt collectors, they are simply acting in their capacity to enforce civil judgements. You know, the seventh amendment? Suits at common law?
- lukev 9y agoNothing you just said is at odds with the article. The problem is that people are spending time in jail (via the process you describe) because of civil debts that can fall into one of the following categories: (a) debts of small sums (b) with insufficient evidence that a debt is actually owed (apparently hoping that the defendant won't be able to competently defend themselves.) (c) with insufficient notice to the defendant (apparently, this is the plaintiff's responsibility in some jurisdictions.) (d) with insufficient consideration for the defendant's situation (i.e, physical or mental disability, single parents that cannot afford childcare, etc.) It seems self evident that these situations are unjust and that reforming the process is desirable, wouldn't you agree?
- vermooten 9y agoDebt collection companies in the US have hijacked ....